Jump to content

Are the Orioles overrating Alvarez?

purple@orange

By purple@orange
in Orioles Talk

Recommended Posts

purple@orange High-A

purple@orange

Posted
Posted

I seriously don't get why Duquette and the O's management are so high on Dariel Alvarez. This morning, for example, I heard Duquette compare him to a young Jose Bautista. Seriously? He really thinks this kid could be a 40 HR/year slugger?

I know the O's (like a lot of teams) overrate their own prospects but this seems like overkill. Most objective scouting sources rate Alvarez as a 4th outfielder at best, saying his strong throwing arm is his only dominant tool

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 54
  • Created
  • Last Reply
BohKnowsBmore Hangout Grand Counsel

BohKnowsBmore

Posted
Posted
I seriously don't get why Duquette and the O's management are so high on Dariel Alvarez. This morning, for example, I heard Duquette compare him to a young Jose Bautista. Seriously? He really thinks this kid could be a 40 HR/year slugger?

I know the O's (like a lot of teams) overrate their own prospects but this seems like overkill. Most objective scouting sources rate Alvarez as a 4th outfielder at best, saying his strong throwing arm is his only dominant tool

Two things.

1) Maybe. They could be overrating him. Hard to say. Young Jose Bautista wasn't viewed as a 40-HR guy, so it's not as though he's saying he was Trout or Harper-like as an OF prospect. Even if they are overrating him somehow, I don't see the harm in it. He's not written in pen as a starter for 2015 or 2016 at this point.

2) So what? DD went on a program and talked up one of his players. I really don't think you can expect ANY team to take the line of "objective scouting sources" in discussing their own players with the media.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
LA2 Hangout Grand Counsel

LA2

Posted
Posted
I seriously don't get why Duquette and the O's management are so high on Dariel Alvarez. This morning, for example, I heard Duquette compare him to a young Jose Bautista. Seriously? He really thinks this kid could be a 40 HR/year slugger?

I know the O's (like a lot of teams) overrate their own prospects but this seems like overkill. Most objective scouting sources rate Alvarez as a 4th outfielder at best, saying his strong throwing arm is his only dominant tool

Duquette has an out--the young Jose Bautista was nothing special.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Camden_yardbird Hangout Grand Counsel

Camden_yardbird

Posted
Posted
I seriously don't get why Duquette and the O's management are so high on Dariel Alvarez. This morning, for example, I heard Duquette compare him to a young Jose Bautista. Seriously? He really thinks this kid could be a 40 HR/year slugger?

I know the O's (like a lot of teams) overrate their own prospects but this seems like overkill. Most objective scouting sources rate Alvarez as a 4th outfielder at best, saying his strong throwing arm is his only dominant tool

As someone who watched a young Bautista come up with Pittsburgh...the line on him was decent fielder, high doubles potential, may develop into 10-15 HR hitter in his peak years.

That's a perfectly legit major league player. Not everyone is going to be a star.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Aristotelian Hangout Grand Counsel

Aristotelian

Posted
Posted

If DD was truly high on Alvarez, we would not have brought in Travis Snider or gone to arbitration with De Aza. He may be overrating Alvarez in his words but in his actions he is treating Alvarez as he should--a prospect with upside but who has not yet proved himself capable of playing MLB. If Alvarez was taking playing time from somebody who should be higher on the organizational chart, then it might be time to worry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
BohKnowsBmore Hangout Grand Counsel

BohKnowsBmore

Posted
Posted
If DD was truly high on Alvarez, we would not have brought in Travis Snider or gone to arbitration with De Aza. He may be overrating Alvarez in his words but in his actions he is treating Alvarez as he should--a prospect with upside but who has not yet proved himself capable of playing MLB. If Alvarez was taking playing time from somebody who should be higher on the organizational chart, then it might be time to worry.

This was what I was trying to say to some degree. It's not as though they're putting all of their eggs in the Alvarez basket or giving him time and attention over clearly superior options.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MurphDogg Hangout Grand Counsel

MurphDogg

Posted
Posted
So much this.

26 years old and barely played above AA, where he was average offensively. How they expect that to translate to a productive major league player is beyond me.

