Jump to content

MLB Network: Belanger. The best Shortstop


weams

Recommended Posts

9 hours ago, Frobby said:

Everything’s relative.    Belanger was incredibly smooth, always in the right place, and could get a strong throw off incredibly quickly. He rarely laid out for a ball and scrambled to his feet the way Ozzie Smith and the great defensive shortstops who followed did.   I haven’t watched the film yet, but I’m hoping they have some good footage of vintage Belanger.   

Crazy talk: in Belanger's era, nobody provided more jaw-dropping plays from SS. There was nothing flashier about Ozzie Smith defensively than Blade; only the pre-game flips were flashier -- if you want to count that. I can't see how a dive and pop up throw is flashier than the gymnastic plays Belanger trademarked. Ozzie never threw out runners deep in the hole like Blade did; Belanger knew that the only chance to throw them out was not to dive and pop up to throw. I think you must be getting your wires crossed and mixing up your cherished memories of Ed Brinkman with Belanger.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My favorite quotes (as best as I can remember) about Belanger: "He didn't even wear a cup.  His hands were that good".  From Brooks - "When there was a high popup, we all just stood around and waited for Belanger to get it".  From guys in front of me at Memorial Stadium with runners on and Belanger up next.  The first guy says "Belanger's due".  His buddy says "Belanger's always due".

I recall Ozzy being flashier than Belanger, but I saw Belanger many, many times, and I just saw highlights and occasional games with Ozzie.  Belanger seemed to make all of the plays.  You had to see him often to truly appreciate him.  Hot smashes and bad hops that ate up other infielders were routine plays for the the blade. He made tough plays look easy.  You got used to seeing him make the tough plays seemingly without max effort, so maybe that's why he isn't remembered as flashy.

With Belanger and Brooks, Chuck Thompson and Bill O'Donnell would remark about how it was hardly worth it to try to hit a ball to their side of the infield.  Few balls ever got through.  It was truly a special time to watch defense in Baltimore, and you also had Paul Blair making plays in the outfield. 

  • Upvote 3
Link to comment
Share on other sites

With the conversation between modern players and players from past generations, we find difficulties. Obviously, as has been mentioned, previous generations did not face competition like today. For this reason many would say that today's players are the greatest ever. I wonder though, if players like Honus Wagner had access to all of the modern training and other "supplements", including being trained from preschool, how they might rank going up against today's players.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm glad this is getting a larger audience. I bought the DVD directly from the filmmaker when it was first available. There's a thread on it somewhere. I don't know who started that thread, but it's where  I learned about it. I'm thinking it was from 2018. 

 

Edit: YeOleDugger started a thread on the making of the film. 

 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, DanS said:

My favorite quotes (as best as I can remember) about Belanger: "He didn't even wear a cup.  His hands were that good".  From Brooks - "When there was a high popup, we all just stood around and waited for Belanger to get it".  From guys in front of me at Memorial Stadium with runners on and Belanger up next.  The first guy says "Belanger's due".  His buddy says "Belanger's always due".

I recall Ozzy being flashier than Belanger, but I saw Belanger many, many times, and I just saw highlights and occasional games with Ozzie.  Belanger seemed to make all of the plays.  You had to see him often to truly appreciate him.  Hot smashes and bad hops that ate up other infielders were routine plays for the the blade. He made tough plays look easy.  You got used to seeing him make the tough plays seemingly without max effort, so maybe that's why he isn't remembered as flashy.

With Belanger and Brooks, Chuck Thompson and Bill O'Donnell would remark about how it was hardly worth it to try to hit a ball to their side of the infield.  Few balls ever got through.  

My favorite quote was from Detroit manager Mayo Smith, who said trying to hit a ball through the left side of the Oriole infield was “like trying to throw a hamburger through a brick wall.”

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

I'm hoping for more footage, too.  I've never really seen much to begin with.  There has to be some out there.  Obviously televised baseball wasn't huge back then but there's gotta be some clips somewhere.

On a similar note, my knowledge of Brooks' defensive prowess is limited to highlights of the 1970 World Series.

I've seen it (I own the DVD). There's not as much game footage as I had expected.You may be in for a let down in that regard.  There actually may be more on YouTube just from watching the '69 and '70 World Series.  But it's still very worth your time.  A lot of the focus is on his upbringing, his high school basketball heroics (he was legendary in that part of the state) and maybe not a total surprise, quite a bit on his post baseball career. It really focuses more on his life story and where he came from. 

Btw, I hurried through this thread and not sure if anyone caught this. I saw the local paper of his region write about this and Dan Duquette was instrumental in getting this on the Network. 

 

"Dastoli said that getting the documentary on the MLB Network was made possible by two Taconic High School graduates, Dan Duquette and Mike Ryan.

"Dan had seen the film. He didn't go to the premiere party [at the Boland Theatre at Berkshire Community College] in 2018," Dastoli said. "Once Dan saw it, he knew that Mike could help us out with Mike's background in programming at ESPN." "

 

https://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/documentary-on-berkshires-native-belanger-to-air-on-mlb-network,613421?

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, NashLumber said:

I've seen it (I own the DVD). There's not as much game footage as I had expected.You may be in for a let down in that regard.  There actually may be more on YouTube just from watching the '69 and '70 World Series.  But it's still very worth your time.  A lot of the focus is on his upbringing, his high school basketball heroics (he was legendary in that part of the state) and maybe not a total surprise, quite a bit on his post baseball career. It really focuses more on his life story and where he came from. 

Btw, I hurried through this thread and not sure if anyone caught this. I saw the local paper of his region write about this and Dan Duquette was instrumental in getting this on the Network. 

