Jump to content

How is Roberts Not Your Leadoff Hitter?

BillySmith

By BillySmith
in Orioles Talk

Recommended Posts

Tony-OH Hangout Grand Counsel

Tony-OH

Posted
Posted
Do you think he would have to win the job with Buck as manager?

If you add Roberts to the current mix of candidates Buck is just going to hand him the job.

And we have a thread winner folks! ;)

It goes without saying that I hope they don't bring Roberts back. Markakis would be the best current option to leadoff but I hope DD acquires a better leadoff guy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
  • Replies 79
  • Created
  • Last Reply
wildcard Hangout Grand Counsel

wildcard

Posted
Posted
After the way Buck put an obviously not ready Roberts out there every day in 2012 that is exactly what I think will happen.

It doesn't help that Roberts' skill set does not translate to a utility infielder role.

Doesn't bother me at all that Roberts can only play one position as long as Flaherty is on the team. Flaherty can switch to SS or 3B and Roberts fills in at 2B.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Can_of_corn Hangout Grand Counsel

Can_of_corn

Posted
Posted
Doesn't bother me at all that Roberts can only play one position as long as Flaherty is on the team. Flaherty can switch to SS or 3B and Roberts fills in at 2B.

Right, so you have the "starter" jump around to accommodate the "backup". Buck likes structure and playing his starters. Unless you are the Rays teams don't jitterbug their starters all over the diamond.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Il BuonO Hangout Grand Counsel

Il BuonO

Posted
Posted
Doesn't bother me at all that Roberts can only play one position as long as Flaherty is on the team. Flaherty can switch to SS or 3B and Roberts fills in at 2B.

The problem with this is Buck's penchant for playing vets no matter how poorly they play. If Flaherty isn't playing well he can be sat or even sent down again, Roberts likely won't be sitting.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
wildcard Hangout Grand Counsel

wildcard

Posted
Posted
And we have a thread winner folks! ;)

It goes without saying that I hope they don't bring Roberts back. Markakis would be the best current option to leadoff but I hope DD acquires a better leadoff guy.

I think if DD thinks that Buck will just hand Roberts the job, Roberts will not be back. See Teagarden for an example. DD and Buck will have to agree that Roberts must earn his spot on the team for Roberts to get signed. JMO.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
El Gordo Hangout Grand Counsel

El Gordo

Posted
Posted
While I can see why Roberts is an option, I hope that the Orioles go in a different direction. My preference is to give Flaherty every opportunity to win the second base job. If Manny is not ready to start the season, sign a veteran like Michael Young to play third until Manny is healthy enough to play. Further, Young is much more versatile than Roberts and will give the team more roster flexiibility in case this scenario plays out. All that being said, IMO having Roberts on the roster much less leading off would be a mistake.
Michael Young has no defensive position to play anymore. Roberts would be a much better 2B choice than him.
Link to comment
Share on other sites
wildcard Hangout Grand Counsel

wildcard

Posted
Posted
Right, so you have the "starter" jump around to accommodate the "backup". Buck likes structure and playing his starters. Unless you are the Rays teams don't jitterbug their starters all over the diamond.

Buck has been known to move players around depending on the circumstances. Davis played 1B, LF. RF and DH in 2012.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
wildcard Hangout Grand Counsel

wildcard

Posted
Posted
If Buck is willing to not play Roberts then how do you explain what happened during that 17 game stretch in 2012? Roberts put up 415 OPS and a 16 OPS+ while playing horrendous defense and the only reason Buck stopped putting him the lineup is he got injured.

Roberts was a veteran player with a 40M contract. The understanding was he would play. Now he is a free agent. The understanding can he reset before signing Roberts.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Can_of_corn Hangout Grand Counsel

Can_of_corn

Posted
Posted
Roberts was a veteran player with a 40M contract. The understanding was he would play. Now he is a free agent. The understanding can he reset before signing Roberts.

Middle of a pennant race, drastically underperforming in every aspect of the game and you think it was just the contract that put Roberts out there?

Nice chatting with you but I think we are too far apart on this topic to have a middle ground.

Good day to you sir!

Link to comment
Share on other sites
wildcard Hangout Grand Counsel

wildcard

Posted
Posted
There were injuries to the outfielders. He got moved to DH because his defense at first was deemed worse then Reynolds.

