Jump to content

A 26-Year 26-Man Roster


Jagwar

Recommended Posts

You must choose a 26-man roster from 26 seasons. Here are the rules.

  1. Ignore 2020
  2. Select 13 position players, with 9 starters and 4 bench players
  3. Select 13 pitchers, with 5 starters and 8 relievers
  4. You can only select one player from each season from 1998-2024 (exclude 2020)
  5. You can only select a given player ONCE 
  6. Starting pitchers have to be starting pitchers, relievers have to be relievers

I will amend rules as appropriate from any suggestions you have. Go. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Here is my roster. Wasn't an easy task with some tough decisions

C  Adley Rutschmann 2022
1B Rafaeil Palmeiro 1998
2B Brian Roberts 2009
SS Miguel Tejada 2006
3B Manny Machado 2015
OF Adam Jones 2015
OF Albert Belle 1999
OF Trey Mancini 2017
DH Chris Davis 2013
        
Bench Gunnar Henderson 2024
Bench Melvin Mora 2004
Bench Jay Gibbons 2003
Bench Matt Wieters 2011

---------------------

SP Mike Mussina 2000
SP Jason Johnson 2001
SP Wei-Yen Chen    2014
SP Erik Bedard 2007
SP John Means 2019
        
RP Jorge Julio 2002
RP BJ Ryan 2005
RP Jim Johnson 2012
RP Koji Uehara    2010
RP Zack Britton    2016
RP Felix Bautista 2023
RP Darren O'Day    2014
RP George Sherril 2008
 

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, Jagwar said:

Here is my roster. Wasn't an easy task with some tough decisions

C  Adley Rutschmann 2022
1B Rafaeil Palmeiro 1998
2B Brian Roberts 2009
SS Miguel Tejada 2006
3B Manny Machado 2015
OF Adam Jones 2015
OF Albert Belle 1999
OF Trey Mancini 2017
DH Chris Davis 2013
        
Bench Gunnar Henderson 2024
Bench Melvin Mora 2004
Bench Jay Gibbons 2003
Bench Matt Wieters 2011

---------------------

SP Mike Mussina 2000
SP Jason Johnson 2001
SP Wei-Yen Chen    2014
SP Erik Bedard 2007
SP John Means 2019
        
RP Jorge Julio 2002
RP BJ Ryan 2005
RP Jim Johnson 2012
RP Koji Uehara    2010
RP Zack Britton    2016
RP Felix Bautista 2023
RP Darren O'Day    2014
RP George Sherril 2008
 

Looks pretty good , only changes I start Gunnar at 2nd. Its late For Cal but 1999 version has to be on team even in back up or dh, Bump Roberts. What about Burnes Bradish, Grod?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Safelykept said:

Looks pretty good , only changes I start Gunnar at 2nd. Its late For Cal but 1999 version has to be on team even in back up or dh, Bump Roberts. What about Burnes Bradish, Grod?

My Bad, just now seeing can only use 1 year. Well thought out list.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, Jagwar said:

SS Miguel Tejada 2006    --    move to DH
3B Manny Machado 2015
OF Adam Jones 2015
OF Albert Belle 1999
OF Trey Mancini 2017  --   move to Bench
DH Chris Davis 2013  --  move to OF
        
Bench Gunnar Henderson 2024  --  move to SS

I think that might be better for the starting lineup.     Sorry, Trey...

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

10 minutes ago, Safelykept said:

Looks pretty good , only changes I start Gunnar at 2nd. Its late For Cal but 1999 version has to be on team even in back up or dh, Bump Roberts. What about Burnes Bradish, Grod?

Like I said... tough choices

The worst part about the team is the starting rotation. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

C Wieters 2011

1B Davis 2013

2B Roberts 2005

3B Machado 2015

SS Tejada 2004

LF Anderson 1999

CF Mullins 2021

RF Markakis 2008

Bench Palmeiro 1998

Bench Henderson 2024

Bench Mora 2003

Bench Rutschman 2022

SP Mussina 2000

SP Bedard 2007

SP Bradish 2023

SP Means 2019

SP Guthrie 2010

RP Britton 2016

RP Johnson 2012

RP Groom 2002

RP Ray 2006

RP Trombley 2001

RP Sherrill 2009

RP Givens 2017

RP Bleier 2018

Link to comment
Share on other sites

22 minutes ago, Frobby said:

C Wieters 2011

1B Davis 2013

2B Roberts 2005

3B Machado 2015

SS Tejada 2004

LF Anderson 1999

CF Mullins 2021

RF Markakis 2008

Bench Palmeiro 1998

Bench Henderson 2024

Bench Mora 2003

Bench Rutschman 2022

SP Mussina 2000

SP Bedard 2007

SP Bradish 2023

SP Means 2019

SP Guthrie 2010

RP Britton 2016

RP Johnson 2012

RP Groom 2002

RP Ray 2006

RP Trombley 2001

RP Sherrill 2009

RP Givens 2017

RP Bleier 2018

Bradish for Felix, thats tough but I can see it. I think the Op left out 2018. I love the love for Bleier but 2018 was the year he got hurt, only pitched into June

Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Safelykept said:

Bradish for Felix, thats tough but I can see it. I think the Op left out 2018. I love the love for Bleier but 2018 was the year he got hurt, only pitched into June

I was really grasping for anyone worthwhile in 2018.   Anyone decent was gone by July 31 anyway.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Jagwar said:

Here is my roster. Wasn't an easy task with some tough decisions

C  Adley Rutschmann 2022
1B Rafaeil Palmeiro 1998
2B Brian Roberts 2009
SS Miguel Tejada 2006
3B Manny Machado 2015
OF Adam Jones 2015
OF Albert Belle 1999
OF Trey Mancini 2017
DH Chris Davis 2013
        
Bench Gunnar Henderson 2024
Bench Melvin Mora 2004
Bench Jay Gibbons 2003
Bench Matt Wieters 2011

---------------------

SP Mike Mussina 2000
SP Jason Johnson 2001
SP Wei-Yen Chen    2014
SP Erik Bedard 2007
SP John Means 2019
        
RP Jorge Julio 2002
RP BJ Ryan 2005
RP Jim Johnson 2012
RP Koji Uehara    2010
RP Zack Britton    2016
RP Felix Bautista 2023
RP Darren O'Day    2014
RP George Sherril 2008
 

I am little confused I thought it said only 1 player from each year.  You have Manny and Jones 2015.  Then two guys 2014.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was a tough challenge. 

 

C Adley 2022
C Charles Johnson 2000
SS Gunnar 2024
3B Cal 1999
2B Schoop 2017
1B Davis 2014
UTIL Tejada 2006


CF Cedric 2021
LF Markakis 2008
RF 2012 Adam Jones
DH/OF Luke Scott 2010
DH/1B David Segui 2001
OF Luis Matos 2005 (defense sub)

CL Britton 2016
RHP Koji 2011
RHP O'Day 2013
RHP Sherrill 2009
LHP Bleier 2018 (good call Frobby)
LHP Groom 2002

SP1 Mussina 1998
SP2 Bedard 2007
SP3 Bradish 2023
SP4 Chen 2015
SP5 Rodrigo Lopez 2004
RHP Ponson 2003
LHP Means 2019

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That was a lot of fun. Felt like there are certain elite seasons that had to be part of the team, and then tried to build from there. 

Outfield depth is a little shaky, as is the rotation — though the latter is probably mostly unavoidable. The lineup would rake and the bullpen would shove, so pretty happy with this combination.

 

C 2022 Adley Rutschman (5.4 rWAR)

1B: 1998 Rafael Palmeiro (6.3)

2B: 2005 Brian Roberts (7.3)

3B: 2015 Manny Machado (7.5)

SS: 2024 Gunnar Henderson (8.9)

LF: 1999 Brady Anderson (5.9)

CF: 2021 Cedric Mullins (5.9)

RF: 2008 Nick Markakis (7.4)

DH: 2013 Chris Davis (7.1)

Bench: 2003 Melvin Mora (4.7)

Bench: 2006 Miguel Tejada (4.5)

Bench: 2011 Matt Wieters (5.2)

Bench: 2001 Jeff Conine (2.9)

 

SP: 2000 Mike Mussina (5.7)

SP: 2007 Erik Bedard (5.7)

SP: 2019 John Means (4.4)

SP: 2002 Rodrigo Lopez (3.7)

SP: 2010 Jeremy Guthrie (4.5)

RP: 2016 Zach Britton (4.1)

RP: 2023 Felix Bautista (3.0)

RP: 2004 B.J. Ryan (3.4)

RP: 2012 Jim Johnson (2.4)

RP: 2014 Darren O’Day (2.4)

RP: 2017 Brad Brach (1.2)

RP: 2009 George Sherrill (1.7)