 

"Dastoli said that getting the documentary on the MLB Network was made possible by two Taconic High School graduates, Dan Duquette and Mike Ryan.

"Dan had seen the film. He didn't go to the premiere party [at the Boland Theatre at Berkshire Community College] in 2018," Dastoli said. "Once Dan saw it, he knew that Mike could help us out with Mike's background in programming at ESPN." "

 

https://www.berkshireeagle.com/stories/documentary-on-berkshires-native-belanger-to-air-on-mlb-network,613421?

 

Sorry to hear there’s not much footage, but it still sounds like something I’d enjoy watching.  And  kudos to Duquette for helping to get this on the air.     

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Belanger has a strong case as the best defensive SS of all time.  In Total Zone Runs, Ozzie Smith noses him out 239 to 238, both far ahead of the no. 3 spot (held by Cal at 176).    But Ozzie played about 40% more innings at SS than Belanger, so on a per game basis, Belanger easily wins.   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • Johnson isn't on the 40 man roster so a promotion would involve some juggling there. Also, while his .920 OPS looks impressive please keep in mind that Ryan McKenna's career OPS at Norfolk was .915. I liked the energy Johnson brought to his game during Spring Training, reminded me a lot of Gunnar's attitude. While I'm not sure he'd be any more valuable on paper than McKenna was, I'm certainly willing to give chances to guys that play the game balls to the wall like he did. 
    • I doubt there is anything in the Union contract preventing MLB from using an electronic strike zone. So long as no umpires are let go or reduced in pay they would have no cause for a grievance or work stoppage. The issue for them would simply be the blow to their ego as they would lose influence over the games that they're used to having. Boo hoo.  IMO the critical reason for MLB to establish an electronic strike zone would be to eliminate the chances of a gambling scandal involving a home plate umpire going rogue in order to change the outcome of the game. I doubt a Black Sox like conspiracy could occur these days simply because players make so much money that it wouldn't make sense for a group of them to throw a game. But a single corrupt umpire calling balls and strikes in a big game could have an enormous influence on the final score. Ask the '97 Braves. Robo-umps would do away with such a possibility forever. 
    • I didn't want to say it, but since your brought it up.....I agree.   I have been involved in the fitness industry as both a person who has worked out with heavy weights for years, a company level as I used to own a supplement company, and a social media level as I know many of the social influencers involved in the fitness industry.   I can tell you that squatting that amount and even further dead lifting that amount, even for a fervent power lifter is very very rare.  Let alone for someone who weighs 180 pounds like JH, who is worth many millions,  and what makes it even more unlikely is there is no way IN H E L L that the O's brass is going to let him try and DL 700 pounds.  We are talking snap city when it comes to the back DLing that amount.  Just no way he could even do that based on his build, which is ok but nothing great.  Plus even IF he could, the Os would never let him.    End of story.   Here is one of the stronger guys I know on you tube who is around JH's weight, actually 10 pounds more, and it took years and years of training to DL 600 pounds for him.   Yet somehow a guy with JHs build is Deadlifting 700 at the age of 20?  Righttttttt lol.      
    • I'm looking at the Rays record over the past decade and I'm a bit confused over your definition of "have not won much". However, my argument is simple - teams that don't invest in payroll don't win championships in baseball. Over the past 21 years (I was going to do 20, but added the extra to include Florida's win in 2003), the average payroll position relative to the league of the eventual WS champ was 9th (see below) Year WS Champ OD Payroll rank 2003 FLA 25 2004 BOS 2 2005 CWS 13 2006 STL 11 2007 BOS 2 2008 PHI 12 2009 NYY 1 2010 SF 10 2011 STL 11 2012 SF 8 2013 BOS 4 2014 SF 7 2015 KC 16 2016 CHC 14 2017 HOU 18 2018 BOS 1 2019 WAS 7 2020 LAD 2 2021 ATL 13 2022 HOU 11 2023 TEX 9   Only three of these teams had payrolls in the bottom half of league: Florida in 2003 had by far the lowest payroll, at 25th. Their payroll climbed to as high as 18th over the next couple of years, but they couldn't maintain their success and haven't made the playoffs since, outside of the COVID season. KC in 2015 had the 16th lowest payroll, barely below the median payroll for the year. They haven't been back to the playoffs since. Houston in 2017 had the 18th lowest payroll. This was their big breakthrough year after their tanking/rebuild, and they haven't been lower than 11th since, and as high as 4th.   The trend is obvious. After the Marlins' miracle run in 2003, no team has won the WS with a payroll lower than 18th, and that team (Houston) is an obvious outlier as they were in the basically the same spot as the O's now (on the upswing from a full tear-down). While KC and Florida both had years where everything came together perfectly, they were unable to sustain their momentum. The O's were 23rd in payroll on Opening Day, and the current roster is good enough to win a championship, but history suggests they'll go the way of Florida and Kansas City if Rubenstein isn't willing to invest in the payroll. Consistently letting the talent drain out of your organization because you aren't willing to pay them won't lead to multiple championships and it won't keep fans engaged.
    • Correlation vs. Causation: The study states that there is a correlation between 1RM (one-rep max) squat and performance metrics like the 10-yard split and 40-yard dash times. However, correlation does not imply causation. Just because these variables are correlated does not mean that one causes the other.   
    • I think he's claimed and right away.
    • His Dad is a big boy and obvious lifter.  Some guys are naturally good squatters.  That’s an impressive number for Holliday, but who knows exactly how legit the actual squat is.  You can find high school kids at nearly every high school about his size with similar squat numbers.  Granted, they will be some of the strongest pound for pound kids, but it’s not a crazy number. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...