Jump to content

Umpire Scorecard Thread


Can_of_corn

Recommended Posts

9 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

In Baltimore's favor?

image.png.d6efa29059c3548924a675b041b3940b.png

 

If the scorecard is gonna be this bad maybe roboumps are not gonna help.  No way that was in favor of us.  Jackson strike out, Adley strike out have to be two most impacted nit a 2-0 third pitch called strike that still became a walk.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

On 8/3/2024 at 4:51 PM, bpilktree67 said:

If the scorecard is gonna be this bad maybe roboumps are not gonna help.  No way that was in favor of us.  Jackson strike out, Adley strike out have to be two most impacted nit a 2-0 third pitch called strike that still became a walk.  

Who it favored and by how much is just UmpScorecard's own "calculation", roboumps would simply get more precise balls and srikes, which is what everyone is after. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, InsideCoroner said:

Who it favored and by how much is just UmpScorecard's own "calculation", roboumps would simply get more precise balls and srikes, which is what everyone is after. 

Why are you using quotes around calculation?  Are you accusing them of just making up numbers?

We do have an idea of how much impact the various counts have on the outcome of an at bat.

There is this for chart for instance, tracking the chance to get on base.

image.thumb.png.dd7aaa4099e1e4517d9ac2ace5149777.png

Edited by Can_of_corn
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

Why are you using quotes around calculation?  Are you accusing them of just making up numbers?

We do have an idea of how much impact the various counts have on the outcome of an at bat.

There is this for chart for instance, tracking the chance to get on base.

image.thumb.png.dd7aaa4099e1e4517d9ac2ace5149777.png

Because I don't know what metrics go into their decision as to how those blown calls affected the runs scored by either team. Either way this is a secondary point. If balls and strikes are called correctly, the predicted Overall Favor category in terms of runs becomes obsolete. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The Sunday game didn't get a scorecard for some reason, but the impact for Cleveland was a full +1.36, as Cory Blaser took a run off the scoreboard by taking away an RBI walk for Ryan O'Hearn on a 3-2 pitch and punching him out to end the inning (also denying the Orioles the run expectancy with bases loaded and two out in the AB after).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

As technology progresses, I think some type of smart goggles/glasses will solve the problem of umpires’ inaccuracy of calling balls and strikes.   Apparently, industry has been working on it for a few years .  That’s probably more palatable for the umpire’s union than robo umps or replay challenges for balls and strikes.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

34 minutes ago, jdwilde1 said:

As technology progresses, I think some type of smart goggles/glasses will solve the problem of umpires’ inaccuracy of calling balls and strikes.   Apparently, industry has been working on it for a few years .  That’s probably more palatable for the umpire’s union than robo umps or replay challenges for balls and strikes.

 

 

Oh, so now its okay to tell them to get glasses?!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

That is pitiful.   

By the way, I wanted to look at the chart of Sunday’s game, which featured a really ridiculous 3-2 call on O’Hearn with the bases loaded.  For some reason, they have a record of that game but no chart of the errant pitches.   3-2 with the bases loaded has to be about as impactful as it gets.  

On the year, the O’s are -10 runs on bad calls (4th worst in MLB), while the Yankees are +19 (2nd best, behind Cleveland at +25).

 

 

Edited by Frobby
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • It takes Orioles rookies 60 or 70 at bats to get their first two hits.
    • Tell me how can Harbaugh help him when he doesn't know how to help himself. Harbs is the worst at burning timeouts stupidly then not having any when they are needed at crunch time. 
    • Yes the same here. They are going to the playoffs and yet I have no feeling towards it whatsoever. Weird feeling. Like you just know they are going to get bounced in the first round. It looks inevitable. I mean you could make a case the Tigers are more deserving of the Orioles spot. They are playing some great baseball of late. 
    • Man Baltimore sports has not been kind. The Orioles are on a  3 month tailspin and the Ravens did what they do best and blew another double digit 4th quarter lead to a inferior team.  Let's see if the Orioles can right the ship,  though I'm not holding my breath on that one at all. Yikes. 
    • Idk how impactful this was, probably pretty low on the list of problems, but this is the 2nd straight week that Lamar threw the ball late in the game and the receiver was unable to get oob.  The ball to Bateman is probably excusable because we had more time on the clock and we needed the deep ball to be in position to make a run, but this time throwing a 12 yard dump to Andrews was just straight up stupid IMO.  I get that they're going to play outside leverage all day every day in this situation but just throw it away and try to take another shot.  Lamar has to have more clock awareness than that,  and Harbaugh has to instill in him the importance of saving those seconds on the clock.
    • Sorry but that response from Fuller sounds to me like too many words, concepts, abstractions, and if that's how he communicates, wordy and convoluted, it's a lot for hitters to carry "into the box." Not to mention all the specifics involved, re. what pitches and locations to look for, all the analytics of how to do the swing and torque the body, etc. I'm no coach but I can imagine a whole season of this approach just becomes information overload. Maybe it's not rocket science, after all (with all due respect to ex-NASA Sig). Maybe the antidote is more Zen: just see the pitch and hit the dang thing.  BTW I think the analytical, overthinking approach is better suited to the pitching side, where you can plan your attack based on all the data. Hitting is more reaction, no time to think. You can't beat pitching using the same approach--rather, need the opposite approach, to counter with instinct and intuition. At least, that's my cheap (2 cents) advice!
    • The proposition that every auction automatically results in an overpay is simplified indeed.  Granted, "kind of true" is a low bar to clear, but still...
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...