Jump to content

MacPhail Coming Back?


brotherlo38

Recommended Posts

I would absolutely hate this move and hope that this isn't what happens, on the other hand I wouldn't mind it simply to see how JTrea would handle the news.

He said that he'll stop following the O's and cease to be a fan of the team if MacPhail was still our GM in 2012. He said that it's him or McPhail.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 179
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Contraction? Really? That's what you jump to?

The best option is Angelos selling the team.

Which may never happen for years and years...

I'm beginning to wonder if contraction and being forced to find a new team would be better for everybody than being loyal to this one and watching it continuously lose.

Then as some suggested, Baltimore could get a relocated team a few years down the road.

In the meantime they could go back to being a AAA franchise like they were before the Browns came to town...

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He said that he'll stop following the O's and cease to be a fan of the team if MacPhail was still our GM in 2012. He said that it's him or McPhail.

Probably an empty threat, IMO.

As for me, I am more interested in what the team does this winter, than which GM does it. I think MacPhail had a pretty good year from Oct. 2010 until the August 2011 trade deadline, despite some mistakes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

And the fanbase. People are so beaten down that they think there is no hope.

If that's the case contraction may truly be the best option...

I agree it is sad...But that "no hope" has been created by Angelos, not AM.

You want to blame AM for everything(and trust me, I am with you on the idea that he isn't any good) but PA is the clear, no doubt about it #1 issue and until he leaves, the Orioles will have to get very lucky to have a shot at contending.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Probably an empty threat, IMO.

As for me, I am more interested in what the team does this winter, than which GM does it. I think MacPhail had a pretty good year from Oct. 2010 until the August 2011 trade deadline, despite some mistakes.

He brought in some nice pieces but really did nothing to help the long term future of the team.

I don't know how that can be characterized as a "pretty good year".

But, again, PA is pulling the strings, so who the hell really knows.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Probably an empty threat, IMO.

As for me, I am more interested in what the team does this winter, than which GM does it. I think MacPhail had a pretty good year from Oct. 2010 until the August 2011 trade deadline, despite some mistakes.

Nope it's not empty. If MacPhail comes back as GM I won't follow this team. You don't invite back one the worst GMs in franchise history in terms of results on the field if you truly care about winning.

And if the Orioles don't care about winning, I'm sick of caring about them.

They don't deserve my support.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nope it's not empty. If MacPhail comes back as GM I won't follow this team. You don't invite back one the worst GMs in franchise history in terms of results on the field if you truly care about winning.

And if the Orioles don't care about winning, I'm sick of caring about them.

Ok..say you stop following and then, AM signs Fielder(I agree this isn't like, this is just a hypothetical)...What do you do then?
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Nope it's not empty. If MacPhail comes back as GM, I won't follow this team. You don't invite back one the worst GMs in franchise history in terms of results on the field if you truly care about winning.

And if the Orioles don't care about winning, I'm sick of caring about them.

They don't deserve my support.

Thank you. Now I don't have to scrounge around the threads to see where you said it previously.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ok..say you stop following and then, AM signs Fielder(I agree this isn't like, this is just a hypothetical)...What do you do then?

Fielder isn't enough. It would have to be the best offseason in franchise history to get me to come back. Otherwise I'm doing something more enjoyable and productive with my life.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Which may never happen for years and years...

I'm beginning to wonder if contraction and being forced to find a new team would be better for everybody than being loyal to this one and watching it continuously lose.

Then as some suggested, Baltimore could get a relocated team a few years down the road.

In the meantime they could go back to being a AAA franchise like they were before the Browns came to town...

