Jump to content

Astros punishment unveiled...


Absltgreek

Recommended Posts

5 minutes ago, weams said:

There is no mention of Elias. Or Sig. Who quit the Astros with no job and went back to corporate work.  I assume at some point both were made aware. This are not dumb men. 

Yeah but either way I don't think you can punish them if they weren't involved.  I don't know that there is whistle blower protection in MLB.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Snutchy said:

I think that Carlos Beltran is going to have a hard time getting into the HoF now.

Baseball has, in the past, largely turned a blind eye to in-game cheating with respect to hall of fame admission.  I don't think this affects his HOF resume much, if at all.  Though it's possible that in the twitter, righteous-fury, cancel culture of the 2010s, he does see a negative effect. A bit of thread derailment, but I feel like this is inconsistent with baseball's view on PEDs.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Hallas said:

Baseball has, in the past, largely turned a blind eye to in-game cheating with respect to hall of fame admission.  I don't think this affects his HOF resume much, if at all.  Though it's possible that in the twitter, righteous-fury, cancel culture of the 2010s, he does see a negative effect. A bit of thread derailment, but I feel like this is inconsistent with baseball's view on PEDs.

We shall see in 2 or 3 years I guess. 

And in all years it was the last of his playing career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Hallas said:

Baseball has, in the past, largely turned a blind eye to in-game cheating with respect to hall of fame admission.  I don't think this affects his HOF resume much, if at all.  Though it's possible that in the twitter, righteous-fury, cancel culture of the 2010s, he does see a negative effect. A bit of thread derailment, but I feel like this is inconsistent with baseball's view on PEDs.

Yeah didn't affect Gaylord Perry very  much and he is pretty much the poster chile for cheaters. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This to me is a much bigger stain on the game than the steroids era.  And the fact is that is probably going on in many more clubhouses than we know about.  I want to shy away from the "everyone is dirty" generalization, because I think it is used too often and gets us down some bad rabbit holes in a race to the bottom than a race to the top.

It is flabbergasting to me that players are not going be at fault in this whole situation.  I understand the men who got fired were the manager and executive, and should have been more accountable when they found out.  Still, baseball has got to create cultural change within the system or we are going to be talking about the next cheating scandal in 10-15 years.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

20 hours ago, atomic said:

Yeah didn't affect Gaylord Perry very  much and he is pretty much the poster chile for cheaters. 

Perry didn’t get in until his third try, despite winning 314 games and two Cy Young awards.    My guess is he would have gotten in on the first ballot except for his reputation.     So, delayed but not denied.    Beltran is more of a borderline HOF guy, so this might hurt him more.    

  • Thanks 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 3 weeks later...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • Isn't is just weird that it took 100+ years to figure that out? Hey, that guy hits a bunch of balls right through the box, maybe we should have the second baseman move over that direction a little? Nah, if we do it so will everybody, and we like .350 hitters even when they're on the other team. It would be like a football game where there's a formation where a WR keeps getting completely open downfield and busting 40 yard plays, and it takes 35 years for defenses to adjust. "It's just how it is! If we cover that guy, then the running back might average five yards a carry!"
    • I was thinking the same thing. 
    • Yes, I think that would be a solution that just might work. If you doubled the number of MLB teams it might take a decade or two for talent to catch back up. One of the reasons many strategies of 100 or 150 years ago worked was a much lower talent level, and much bigger spread between the best and worst MLB players. Even just going back 50 years or so it's clear to me one of the reasons pitchers could throw 300 innings was a much shallower pool of hitters, or at the very least choices that favored .220 hitting shortstops with no power. But, what do you think the odds are of Major League Baseball expanding to 60 teams in the next decade? 0.001%? 0.0000001%? The owners would look at such a proposal as an idea for how to slash their shared revenues by 50%, and would probably rather spend the last 20 years of their life fighting it in court than let that happen. This is like the discussions I have with soccer fans on promotion/relegation in the US. Great idea, tremendous benefits, works beautifully in the rest of the world, fosters all kinds of local grassroots interest in the sport, punishes tanking. But current owners would rather gouge their eyes out with their thumbnails than implement it here.
    • I only watched the first two innings.  I didn’t think he’d last much longer because he looked very hittable to that point.  I really question the pitch selection to Rorthsveldt on a 1-2 pitch with a man on third and one out.  He just swung threw a up in the zone fastball, Suarez’ best pitch.  Throw another one same spot, or higher, or in, or even try to bury a changeup low.  Anything to try and get a swing and miss.  But a two seamer (that’s what they called it) down and away? Credit to Suarez for giving us 5.  I don’t really think he’s a starter but he’s getting it done.  Why can he hit 97 in the first inning but not in relief?   I guess it’s a warmup thing.  The 2023-24 Orioles are very good at “winning ugly”.   They find a way more often than not.
    • I hadn’t heard an up to date report on Gillen’s arm.  He’s two years out from that surgery so that’s certainly not good.   I like Lindsey too.  The only real drawbacks are that he’s a RH hitter and the power projection is questionable but he’s got top of the line speed. I’m really not interested in the hit first college types like Amick.   I’d like to see them go HS position player or roll the dice on a Brody Brecht/Jonathan Santucci college pitcher with big stuff and command issues.   At #22 and #32 maybe they can do both.
    • We've really needed Suarez to step up, and so far he has. He does this a couple more times, I might be a believer.
    • Been going downhill ever since Roy started calling for him in the pen. The jinx goes both ways.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...