Jump to content

Thoughts on McCutchen in the rebuild?


MemorialStadKid

Recommended Posts

 

Quote

 

Andrew McCutchen’s time with the San Francisco Giants might be coming to an end soon. The 31-year-old outfielder was reportedly placed on revocable waivers, according to The Athletic’s Andrew Baggarly, and he could be on the move soon.

McCutchen has hit .257/.354/.417 over 528 plate appearances. He’s set to be a free-agent at the end of the season and is making a little under $15 million in 2018.

 

SOURCE: https://sports.yahoo.com/andrew-mccutchen-reportedly-placed-waivers-lead-trade-020016780.html

Would anyone want him on the team for a veteran presence if AJ is leaving? 

Thoughts? 

MSK

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 38
  • Created
  • Last Reply

I am pretty sad his career didn’t turn out better, Allstar to HOF trajectory. He should go fill out a competing team or work on getting back to his AS self. There really isn’t a place for him on the Os. If you think about it, over the next couple of years the OF (on paper) is looking to be their strong suit. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

We’re loaded with OFs. Mullins is up. We have to play Mancini out of position in LF until Trumbo/Davis are gone. It’s time to see what Stewart can do. Hays is back to raking after an injury plagued year. Diaz is really hitting in AA too. Even Rickard is having his highest OPS of his career. McKenna will have a lot of AA PAs under his belt at season’s end  

We have a bunch of OFs that we need to find out if they can play in the near future. As far as veteran presence, even though Davis is terrible, he’s still a decent dude. Plus we have Trumbo, Joseph, Cobb, Cashner, Givens, and Bundy here next year. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, MemorialStadKid said:

 

SOURCE: https://sports.yahoo.com/andrew-mccutchen-reportedly-placed-waivers-lead-trade-020016780.html

Would anyone want him on the team for a veteran presence if AJ is leaving? 

Thoughts? 

MSK

 

I think we need to address the reality of only signing players at league minimum for the next two seasons. I don't see a reason to insult Andrew. Players acquired at this point need to be MLB ready in 2021 and of limited expense until then. Those are my thoughts. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

49 minutes ago, weams said:

I think we need to address the reality of only signing players at league minimum for the next two seasons. I don't see a reason to insult Andrew. Players acquired at this point need to be MLB ready in 2021 and of limited expense until then. Those are my thoughts. 

Maybe a non tendered IF or SP if a player is looking to rebuild their value. But spending money after we just dumped Gausman to dump O’day wouldn’t make any sense at this point. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, sevastras said:

I am pretty sad his career didn’t turn out better, Allstar to HOF trajectory. He should go fill out a competing team or work on getting back to his AS self. There really isn’t a place for him on the Os. If you think about it, over the next couple of years the OF (on paper) is looking to be their strong suit. 

Welcome to the post PED world.  What has apparently happened to McCutchen has happened numerous times in baseball history.  Very good player, with HOF potential gets to his early 30's and just suddenly falls off a cliff to an average player, sometimes not even that.  Maybe McCutchen bounces back next year or maybe guys like Boog Powell, Roger Maris and Rocky Colavito are all waiving high to him (all of them with another 3 to 4 good years are probably HOF worthy, at least in the discussion, instead now hall of very good). 

Another reason why the Chris Davis contract was dumb, or any contract big money contract that extends past a players age of 32 or 33.  Baseball history does not support it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

If there's no room for Jones in the future, there's no room for Cutch.

I like Cutch a lot, too.  Hard to believe he's only 31.  But I don't think he's got much left in the tank.

I honesty thought the same with Cakes, figured he had 1, maybe 2 good years left in him, and just another point in time, when i was wrong.

