Jump to content

I'm going to make a bold statement. I don't think Andy MacPhail is employed by the Orioles any more.


Snutchy

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 145
  • Created
  • Last Reply
And what do you see Angelos telling Buck in response?
I enjoy speculating on fantasy dialog.

Μετά από την εποχή που είχε πέρυσι έχετε το θράσος να μου πει να δαπανήσει περισσότερα από τα χρήματά μου;

I kept it clean since its a family board.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I'm not disputing your points, Trea. You probably have 1,000 posts making these same points. We get it. I'm simply saying that you should step back for a bit.

Remove Flanagan from things for one minute. AM is the GM of a team that has been completely embarrased over his tenure. Whether it's 30-3, brawls that start because we're sick of good teams kicking our butts, young guys failing to meet expectations or draft picks that have barely played. We've been embarrassed on many levels, constantly really.

Now...imagine you're the guy in charge of all of this. Your contract is up. You know your admirers from an organizational management standpoint are dwindling. Your days are numbered. Would you be happy? Would it affect your life? Would you become depressed?

Now, imagine this professional difficulty is as visible as his and you have a small but very vocal group of people who never shut up about it. Who always harp on what a failure you are. Who make the same case over and over and over and over again. Would that make you insular?

I think you just need to realize there are real people on the other end. Most don't have the struggle that Flanagan obviously had, but they're still real people with genuine human emotions.

AM is probably on his way out. You're constant harping about him is tantamount to your friend closing the door to hit your butt on the way out. It's hurtful, and not needed.

I highly doubt MacPhail is losing sleep at night because Jtrea keeps harping on his short comings. Come on man, I'm all about being respectful to players, managers and club officials, but they are in a public business so they know criticism is part of the business. Unlike Flanagan, MacPhail had no real attachment to the Baltimore Orioles other than the fact he was hired by them to do a job. I'm sure MacPhail has done the best he can do, but unfortunately, it appears his style won't work in a Division that requires something outside of the norm to be successful if you are not the Red $ox or Yankee$.

I think you are taking Flanagan's situation and applying it to all. I'm sure criticisms are not fun to hear, but I seriously don't think they are hurtful to MacPhail in anyway. He's been doing this a long time and he knows what comes with not winning. MacPhail came here with a plan and it did not work for various reasons. At the end of the day, he has to take responsibility for the failure and the criticism that comes along with it from the fans and media.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The local and national media scrutiny MacPhail's been subjected to given the performance of the Orioles over his tenure is about as hurtful as a kiss from a creepy aunt. Imagine the treatment he would be getting in New York, Boston or Philly.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.




  • Posts

    • Baltimore and DC surrounding population around 9 million. NYC around 24 million.
    • This is accurate based on pockets.  But the Yankees have positive Cash Flow even with the huge payroll, because they are the richest franchise in the MLB.  The fact that the owner can fund higher salaries is certainly important, but it isn't the same thing as team revenue.
    • These two paragraphs are not congruent.  I disagree that the Orioles have to resign Burnes.  I think they should be in on him, but they don't have to sign him. I completely agree that if they do not sign him the have to have another TOR.  I think counting on Bradish to return is a poor decision.  You hope so, but planning on it would be weak.  Same with assuming #2 status for Rodriquez.  His case is stronger of course, but still.  We have some depth IF we have a TOR and that should be Burnes or someone comparable.  
    • There are several. Snell, Pivetta, Bieber (depending on structure of the contract), Nick Martinez (swing type guy) and Heaney.  May be others. This is off the top of my head.
    • I think this is correct but I would say it differently.  I think Elias has done a great job constructing the organization and making it one of the top teams, complete teams, in baseball.  That was a huge hurdle from where he started and that has been a major success. Getting from a top MLB team to a successful playoff team may seem like a small jump but it is pretty large.  And Elias has been tentative at best at trying to make those changes.  He has taken an incremental path in hopes of maximizing his long term potential.  So far that really hasn't had much success.   But like Elias, we really should not assume that the changes needed to make that seemingly small jump from AL East contender to WS contender will not require some pretty big things.  I don't know if that is really different than what you are saying.  
    • It was never in hindsight. The Os were always against it. We had the numbers. We knew how bad it was going to effect the team.   That is why the MaSN deal was structured the way it was. It benefited the Os for a reason. That was essentially the compromise to having the team move to DC.
    • The Mets just had more exciting wins in one week than we had in four months.  I called us the Dull Orange Machine a few weeks ago for a reason.  Really boring team most of the season, with no personality at all.  They seemed to have a "get knocked down, stay down" mentality, which isn't fun to support as a fan.  There are a lot of very good reasons noted here as to why attendance wasn't great, but the energy around this team and the organization is just low and that can't help.  And a slow and boring offseason that doesn't move the needle much won't help attendance heading into next season either.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...