Jump to content

Astros punishment unveiled...


Absltgreek

Recommended Posts

Just now, dtk9119 said:

How is Mike Elias not affected by all of this? He worked for Luhnow and from what I've heard, the entire front office knew about the cheating. Ive not seen Elias mentioned anywhere in the breaking news.. At least explaining why he will not be penalized or not.

After having read the report it seemed pretty clear the baseball operations department didn't know or wasn't involved. There were no indications or mentions that Mike or Sig were anywhere close to being involved.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Absltgreek said:

After having read the report it seemed pretty clear the baseball operations department didn't know or wasn't involved. There were no indications or mentions that Mike or Sig were anywhere close to being involved.

I am sure they knew. Many in baseball had a good idea what was going on. But direct involvement probably not.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Absltgreek said:

Wow, multiple Tweets including Rosenthal that Jim Crane has fired both Luhnow and Hinch.

 

https://twitter.com/Ken_Rosenthal/status/1216813978988490752

MLBTR said it has happened. Astros might fall fast. Glad they had that few year run. The farm system was going down and now losing draft picks.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Seems too light.  Luhnow and Hinch should have gotten more.  This won't stop managers from cheating.  If you only get 1 year out of the game.  I am fine with the draft pick loses punishment but managers trying to keep their job won't be stopped by a slap on the wrist 1 year punishment.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 minutes ago, atomic said:

I think as an assistant, knowing about it and not being part of it is going to save you from punishment.  

There is no mention of Elias. Or Sig. Who quit the Astros with no job and went back to corporate work.  I assume at some point both were made aware. These are not dumb men. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • Great post.  I like your optimism, and I'll try to believe this team can turn things around just in the nick of time like some classic Hollywood baseball movie.
    • I think Elias has mostly done an excellent job with one exception -- he seems like he treats the bullpen like an afterthought.  I doubt that will happen again this coming offseason. I don't really blame him for the current offensive struggles overall.  Just too many injuries late in the season.  That said I don't understand how we went from dealing Austin Hays, Connor Norby and Ryan McKenna just so we could land the right handed bat of, gulp, Austin Slater.  
    • Man this team has no shot. Right now they may not even make it. 
    • Most of these guys are only playing because of injuries to starters.  But Austin Slater I'm guessing was brought in to replace the traded Austin Hays.  The problem is that Slater has shown little ability to hit lefties this year, after hitting them pretty well up to this season.  This must be why two teams dropped him before the O's picked him up.  I know he was let go much earlier in the season, but is Ryan McKenna actually worse than this guy?  I don't understand how the front office went from releasing McKenna to later trading Hays and Norby -- thinking their right handed bats could adequately be replaced by someone like Slater.  
    • I'm willing to give Elias some rope because of the strict limitations he was under with JA but he better not be so damn conservative again this year and let every serviceable FA out there sign with other teams while he's busy picking up reclamation projects again. Minus Burns of course.  
    • I agree completely that it’s irrelevant whether it worked.  But I don’t agree that bunting is clearly the right decision in either scenario, and I think that decision gets worse if it’s intended to be a straight sacrifice rather than a bunt for a hit. To be clear, the outcome you’re seeking in tonight’s situation, for example — sacrifice the runners over to 2nd/3rd — lowers both your run expectancy for the inning (from 1.44 to 1.39) and your win expectancy for the game (from 38.8% to 37.1%). It increases the likelihood of scoring one run, but it decreases the likelihood of scoring two runs (which you needed to tie) and certainly of scoring three or more runs (which you needed to take the lead).  And that’s if you succeed in getting them to 2nd/3rd. Research indicates that 15-30% of sacrifice bunt attempts fail, so you have to bake in a pretty significant percentage of the time that you’d just be giving up a free out (or even just two free strikes, as on Sunday). The bunt attempt in the 3rd inning on Sunday (which my gut hates more than if they’d done it today) actually is less damaging to the win probability — decreasing it only very slightly from 60.2% to 59.8%. More time left in the game to make up for giving up outs, I guess, and the scoreboard payoff is a bit better (in the sense that at least you’d have a better chance to take the lead).   At the bottom of it, these things mostly come down to gut and pure chance. The percentages are rarely overwhelming in either direction, and so sometimes even a “lower-percentage” play may work better under some circumstances. You would have bunted both times. I wouldn’t have bunted either time. Hyde bunted one time but not the other. I don’t know that anyone is an idiot (or even clearly “wrong”) for their preference. Either approach could have worked. Sadly, none of them actually did.
    • Wasn't Hyde always thought of more or less as a caretaker? I'm on the fence about him coming back. I totally get the injuries and that needs to be taking into consideration but man this collapse some heads have to roll who's I'm  mot sure 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...