Jump to content

Question regarding Chris Davis suspension


puppet

Recommended Posts

Since Davis has, I believe, one more game to serve, can he participate in spring training? Sorry if this has been covered previously!

Thanks!

Yes he can.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Little weird to me how he got an exemption in 2013 and now in 2015 but not 2014.

Do they think ADHD comes and goes when it wants?

Idk if he has to.get an exemption every year, maybe he didnt realize either. Idk.

But the fact that he actually has ADHD, already had an.exemption and now another one shortly after the season had been completed smells fishy.

Obviously I'm not suggesting they tried purposely sabotaging the Os last year but this don't sit well with me. Nothing can be done now but the MLB lost a little respect in my eyes.

It's so easy today to have doctors write phony scripts for almost anything. Soon players will start having doctors say they have muscle deficiencies and get exempted for the use of steroids.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Little weird to me how he got an exemption in 2013 and now in 2015 but not 2014.

Do they think ADHD comes and goes when it wants?

Idk if he has to.get an exemption every year, maybe he didnt realize either. Idk.

But the fact that he actually has ADHD, already had an.exemption and now another one shortly after the season had been completed smells fishy.

Obviously I'm not suggesting they tried purposely sabotaging the Os last year but this don't sit well with me. Nothing can be done now but the MLB lost a little respect in my eyes.

It's so easy today to have doctors write phony scripts for almost anything. Soon players will start having doctors say they have muscle deficiencies and get exempted for the use of steroids.

Where did you read he had an exemption in 2013?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Little weird to me how he got an exemption in 2013 and now in 2015 but not 2014.

Do they think ADHD comes and goes when it wants?

Idk if he has to.get an exemption every year, maybe he didnt realize either. Idk.

But the fact that he actually has ADHD, already had an.exemption and now another one shortly after the season had been completed smells fishy.

Obviously I'm not suggesting they tried purposely sabotaging the Os last year but this don't sit well with me. Nothing can be done now but the MLB lost a little respect in my eyes.

It's so easy today to have doctors write phony scripts for almost anything. Soon players will start having doctors say they have muscle deficiencies and get exempted for the use of steroids.

Buck said this without saying it in the press conference when it was revealed that Chris has a 2015 exemption. Something like, " it makes you wonder, it makes you wonder publicly". I am wondering if the players union will defend Chris on this. I think they should.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

My mistake..I knew he had one. Thought I heard it was 2013.

No one knows the whole truth/timeline but it sounds like it expired and he did not bother to appeal it. Probably because he had good years in 2013 and 2014 and figured he didn't need it. From what I read Davis's ADD may have been exacerbated by the stress of his slump last year and people with ADD have more severe issues with stress than non-ADD people.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Little weird to me how he got an exemption in 2013 and now in 2015 but not 2014.

Do they think ADHD comes and goes when it wants?

Idk if he has to.get an exemption every year, maybe he didnt realize either. Idk.

But the fact that he actually has ADHD, already had an.exemption and now another one shortly after the season had been completed smells fishy.

Obviously I'm not suggesting they tried purposely sabotaging the Os last year but this don't sit well with me. Nothing can be done now but the MLB lost a little respect in my eyes.

It's so easy today to have doctors write phony scripts for almost anything. Soon players will start having doctors say they have muscle deficiencies and get exempted for the use of steroids.

I've had it for a few years and mine is adult onset. My personal experience with it is that it actually does come and go, in a way. There are days that it is worse than others. For me it is like my bad knee, there are days where it hurts worse than others.

With that being said, I still don't agree with the MLB policy on this specific medication. If he obtains it legally through a doctor, there should be no question that he needs it and should be allowed to use it. This medication does not make you stronger or faster. But it's not just MLB's fault either. He knew the rules and it appears that he didn't play by them, but at least he has been forthcoming about it. I support him. MLB is way over their heads with this, and in my opinion it is down right crummy of them.

How silly does it look that he has to sit out opening day for taking a medication that he is legally prescribed and now has an exemption for again? And why does the exemption only last 1 freaking season? As long as he still has a prescription why can't that be good enough for them to just keep the same one active? It's stupid and redundant.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I've had it for a few years and mine is adult onset. My personal experience with it is that it actually does come and go, in a way. There are days that it is worse than others. For me it is like my bad knee, there are days where it hurts worse than others.

With that being said, I still don't agree with the MLB policy on this specific medication. If he obtains it legally through a doctor, there should be no question that he needs it and should be allowed to use it. This medication does not make you stronger or faster. But it's not just MLB's fault either. He knew the rules and it appears that he didn't play by them, but at least he has been forthcoming about it. I support him. MLB is way over their heads with this, and in my opinion it is down right crummy of them.

How silly does it look that he has to sit out opening day for taking a medication that he is legally prescribed and now has an exemption for again? And why does the exemption only last 1 freaking season? As long as he still has a prescription why can't that be good enough for them to just keep the same one active? It's stupid and redundant.

Back in the '70's my mother used to get "diet shots" for a buck pop from a medical doctor. It is an unfortunate reality that if a baseball player wants to pay for it, he can find a doctor that will write him a script.

