Jump to content

Unbreakable Records????


waroriole

Recommended Posts

Part of what makes baseball such a great game is the way we can compare stats of players today to players of the past. Now, this is an inexact science as the game has evolved over time, but it is still fun to look at. Here are, IMO, the most unbreakable baseball records. The percentages are just an estimation.

PITCHING

Wins - Cy Young -511

- This would take 25 years of 20 wins per year, and then 11 more wins.

- IMO, the type of pitcher who has the best chance to break this record is a guy with the greatest knuckleball we've ever seen. This pitcher would have to come into the big leagues very early. As an example he would have to pitch from age 21 until age 46.

- Odds of breaking the record- .000001%

Strikeouts - Nolan Ryan - 5,714

- This would take 19 years of 300 K's per year, plus 14 K's.

- This pitcher would have to be big, strong, durable and throw very hard. (Just like Ryan himself). He would have to have at least one other plus-plus pitch and have a desire to play a very long career. Basically, there would have to be another Nolan Ryan.

- Odds of breaking the record - 1-2%

Complete Games - Cy Young - 749

- This would take 25 years at 30 complete games per year.

- Nobody can do it, it's just impossible. Only 3 pitchers (Young, Ryan, & Don Sutton) have ever started more than 749 games.

- Odds of breaking the record - 0% (actually less than that).:D

Shutouts - Walter Johnson - 110

- 5 shutouts a year for 22 years.

- Sabathia had 5 shutouts tis year in a very dominant season. Sabathia, Dontrelle Willis, and A.J. Burnett are the only pitchers this century to record 5 shutouts in a season.

- Odds of breaking the record - .0001

BATTING

Hits - Pete Rose - 4,256

- 21 years at 200 hits per year, plus 56.

- If Ichiro had began his MLB career at age 20, he could have an outside shot. Unfortunately, he was 27 when he began playing and has only an outside chance at 3,000. This would take a hitter in Ichiro's mold (slap hitter who doesn't walk much) and there just aren't any now.

- Odds of breaking the record - 2-4%

Stolen Bases - Ricky Henderson - 1,406

- 20 years at 70 SB's per year, plus 6

- Only 2 players this century have had 70 SB's in a season (Jose Reyes & Scott Posednik). This would take another player like Ricky, and he is certainly one of a kind. It is possible that SB's become more important in this post-steroid era, but with the attention that Moneyball has got they are seen as more of a risk.

- Odds of breaking the record - < 1%

Career Batting Average - Ty Cobb - .366

- Entire career of .366 average.

- Only 4 players this century have had a batting average over .366 in one season (Ichiro, Barry Bonds, Todd Helton & Nomar) and nobody has done it more than once. Tony Gwynn, considered the best batting average hitter of my generation has a career average of .338, 28 points lower than Cobb. This would almost certainly take someone would could hit over .400 mulitple times; something that nobody has done in 67 years.

- Odds of breaking the record - < 1%

Consecutive Games Played - Cal Ripken Jr. - 2,632

- This would take playing 162 games a year for 16.25 years.

- A player would have to play every game from age 21 to age 37 without taking the day off. No injuries, no minor problems that keep you out of the lineup, no prolonged slumps that cause the manager to give you a day off. The more I think about this record the more impressive it is.:clap3:

- Odds of breaking - .001%

What is your most unbreakable record?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Batting average in a season. I think the all-time record is .424, but don't quote me on that. I would say not even breaking this record is impossible, but a player actually hitting .400 is very unlikely. Still possible, but very unlikely.

You also have to say DiMaggio's 56 game hitting streak.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You also have to say DiMaggio's 56 game hitting streak.

To me this is very possible. People have got into the 30's and 40's with hitting streaks. From there, you just need 15-20 games. Of course, the media scrutiny would be absurd, but I still think that is very possible. Not likely, but I say 10-15% chance of it being broken in my lifetime.

Wins in a season: 41 - Jack Chesbro (1904)

This won't happen, nobody even makes that many starts in a season anymore.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

To me this is very possible. People have got into the 30's and 40's with hitting streaks. From there, you just need 15-20 games. Of course, the media scrutiny would be absurd, but I still think that is very possible. Not likely, but I say 10-15% chance of it being broken in my lifetime.

Maybe not impossible, but I think the %age chance is much less. Players have gotten (rather) close, but to go all the way, and the IMMENSE media pressure of today, make it seem very unlikely to me.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Cy Young is THE record never to be broken pitcher...

Wins = 511

Losses = 316

Innings = 7354.2

Complete Games = 749

Games Started = 815

Yeah, it really isn't fair to include him in the records list. All of these will never be approached, just a different game now. Still, just think of the work his arm put out and it doesn't even seem possible.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yeah, it really isn't fair to include him in the records list. All of these will never be approached, just a different game now. Still, just think of the work his arm put out and it doesn't even seem possible.

:eek: Yeah really! It's why the greatest award in pitching is named after him. What he did is just hard to even fathom today.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

:eek: Yeah really! It's why the greatest award in pitching is named after him. What he did is just hard to even fathom today.

Have you ever seen a scouting report on him. I'm interested to know what kind of stuff he had. Did he throw hard, did he have breaking pitches, was he a control guy?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.



  • Posts

    • You guys that are worrying about blocking guys crack me up. If you aren’t adding in free agency you aren’t trying to win now. Besides the Os don’t have 7 allstar ballplayers coming up in the next 2 or 3 year.
    • Going from Mullins to Kiermaier is a downgrade and there is no proof that Cowser has anywhere close to the range of Mullins.   Better to keep Mullins and sign a FA starter. Stowers and Cowser will push Santander and Hays for playing time  in the near future but not quite yet.    I like the depth they provide.   Did you see how injuries hit Tampa last year?
    • Yes, they can.  But could they improve more by downgrading somewhat in CF to get a pitcher who’s a better option than anyone available on the FA market, age, health, ability and cost all considered?   That’s the question.   I’m not saying the answer is clear, but that is what Elias & co. need to consider.   And it depends on what Mullins would bring back and what the alternatives are in CF.   Trade Mullins straight up for Lopez and sign Kiermaier until Cowser is ready?   I am not crazy about that one.  But there could be some similar scenario that works.  
    • There are many ways to improve.  In my opinion starting pitching is our greatest weakness.  If we can trade from our strengths, position players, to enhance our pitching staff, then do it if the right deal came along.  I'd be willing to part with about any position player on our mlb roster other than Adley and Gunnar.  If Mullins is our most valuable trade piece on the roster, then trade him for pitching.  I feel we have enough young talent coming up to replace his production in the lineup. Let's be clear, I'm not advocating a firesale or anything goofy. But with Westburg, Ortiz, Stowers, Cowser, etc all possibly seeing MLB time this year and hopefully outperforming who they replace in the lineup, and a full year of Gunnar and Adley, I expect the runs scored to increase even if we don't add bats from free agency.  But it's the arms that worry me as Grod only 1 starter and will be limited on pitches.  I'm ok with trading a position starter if we can get a worthwhile pitcher, and Mullins may be the best chip to play.   And given that I'm down on him repeating a 3.8 WAR season or better in 2023, he'd be at the top of my list.  We will get more for him than we would for a Hays, Mateo or Urias.
    • But the O's can keep Mullins, improve at other positions and have a better team.
    • I think Carlos Rodon just makes too much sense. That’s the guy I would be targeting.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...