Jump to content

vs. RED SOX 5/21


OFFNY

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 483
  • Created
  • Last Reply
What part of what Hunter did there should be allowed?

Honestly, I think there needs to be an overhaul as it pertains to situation. And to some extent, intent, though I realize that there is no way to prove intent, but in that situation, what he did was more of a mental screwup than any move designed to deceive the runner. Not that what he did would actually deceive the runner, especially one on third.

I just really hate the balk rules. I don't disagree that there should be balk rules, because letting the pitcher deceive the runners willy nilly is obviously not fair. But a lot of the stuff that falls under the umbrella of a balk would never actually deceive the runner. And maybe that actually wasn't one, but when I see something that really seems to me to be more of a pitcher whoopsy instead of a move thats meant to deceive (or worse yet, when a runner tricks the pitcher, wheres the parity in that??) it makes me lament again how much the balk rules just need to be re-examined.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't care about Sox homerism. I'm just curious why he thinks Ortiz is a sure-fire HOFer.

Because any fact based, non Bosox cheer leader announcer can see clearly Pappi is a shoe-in first ballot HOFer. :laughlol::D
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Because any fact based, non Bosox cheer leader announcer can see clearly Pappi is a shoe-in first ballot HOFer. :laughlol::D

Yeah, like Gary Thorne is alone in the world in considering Ortiz a shoe in HOF'er. Again, people hear what they want to hear.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • Yes, I think that would be a solution that just might work. If you doubled the number of MLB teams it might take a decade or two for talent to catch back up. One of the reasons many strategies of 100 or 150 years ago worked was a much lower talent level, and much bigger spread between the best and worst MLB players. Even just going back 50 years or so it's clear to me one of the reasons pitchers could throw 300 innings was a much shallower pool of hitters, or at the very least choices that favored .220 hitting shortstops with no power. But, what do you think the odds are of Major League Baseball expanding to 60 teams in the next decade? 0.001%? 0.0000001%? The owners would look at such a proposal as an idea for how to slash their shared revenues by 50%, and would probably rather spend the last 20 years of their life fighting it in court than let that happen. This is like the discussions I have with soccer fans on promotion/relegation in the US. Great idea, tremendous benefits, works beautifully in the rest of the world, fosters all kinds of local grassroots interest in the sport, punishes tanking. But current owners would rather gouge their eyes out with their thumbnails than implement it here.
    • I only watched the first two innings.  I didn’t think he’d last much longer because he looked very hittable to that point.  I really question the pitch selection to Rorthsveldt on a 1-2 pitch with a man on third and one out.  He just swung threw a up in the zone fastball, Suarez’ best pitch.  Throw another one same spot, or higher, or in, or even try to bury a changeup low.  Anything to try and get a swing and miss.  But a two seamer (that’s what they called it) down and away? Credit to Suarez for giving us 5.  I don’t really think he’s a starter but he’s getting it done.  Why can he hit 97 in the first inning but not in relief?   I guess it’s a warmup thing.  The 2023-24 Orioles are very good at “winning ugly”.   They find a way more often than not.
    • I hadn’t heard an up to date report on Gillen’s arm.  He’s two years out from that surgery so that’s certainly not good.   I like Lindsey too.  The only real drawbacks are that he’s a RH hitter and the power projection is questionable but he’s got top of the line speed. I’m really not interested in the hit first college types like Amick.   I’d like to see them go HS position player or roll the dice on a Brody Brecht/Jonathan Santucci college pitcher with big stuff and command issues.   At #22 and #32 maybe they can do both.
    • We've really needed Suarez to step up, and so far he has. He does this a couple more times, I might be a believer.
    • Been going downhill ever since Roy started calling for him in the pen. The jinx goes both ways.
    • Suarez traveled 🧳 a long road to arrive with the Orioles . I can’t help but root for him to succeed this season 
    • Before the season, I was one in trade Mateo camp . He only played SS , but with Gunnar locking up SS , I was not sure about his value anymore. But when he started playing at Second and CF , he looked like he picking up at these positions.  I think maybe he should be their utility player now. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...