Jump to content

A very random question


Pedro Cerrano

Recommended Posts

Why can so many ballplayers throw righty but hit lefty, but you rarely see a guy who throws lefty hit righty? Some guys that throw righty and bat exclusively lefty that come to mind, just off the top of my head, include Robinson Cano. And it seems like every switch hitter in history throws right handed. Other than Rickey Henderson, I can't think of any player that throws lefty and hits righty.

A bit of a background. I am left handed, but I've always hit righty, it just felt more normal. The other day, as a joke I decided to try hitting lefty in the cage and while it felt insanely awkward, I was driving the ball a little better. That's what led to this question. Is it something biological? What makes hitting "lefty" batting from that side of the batters' box? Is it because your left hand is your guide hand when hitting lefty? Or because you drive off your left leg? Both?

Any info would be appreciated.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 33
  • Created
  • Last Reply
I throw lefty but hit righty. I golf righty, play guitar righty, shoot guns and bows lefty.

What do you write with?

I write and throw lefty, eat lefty (Lord do I eat lefty haha). But I also play golf and hockey righty, which is generally an extension of my right-handed hitting

I've never shot a gun but on arcade games I "aim" with my right hand and pull the trigger with my left hand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

What do you write with?

I write and throw lefty, eat lefty (Lord do I eat lefty haha). But I also play golf and hockey righty, which is generally an extension of my right-handed hitting.

I've never shot a gun but on arcade games I "aim" with my right hand and pull the trigger with my right hand.

I write lefty. What you described is shooting a rifle righty. Your trigger finger is the dominant hand.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another thing I've never gotten. Wouldn't guitar playing be reversed? It's easier to strum than to grip chords right? So it makes sense that I'd use my left hand to grip the chords. What the hell did Hendrix know anyway?

Both hands have an important job with guitar. Gripping chords is difficult to do with your non-dominant hand, but so is making strum patterns or, even worse, plucking individual strings.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Why is it more advantageous? Because there are more righty pitchers? What about the shift and the fact that a ton of lefties can't hit left-handed pitchers a lick.

Yes. The shift isn't a righty/lefty specific tool, even if it was, it has only recently come into vogue.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes. The shift isn't a righty/lefty specific tool, even if it was, it has only recently come into vogue.

Sure it is, shifting the infield to the left for a righty doesn't make sense because a guy playing that far into the OF grass wouldn't be able to throw the runner out in time.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Sure it is, shifting the infield to the left for a righty doesn't make sense because a guy playing that far into the OF grass wouldn't be able to throw the runner out in time.

You can certainly shift defenders if you have a right handed pull hitter up. It doesn't work to the extent that it does against a lefty but the principal is the same.

Kinda a moot point since shifts of that sort were rare before the last couple seasons.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My parents tried to force me to be right-handed even though I'm naturally lefty. As a result, I:

write right

eat switch

throw left

bat right

golf right

tennis left

kick left/switch

shoot pistol left

shoot rifle right

pull bowstring right

Regarding batting sports (bat, golf, tennis) a right-handed batting and golf swing is similar to a left-handed tennis backhand, so depending on what you consider proper swing mechanics to be, it may be easier to bat right-handed if you have a good left-handed tennis backhand.

Also, baseball selects for pitchers to pitch lefty, batters to bat lefty, and fielders to throw righty. Thus, you're more likely to see players that throw righty and bat lefty due to this selection tendency.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




  • Posts

    • The orioles will probably have around 38 guys on the 40 man by the rule 5 draft. If you’re taking more guys off of it then you need to put more players on. There aren’t that many options to add that I see a situation where bubble guys like Zimmerman are left off and bubble guys like Handley aren’t added. 
    • The MLB Pipeline podcast yesterday (either Callis or Jason Ratliff) said it was the longest HR he's seen hit at the Scottsdale Stadium.
    • I think he's a guy who protect if you have a spot, but if you need one for a better player, then I'd be ok with him being dropped off. There's a lot more guys who can go before him. His .317 wOBA (10th best on the team) is just a little over major league average of .310 and that was after a pretty bad second half where as Frobby pointed out, he may have just worn down.  He's a decent 6th inning guy or the guy you bring in for two when you are up or down by 3 or more. If you can find something better then he can be replaced, but he's not a guy I'd focus on getting rid of this season. There have been flashes a brilliance with, but he's coming up on 30-years old which again, makes him a low end bubble guy for me.
    • I'd sign them both next year. Goal needs to be something like 10 more years with Gunnar. 7-8 with Adley. Give or take. But there'd be no doubt they are cornerstones if I was the owner.
    • If we had a 23 year old 1B prospect in AAA who put up an .860 OP with 27 homers and 106 RBI,  would you be ok with giving him a chance?
    • If Diaz is not DFA'd I'd be shocked. I suppose he could be a throw in player in some deal, but if he's on the 40-man roster when the Rule 5 draft occurs I'll be shocked. He's a guy who can't stay healthy and probably needs a change of scenery and even then, the hit tool have not improved and he still has very little plan at the plate.
    • Boy did Severino not come close to that 205 innings mark very often! lol True Roberts has improved a bit with his receiving and i have no idea how either of them frame balls though from watching, seems like Handley is pretty good and stealing strikes though AA umpires can be wildly inconsistent so that's tough to judge. Either way, as I showed, Handley bat should play better overall.  For me, Handley is 40 level prospect while Roberts is a 35.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...