BP Top 10

[LookinUp]

41 minutes ago, Frobby said:

I know Luke liked Hall’s defense better than Grenier’s.    But, to each his own.   
 

I remember Tony having a conniption a few years ago when BP put Josh Hart in their top 10.   They aren’t afraid to go out on a limb.     In that case, the limb got sawed off while they were sitting on it.    

What they seem afraid to do is update their lists based on more current info. I have to assume they’re just really short on resources.

[Luke-OH]

1 hour ago, Frobby said:

I know Luke liked Hall’s defense better than Grenier’s.    But, to each his own.   
 

I remember Tony having a conniption a few years ago when BP put Josh Hart in their top 10.   They aren’t afraid to go out on a limb.     In that case, the limb got sawed off while they were sitting on it.    

I do, but I think I’m in the minority there. I just think Hall is more twitchy and has quicker hands on the release or transfer. Grenier is more consistent. Both are better fits at 2B IMO. 

I wasn’t around for Tony’s take on Hart in their 10. I actually preferred BP over BA for awhile but they’ve drastically cut their in person scouting.

I did get into my first Twitter argument (with Meoli actually) over Chris Lee in BA’s top 10 over Akin and Stewart. I had Lee at 36 or something. 

[Flash- bd]

12 hours ago, LookinUp said:

Honestly, Grenier at 10 makes me discount the entire thing. For example, maybe Hall at 4 makes sense, but I won't give that any credence unless it comes packaged with a bunch of other smart takes.

They also have Yusniel below McKenna after ranking him 1st last season. Smacks of incoherence. 

[Tony-OH]

Let's just say, to each is own. The list is pretty out there, but if that's how they feel, more power to them. 

[Frobby]

2 minutes ago, Tony-OH said:

Let's just say, to each is own. The list is pretty out there, but if that's how they feel, more power to them. 

It would be boring if these lists always came out virtually identical.