RP: 2018 Richard Bleier (1.5)

Edited by e16bball
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Posts

    • For me, bullpen strategy in a short series is developing a core principle or two and working backwards from that. That’s usually going to involve how we want to pitch to their best guys. In this case, there’s really no way to game Witt. He doesn’t have any discernible platoon splits, and in fact he destroyed RHPs this year. He doesn’t even have any particular pitches he struggles against. If you have to pitch to him, power stuff seems to be the way to go — if he has any weakness, it seems like maybe it’s LHPs who can attack him with high velocity and some sort of off speed weapon (Skubal, Framber, Kikuchi, EdRod, Rodon, Sale, Gore). So maybe you’re looking at Soto and Perez there, although you really just shouldn’t be pitching to him at all if you can avoid it. Beyond him, the other “hero” is Salvador Perez. And that’s from where I’d be building out my strategy. He probably should not see a LHP all series. There’s a fairly meaningful career platoon split there (109 wRC+ to 101), and it’s been more pronounced this year (130 to 110). I would be looking to force feed him ABs against Cano (1/4 with a single), Webb (0/2 with two Ks), and Dominguez. He’s always had trouble with offspeed stuff, which means Webb might be the preferred option. They’ve faced a ton of LH starters in the last week or so, but it seems like their preferred lineup against RHPs stacks LH hitters like Melendez and Gurriel behind Perez. Melendez is awful against LHPs, so ideally Perez might be the last hitter that the starters see. They pinch hit very liberally in platoon fashion in the bottom half of the lineup, so if you brought in someone like Akin behind the starter, they might very well hit for him. Forcing them to do that erases a lot of the platoon stacking in the late innings, so you could subsequently bring in a RHP to pitch to Perez without the same concern that they’d be exposed after him.    In sum, I think the ideal attack plan is for Burnes/Eflin/Kremer to see Perez three times, then bring in Akin or Cionel to pitch to the bottom of what will likely be a lefty-heavy lineup. They’ll potentially PH there, but that’s okay because none of those guys are that good. You then go to one of the RHPs for the top of the lineup, which it seems will consist of Pham, Witt (pitch around), and Perez. Then back to Coulombe or Soto for the bottom of the lineup again.
    • I have two tickets to Game 1 of the WC which I cannot use due to work travel.  Section 352, row 4, seats 9 & 10.  Asking $70 total for the two.  Paid $205 to the Orioles as a season plan member.   PM me if interested.  Paypal preferred.    
    • Can't make game 1. I'll be at game 2...last time I was at a playoff game at Camden, we beat Scherzer and the Tigers.
    • He should be taking fly balls all winter.
    • That was a lot of fun. Felt like there are certain elite seasons that had to be part of the team, and then tried to build from there.  Outfield depth is a little shaky, as is the rotation — though the latter is probably mostly unavoidable. The lineup would rake and the bullpen would shove, so pretty happy with this combination.   C 2022 Adley Rutschman (5.4 rWAR) 1B: 1998 Rafael Palmeiro (6.3) 2B: 2005 Brian Roberts (7.3) 3B: 2015 Manny Machado (7.5) SS: 2024 Gunnar Henderson (8.9) LF: 1999 Brady Anderson (5.9) CF: 2021 Cedric Mullins (5.9) RF: 2008 Nick Markakis (7.4) DH: 2013 Chris Davis (7.1) Bench: 2003 Melvin Mora (4.7) Bench: 2006 Miguel Tejada (4.5) Bench: 2011 Matt Wieters (5.2) Bench: 2001 Jeff Conine (2.9)   SP: 2000 Mike Mussina (5.7) SP: 2007 Erik Bedard (5.7) SP: 2019 John Means (4.4) SP: 2002 Rodrigo Lopez (3.7) SP: 2010 Jeremy Guthrie (4.5) RP: 2016 Zach Britton (4.1) RP: 2023 Felix Bautista (3.0) RP: 2004 B.J. Ryan (3.4) RP: 2012 Jim Johnson (2.4) RP: 2014 Darren O’Day (2.4) RP: 2017 Brad Brach (1.2) RP: 2009 George Sherrill (1.7) RP: 2018 Richard Bleier (1.5)
    • Gray started off well  but then ran out of steam a bit. He's not getting any younger. I was interested in him last year but I think the Cardinals overpaid and his contract only gets worse. 
    • A bit. Nothing life changing, but the format seems…Cleaner.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...