Alvarez was not average offensively in AA. 2014 Eastern League, league-wide OPS was .718, with a triple slash line of .261/.327/.392. Alvarez's line was .309/.332/.487. Hell, he was above average in his 44 games in AAA where the average triple slash line in the International League was .261/.331/.393 and his was .301/.328/.439.

Yes, age is working against him, but that is what happens when you don't sign with an MLB club until you are 24. It's tough to be young for your league when you sign with a big league club when you are 3-8 years older than everyone else. Despite that, Alvarez was still two years younger than the weighted average of International League players last season and he more than held his own, in fact he was above average over 44 games.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Frobby Hangout Grand Counsel

Frobby

Posted
Posted

No, only wildcard is overrating Alvarez. ;)

I take everything Dan and Buck say about our minor leaguers with a huge grain of salt. I don't think they expect Alvarez to make the Opening Day roster or are counting on him making a significant contribution to the major league team this year. But it's their job to encourage these guys and build fan interest in them as well. Who knows, maybe he'll continue progressing and eventually help the big club. He has at least some tools.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
MurphDogg Hangout Grand Counsel

MurphDogg

Posted
Posted
Right, I just feel like if he was really that good and highly thought of, he would've started at AAA at the very least. All the top tier Cuban guys either went straight to the majors or just did a brief stint in AAA.

Well that's an issue with the Orioles development style, not an issue with Alvarez. I don't think a half-season at Bowie will hurt him necessarily. The Orioles seem to prefer having their top prospects spend more time at Bowie than Norfolk, they have said in the past that they like to see how players top prospects as opposed to AAA retreads. And he did very well (not average) in Bowie and while he was old as a prospect for the league he was still near the average age overall.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

  • Posts

    • OnlyOneOriole
      Felix Bautista 2024 (Monitoring his injury rehab)

      By OnlyOneOriole · Posted

      I would agree.  Not sure if he can pitch this season or not (probably not), but the way they do that surgery now along with the healing powers of platelet injections?    A pitcher can be back throwing and almost 100% within 8 months.  I have the exact same injury as Felix along with a bone chip in my right elbow and I was told if I have the surgery I will feel basically brand new after 6-8 months.   Granted I am not trying to throw 95 MPH 8 months later.
    • Malike
      Colton Cowser 2024

      By Malike · Posted

    • Explosivo
      Are we actually 27-14 with the highest runs/game in the AL?

      By Explosivo · Posted

      Ding ding ding. It’s the crab pot mentality. Most will drag you back to the bottom rather than allow others to climb out to freedom. It’s the old misery loves company.   Sadly for my Orioles fans, they have used this misery as a warm blanket and have even rationalized their sorrow by way of linking up with other sorrowful fans. It’s a sort of companionship in misery. Suddenly the orioles start to do well, as if this wasn’t the plan by Elias all along, and many orioles fans are still clinging to their long held beliefs that the shoe will drop, that the end is nigh, and that success will all come crashing down.   After all, failure is what they have grown accustomed to, it’s all they know, their world is an abject failure, so when the team they love suddenly starts doing well…they have no idea what to do. They lash out. They find fault where there is none, and their extreme uncomfort becomes full display to all those who might say “yeah but we’re good now, things are good now” but that simply can not be so. There must be something wrong. The shoe will drop. The loss will happen. My life is not fulfilled without the thumping of the chest from the loser Oriole who proclaims to his tribe, “see, I told you so!” sad sacks of shit, the lot of them!
    • FlaO'sFan
      Ohtani's Interpreter Accused of Theft, Fired.

      By FlaO'sFan · Posted

      Another MLB player, once a teammate and friend of Ohtani, maybe tied to gambling. I didn't bother to try to understand the exact timeline or tie to Ohtani, which seems to be just as friends, but here it is for anyone interested. https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/40166891/angels-david-fletcher-bet-bookie
    • Roy Firestone
      Austin Hays 2024

      By Roy Firestone · Posted

      tomorrow...I think..
    • Punchandjudy
      Joey Ortiz 2024

      By Punchandjudy · Posted

      Not for someone who has money riding on him winning the award.
    • Cheetos
      Are we actually 27-14 with the highest runs/game in the AL?

      By Cheetos · Posted

      Well, now that we’ve established the hitting sucks, is it a good time to complain that this pitching is obviously over performing and will crash and burn any day now?

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...