I think you are right, good player, just not sure what he has left.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

So we substitute one outfielder with an eroding skill set for another who while at one time in his respective career was superior to the aforementioned outfielder we already have, also now has an eroding skill set and has been degrading in quality for some time.  Not to mention, veteran presence is such a 2002-2011 Orioles phrase that I'm honestly starting to have terrible flashbacks.  Marty Cordova, Jeff Conine part II, Miguel Tejada part II, Kevin Millar, a lot of these types of moves while short term investments were sold on the idea of having a veteran presence around a supposedly rebuilding team.  Provided there aren't any moves, guys like Cashner, Cobb, Givens, and others already fill that bill.  If McCutchen, Jones, or anyone for that matter aren't a legitimate upgrade in terms of offense or defense, intangibles aren't going to make a whole lot of difference.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, MemorialStadKid said:

 

SOURCE: https://sports.yahoo.com/andrew-mccutchen-reportedly-placed-waivers-lead-trade-020016780.html

Would anyone want him on the team for a veteran presence if AJ is leaving? 

Thoughts? 

MSK

 

He and Jones will be competing for free agent work..and it will be even sparser for them to find as a result...I would not be surprised to see Jones on a pillow deal with us, but only if it is a steal for us,  Otherwise, nope.  We can finish last just fine for the next two years without a “veteran presence.”    We need to furiously be turning over young players, seperating wheat from chaff and any veteran will just be an obstacle, except maybe at backup catcher. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • Trading Mayo Kjerstad and Povich for one guy to become a relief pitcher is nuts.
    • We don't need starting pitchers. We need Relief Pitchers. We don't need average Relief Pitchers, we need consistent high leverage/high K Relief Pitchers.
    • If you feel comfortable putting Aiken and Baker (or even Tate) in during an elimination series, that's your prerogative. But I do not. Too inconsistent, which is the same reason why Mike Baumann pitched himself off the active roster. when spot was needed for returning starters off the IL. Currently Coulombe is on IL so we can't even count on one of our best. Cano has regressed from last season. We've also witnessed last season how Webb broke down from over use and was ineffective in the playoff series against Texas. Perez goes in streaks of either really good or concernedly bad (he loses his command). Akin's problem is he leaves the ball over the heart of the plate and he doesn't have good enough stuff to get away with it. They're meatballs. We might get some good times from Baker now that he's up, but I would only expect a month or 2 at best from him before he returns to old habits. And Suarez is a starter who wants to be a starter. Who knows if he will go back to the bullpen? He'll have to go deeper into games if he wants to stay in the rotation, otherwise, I think he should be in the bullpen. But that's not what he is right now in this moment. He's a starter with a ERA in the 1s.
    • It's pretty hard to say definitively that the bolded is true.  It might be, but there's also the loss in ability you have to account for.  30 year olds are slower than 26 year olds too.  Maybe their game knowledge and practice have made it so they can overcome the meager loss in bat speed/athleticism over that time span.  But the picture is a bit muddy.   I also don't think the aging issue is limited to people in their mid-late 30s.  Bat speed peaks at like 24 or 25 based on the data we have right now on it, and after 31 starts falling off fairly fast.  Obviously this is population data and individuals are likely to see different curves.   But outside of the stars that have a lot of ability to lose, it's becoming pretty clear that once you hit your early 30s it's pretty hard to maintain your skills without all the "help" that is extensively tested for.   I think that even for early-30s players teams are much more willing to drop them over giving them expensive market-rate deals, especially since they can abuse young talent so readily.
    • After a really dumb day at work, this was an absolutely delightful read. Seeing a diamond expert and a can of corn detonate a yoked PBA pro was absolutely wonderful. I love this website. 
    • If you pitch Bradish on 5 days rest you'd pitch Rodriguez on 3 days rest?
    • I think if you look at it draft by draft most years Elias did not have a chance to take a pitcher early. 2019 was Adley/Witt, 2020 everyone wanted Austin Martin SS over Kjerstad, 2021 it was Cowser or a few high school SS, and 2022 it was 5 position players at the top of the draft. I think Asa Lacy or Max Meyer were the only pitchers we could have possibly taken up until last year. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...