Jump to content

Jim Callis comments on the O's lack of prospects in the league top 20's


Frobby

Recommended Posts

Some thoughts:

-- If $9 mil is not keeping up, what do we need to spend??

-- Has Callis looked at our Major League roster of late. We probably had a half dozen guys who were forced fed to the major league level. We lost close to a 100 games for a reason.

-- As Tony pointed out, we had a lot of guys hurt this season in the system and that greatly skewed things.

-- We'll find out how good Tampa is when they have to fill LF, 1B and Closer with a $20 mil cut in payroll. Good luck to that!! They will have to deal pitching and lots of its to stay on pace.

-- Machado aside, what are the good things about our system Mr. Callis?? I think overall this was a pretty shallow exercise on his part filled with lots of love for the Red Sox and their overrated blown farm system:)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 140
  • Created
  • Last Reply
Some thoughts:

-- If $9 mil is not keeping up, what do we need to spend??

To me the template is the '09 draft after the first round. Pick, and pay, the BPA in the first round then follow the '09 formula. Of course the '09 overslot kids are not looking great ATM but thats the risk you need to take when dealing with the Sox and Yanks.

Also spend more resources on the international market.

Edit-Also no more giving up draft picks for relief pitchers.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Melewski has been reading the board here:

I saw that some fans on message boards were upset with Jim Callis' comments about Joe Mahoney.

To remind you, Baseball America's Callis said of Mahoney:

"A lot of times the teams' minor league player of the year is the guy that performed the best and not the best prospect. He is not a blue-chip, cornerstone type of prospect. He is a 23-year-old guy that spent half the season at High A and he got to Double-A and performed well.

"He had a nice year, but I don't think scouts are projecting him as a .300 hitter with plus power, like he did this year. He hit 18 home runs, which is a nice year, but you don't see him as guy that will hit 25 in the Majors. He is not a top prospect."

In my mind, Callis said nothing wrong and was not disrespectful of Mahoney in any way.

There is no reason for Callis to have a bias against Mahoney or the Orioles. It's his business to express opinions about young players and he is so well known and respected because he gets a lot right.

http://www.masnsports.com/steve_melewski/2010/10/monday-quick-takes-1.html

There's a bit more, which I omitted.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • His real age will match his baseball age in June.   He could have a role next year assuming Hays doesn't come back.  
    • High school players are also less likely to make the majors than college players. Picking Abrams or Witt would also increase the chances your 1:1 pick is a bust, or at least less than you hoped for. When I say Adley wasn't a "safe" pick, I meant that the Orioles didn't sacrifice much, if any, ceiling to raise the floor. I remember the vast majority of pundits saying that Adley was the most likely player in the draft to be an excellent baseball player. A few said they thought Witt or Abrams had a higher ceiling, but they also were less likely to reach it than Adley. And even they were like, "slightly higher ceiling, much lower floor, and C is more valuable than SS." Even if more all-star level players come out of high school, in that particular draft Adley was a special player who had a super high floor and a super high ceiling. The fact that high school players are more likely in general to be all-stars shouldn't blind one to the fact that there was an incredibly special college talent available at 1:1. Bottom line is the idea that the O's should have picked anyone other than Adley in that draft was a small minority opinion on draft day, and the fact that Witt and maybe Abrams ended up hitting their ceilings doesn't change the fact that Adley was the obvious choice with the information available at the time, and it's not like it didn't work out awesome for us. I would say Adley is definitely more likely to be a HOF than Abrams and probably Witt, too.
    • Yeah, but Westburg has become such a staple to the lineup and begun to establish himself offensively I thought they might do the Gunnar thing and say 3B is yours.  No more back and forth. 
    • I'm rambling now, but the 1928 A's may have been one of the coolest teams ever to hang around. Not only did they have a bunch of these old IL Orioles, and an unbelievable stock of young talent. But Mack had brought in some old guys, I guess to provide leadership and mentoring and the like. So on this one team they had the younger HOFs: Mickey Cochrane, Al Simmons, Jimmie Foxx, Lefty Grove. They had the Orioles in Boley, Bishop, Grove, Earnshaw. But on top of all that, they had 41-year-old Ty Cobb, 40-year-old Tris Speaker, 41-year-old Eddie Collins, 44-year-old Jack Quinn, and 35-year-old Bullet Joe Bush. Of course Cobb, Speaker, and Collins are inner-circle HOFers, among the best to ever play their position. Quinn was a grandfathered spitballer, probably worthy of a book or three, who won 96 games in his 40s and pitched his last MLB game at the age of 50. And Bush had a 17-year career where he won 196 games. The '28 A's won 98 games and only finished 2.5 games behind a Yanks team that was the freakin' '27 Yanks the year before. For '29 Mack say goodbye to Cobb, Speaker, made Collins a coach, plugged in the kids, and ran away with the league for three straight years. Until the Depression hit, Connie didn't have any other sources of income or wealth, and for the 2nd time had to sell off his stars to make payroll.
    • If they really want to get his bat going, send him to Delmarva!
    • Sounds like the FO believes Norby and Mayo (both righties) need to work more on their defense Holliday and Stowers (both lefties) need to work more on their hitting
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...