Underrated and Overrated player on OH

[maybenxtyr]

We should bump this thread in June when everyone's crying about how he should be our lone all-star representative.

I think this will be the year for him to break-out. Buck will have a chance to put a pretty good line-up out each night, and certain players will benefit from where they bat in the order. I know some folks think batting position does not matter, but I think for some players it does.

[Eddie_Ripken]

We should bump this thread in June when everyone's crying about how he should be our lone all-star representative.

+1

Pickles

[RavensNTerps]

Does Casey Kotchman count?

[clarence]

I was going to vote for the left side of our infield with Gordon and Wood as being overrated.

[ThisIsOurHouse]

How is Markakis overrated on the OH if everyone does not like him in the first place?

Overrated- Most free agent threads (Beltre)

Underrated- Markakis, he is so grounded on this site that people forget what he actually does well (Get on base, great defense). He will put 20+ HR's this year and be selected in his first AS game.

[Tank]

Underrated: Chris Tillman

Overrated: Jake Arrieta

[sportsfan8703]

Underrated- Guthrie

Overrated- Reimold

[frstbasmn13]

Overrated - Reimold/Pie

Underrated - Wieters/Scott

[OrangeJerseys]

underrated: Tillman, Weiters, Markakis

overrated: Scott, Jones,