It has been decided that the drug, when used by folks not suffering from ADHD, does indeed enhance performance. It increases focus amongst other effects.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Back in the '70's my mother used to get "diet shots" for a buck pop from a medical doctor. It is an unfortunate reality that if a baseball player wants to pay for it, he can find a doctor that will write him a script.

It has been decided that the drug, when used by folks not suffering from ADHD, does indeed enhance performance. It increases focus amongst other effects.

Your mom sounds like a fun lady!

I'm sure that anyone could find a doctor to write them a prescription for whatever. I have an easy way to solve this problem. Each team has a team of physicians. Why cant team doctors prescribe this stuff and report it to the top? MLB should have their own doctor at the top anyways. As long as it is written by a team doctor there shouldn't be a problem. Maybe there is too much liability involved with that? I'm not a lawyer but I think I'd make a handsome one on TV.

I'm not sure I know what you're implying with your last sentence.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your mom sounds like a fun lady!

I'm sure that anyone could find a doctor to write them a prescription for whatever. I have an easy way to solve this problem. Each team has a team of physicians. Why cant team doctors prescribe this stuff and report it to the top? MLB should have their own doctor at the top anyways. As long as it is written by a team doctor there shouldn't be a problem. Maybe there is too much liability involved with that? I'm not a lawyer but I think I'd make a handsome one on TV.

I'm not sure I know what you're implying with your last sentence.

You are about 10 years late when it comes to my mother.

There is a policy in place to review the prescriptions. I would rather have that then to trust team doctors.

Focus, it's helpful to ball player. Adderall helps increase focus. It also helps fight fatigue and possibly slightly boosts reflexes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Your mom sounds like a fun lady!

I'm sure that anyone could find a doctor to write them a prescription for whatever. I have an easy way to solve this problem. Each team has a team of physicians. Why cant team doctors prescribe this stuff and report it to the top? MLB should have their own doctor at the top anyways. As long as it is written by a team doctor there shouldn't be a problem. Maybe there is too much liability involved with that? I'm not a lawyer but I think I'd make a handsome one on TV.

I'm not sure I know what you're implying with your last sentence.

MLB has professionals and procedures in place to review these cases. It's not like they accept or deny the them willy nilly. Maybe Davis's denial was unfair but he "apparently" chose not to even take the time to appeal the case/decision initially. I'm sure quite a few of us have spent many an hour fighting with our health insurance companies/HMO's appealing decisions. I don't have a lot of sympathy for him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

MLB has professionals and procedures in place to review these cases. It's not like they accept or deny the them willy nilly. Maybe Davis's denial was unfair but he "apparently" chose not to even take the time to appeal the case/decision initially. I'm sure quite a few of us have spent many an hour fighting with our health insurance companies/HMO's appealing decisions. I don't have a lot of sympathy for him.

There is an expert panel of 3 psychiatrists that review all adult adhd claims.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • For Norfolk, Cook has started 29 games at 1B with a .996 fpct. and 5 games each at LF, CF, RF.   He started one game at 3B and made an error and at lower levels played a decent amount of 2B.   I think he’s probably an emergency/last resort guy at 2B/3B and @Tony-OH seems skeptical of his outfield defense in general.  Saying all that, with a LH heavy hitting OF he has a decent shot as soon as next year, especially if Norby gets moved.  Norby, with the ability to play LF/RF/2B would probably be his chief competitor for a backup role.  Also depends on what they do with Hays.
    • Your definition of what we need and @Bemorewins definiton of what we need may be different.    Getting a #3 starter he feels confident as a game #3 starter in the playoffs.   Who, in his mind, is that pitcher?   Fedde will not require one of those guys.  Crochet might.
    • We do not have to give up Holliday, Basallo, or Mayo to get what we need.
    • So you think Elias will give up one of the top 3 prospects to get upgrades?
    • “Dramatics”? That’s an interesting way of framing my opinion. I promise you I am as calm and cool as a cucumber. There’s no “dramatics” going on here. As you know, numbers fluctuate during any given period of time in the season. Good/great players have bad/cold stretches and bad/terrible players have good stretches. IMO we do not possess the type of top end talent at the back end of the bullpen needed to win multiple rounds against the best opposition in October.  If you are confident in Cano/Kimbrel or worse in Vespi/Baker/Perez/etc getting Soto and Judge out in a big spot late in the game in Yankee stadium in October, that is fine. I am not.  Just as an observer of baseball, Holmes is a much better pitcher than any reliever that we have. I would be much more confident in his talent than any reliever that we have. Now if we had Felix that would be one thing. But this season we do not. And I would hate for a team as good as ours to be held back by not making the needed/necessary move(s) before we get into October.  IMO we did that last season (with the starting pitching) and it didn’t end well. And I acknowledge that everybody doesn’t think like me nor have the same championship expectations/aspirations. Some fans/posters here have stated as much and that they are happy if we have a winning team year after year or if we just make it into the tournament year after year, regardless of results when we get there. And that’s fine. That’s just not my desired outcome. The great thing about this board is that we don’t have to agree and are able to express our opinions.
    • That’s right. Great times are here and more ahead with this group. 
    • Over/under on the number of times we walk Judge and Soto in this series?   10?  Nobody else really worries me.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...