images?q=tbn:ANd9GcR_32MtyFruXFwJcoTju0Z4EZMgJ-pNkJeXRK-5-Xeb2bWEEjI4Mg

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • But it doesn't really matter if correlation implies causation, because we can at least infer that people with fast 40 times have a good chance of being able to squat 2.5x their body weight, regardless of whether there is a causative relationship.  And we have verifiable data thay many football players at skill positions are able to squar large amounts of weight that would be out of reach of many other people even given the same amount of training and diet.  So with both if these things in hand we can safely assume that these lifting numbers are achievable for most elite athletes, which Holliday qualifies as.  So I don't think we should be shocked or skeptical that he's able to pull these numbers.    I'd also be shocked if there wasn't a causative relationship between 40 times and lifting heavy.  Lifting large amounts of weight requires powerful muscles in the legs.  Running really fast also requires powerful muscles in the legs.  You can get in the weeds about muscle fiber type but to me if you're good at one, there's a great chance thay you're at least moderately good at the other.
    • Johnson isn't on the 40 man roster so a promotion would involve some juggling there. Also, while his .920 OPS looks impressive please keep in mind that Ryan McKenna's career OPS at Norfolk was .915. I liked the energy Johnson brought to his game during Spring Training, reminded me a lot of Gunnar's attitude. While I'm not sure he'd be any more valuable on paper than McKenna was, I'm certainly willing to give chances to guys that play the game balls to the wall like he did. 
    • I doubt there is anything in the Union contract preventing MLB from using an electronic strike zone. So long as no umpires are let go or reduced in pay they would have no cause for a grievance or work stoppage. The issue for them would simply be the blow to their ego as they would lose influence over the games that they're used to having. Boo hoo.  IMO the critical reason for MLB to establish an electronic strike zone would be to eliminate the chances of a gambling scandal involving a home plate umpire going rogue in order to change the outcome of the game. I doubt a Black Sox like conspiracy could occur these days simply because players make so much money that it wouldn't make sense for a group of them to throw a game. But a single corrupt umpire calling balls and strikes in a big game could have an enormous influence on the final score. Ask the '97 Braves. Robo-umps would do away with such a possibility forever. 
    • I didn't want to say it, but since your brought it up.....I agree.   I have been involved in the fitness industry as both a person who has worked out with heavy weights for years, a company level as I used to own a supplement company, and a social media level as I know many of the social influencers involved in the fitness industry.   I can tell you that squatting that amount and even further dead lifting that amount, even for a fervent power lifter is very very rare.  Let alone for someone who weighs 180 pounds like JH, who is worth many millions,  and what makes it even more unlikely is there is no way IN H E L L that the O's brass is going to let him try and DL 700 pounds.  We are talking snap city when it comes to the back DLing that amount.  Just no way he could even do that based on his build, which is ok but nothing great.  Plus even IF he could, the Os would never let him.    End of story.   Here is one of the stronger guys I know on you tube who is around JH's weight, actually 10 pounds more, and it took years and years of training to DL 600 pounds for him.   Yet somehow a guy with JHs build is Deadlifting 700 at the age of 20?  Righttttttt lol.      
    • I'm looking at the Rays record over the past decade and I'm a bit confused over your definition of "have not won much". However, my argument is simple - teams that don't invest in payroll don't win championships in baseball. Over the past 21 years (I was going to do 20, but added the extra to include Florida's win in 2003), the average payroll position relative to the league of the eventual WS champ was 9th (see below) Year WS Champ OD Payroll rank 2003 FLA 25 2004 BOS 2 2005 CWS 13 2006 STL 11 2007 BOS 2 2008 PHI 12 2009 NYY 1 2010 SF 10 2011 STL 11 2012 SF 8 2013 BOS 4 2014 SF 7 2015 KC 16 2016 CHC 14 2017 HOU 18 2018 BOS 1 2019 WAS 7 2020 LAD 2 2021 ATL 13 2022 HOU 11 2023 TEX 9   Only three of these teams had payrolls in the bottom half of league: Florida in 2003 had by far the lowest payroll, at 25th. Their payroll climbed to as high as 18th over the next couple of years, but they couldn't maintain their success and haven't made the playoffs since, outside of the COVID season. KC in 2015 had the 16th lowest payroll, barely below the median payroll for the year. They haven't been back to the playoffs since. Houston in 2017 had the 18th lowest payroll. This was their big breakthrough year after their tanking/rebuild, and they haven't been lower than 11th since, and as high as 4th.   The trend is obvious. After the Marlins' miracle run in 2003, no team has won the WS with a payroll lower than 18th, and that team (Houston) is an obvious outlier as they were in the basically the same spot as the O's now (on the upswing from a full tear-down). While KC and Florida both had years where everything came together perfectly, they were unable to sustain their momentum. The O's were 23rd in payroll on Opening Day, and the current roster is good enough to win a championship, but history suggests they'll go the way of Florida and Kansas City if Rubenstein isn't willing to invest in the payroll. Consistently letting the talent drain out of your organization because you aren't willing to pay them won't lead to multiple championships and it won't keep fans engaged.
    • Correlation vs. Causation: The study states that there is a correlation between 1RM (one-rep max) squat and performance metrics like the 10-yard split and 40-yard dash times. However, correlation does not imply causation. Just because these variables are correlated does not mean that one causes the other.   
    • I think he's claimed and right away.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...