Would you trade Gunnar Henderson for George Kirby or Spencer Strider?

[Billy F-Face3]

My 1st reaction to this question was negative. So I took a few days and tried to give it some thought.

I can see thr thinking that we have a gluttony of Shortstop options so it would make sense to pull off a blockbuster deal ti get an Ace pitcher. However, I wouldn't give up Gunnar for it. Nope. 

Gunnar is a rare talent. He's a big guy with a rare combination of power and speed. He has a cannon for an arm and can play 3B as well as Shortstop. He has also surprised me with how well he's played defense in the Majors so far and how much range he has for a big guy. 

If we were to keep the trade options alive, I would consider another SS but not Gunnar. Gunnar has talent you just can't teach. Even Jackson Holliday lacks Gunnar's speed. 

[Hallas]

How about Kirby and Cole Young for Gunnar?  That starts to get intriguing.

Or Strider and someone like Cade Kuehler for Gunnar? 

Edited January 26 by Hallas