Buck has been know to stick with players having defensive problems but he didn't with Davis at 1B in 2012. Buck could have stayed with Davis at DH or 1B and put someone else in the outfield if all Buck does is stick with his players at one position. However, that is not what Buck did. He moved Davis around as needed. Just like he can do with Flaherty if he starts at 2B but is needed at SS or 3B, Buck is not a inflexible as you make him out to be.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing

Orioles News and Information
Daily Organizational Boxscores

News

Orioles Roster Resource

Orioles Prospect Information

2022 Top 75 Prospects

Statistics

2022 Orioles Stats

2022 Orioles Minor League Stats

Baseball Savant Stats


  • Posts

    • Orioles0615
      ALDS First Pitch - game start time

      By Orioles0615 · Posted

      I am sure the O’s get screwed somehow. There is no way they can have the game and concert at the same time 
    • ledzepp8
      Trevor Bauer

      By ledzepp8 · Posted

      Exactly. You're presumed innocent. The onus isn't on Bauer to prove his innocence. It's on MLB or the justice system to prove his guilt.
    • Bahama O's Fan
      Game 1 Starter

      By Bahama O's Fan · Posted

      I would go Bradish game 1, no question. He's earned it Means game 2 because it's in Camden Yards. Teams will put righties up to face him and we have Waltimore to help protect against the long ball Grayson game 3 on the road Tough choice between Gibson or Kremer for game 4, but I bet Hyde gives the vet the nod. I think that means Bradish is available for game 5
    • IPlayGM
      Coby Mayo 2023

      By IPlayGM · Posted

      I understand your point, but 40 HRs with a solid OBP won’t be a waste no matter where he plays.
    • wildcard
      My 2023 second half and full regular season report card

      By wildcard · Posted

      Adley -  Had pretty much the same results as last year while playing 39 more games which are simply outstanding for a catcher. Handled the pitching staff as a leader, controlled the running game and hit well - 810 OPS. But his offense was very different this year.   In 2002 he hit righties - 889 OPS vs lefties - 552 OPS.  In 2023 he flipped that righties -778 OPS vs lefties  - 895 OPS.   He hits much better as a DH (874 OPS) vs C (786 OPS).  He is an on base machine 374 OBP.   He leads the team and the winning culture with his attitude and hugs. Grade A McCann - Agree Mountcastle - In an injury plagued year that cost him 132 at bats his biggest improvement was to his OBP at 328 compared to 309 in 2021 and 305 in 2022.   He seemed to adjust to the wall that has cost him power by hitting more up the middle.  While sharing 1B with O'Hearn instead of Mancini and DH with Adley he killed lefties with a 1052 OPS but fell off vs righties with a 640 OPS.  He seem like a platoon player at times.    He hit better as a DH (900 OPS) vs 1B (754). None of this is consistent on a year over year basis.  Some years he hits rights better, some years lefties, some years better as a 1B and some as a DH.    Grade  C+ while noting his improved OBP which is major IMO. O'Hearn - Agree Frazier - Agree Gunnar -  He has come so far so fast.  Deserves MVO.  Took over SS.  Much better SS than 3B at this point IMO.   Offensive weapon.  Grade A+ Urias -  Fell off in power from 16 HR to 4 HR and drop in  defense may have cost him his spot on the roster.  Grade D+ Mateo - Began the season as a potential starting SS but became a Backup SS.  As a utility player his speed on the base path and ability to steal (32 steals) is a weapon.    A game changer in close games which the O's play a lot.   Defense at SS dropped from elite to be roughly compared to Gunnar which is still a very high level.  Can't hit.  Grade as a utility player is a B-. Hays -  Has become a first half player over the last two years.  All-Star first half followed by a beat up body that costs him offensively in the 2nd half.  He plays hard.  Defensive standout in spite of losing speed as the year goes on due to injuries he plays through.  Wall has cost him some power but like Mountcastle the improved OBP to 325 is a impressive.  Agree with B- grade. Mullins - Agree.  Injuries cost him greatly.  Amazing he can play defense at such a high level even with the injuries. Grade C+ but an All Star when healthy. Santander - Agree Hicks - Wow.  Where did that come from.  Showed up at just the right time with Mullins injury and was a solid performer.   Unexpected.   Not the best backup centerfielder because his speed is average but can catch what he gets to.  Fine in the corners. Grade B- McKenna  - Agree Westburg -  Better that expected at 2B.  Rangy.  Solid.  Not as good at 3B.  SS only in emergencies.   Nice break in to the majors.  Future looks bright.  Grade B looks good.
    • Sports Guy
      Game 1 Starter

      By Sports Guy · Posted

      If you play  Texas, they are excellent Vs righties or lefties. OPaCY is much tougher on lefties (and righties) than Globe Field is. So, you may go with GRod in game 2 because the lefties are going to struggle to hit more in OPACY anyway but at the end of the day, it may not make of a difference. They also may just want the rookie pitching at home. Kyle Gibson is intriguing. He has a high OPS against the Rangers but he pitched for them in 2021 And he has a sub 3 ErA at home that year. In its first full year, Globe had a 97 park effect. This year it’s 106.  So that’s a factor too.  
    • Jagwar
      My 2023 second half and full regular season report card

      By Jagwar · Posted

      Thanks for a great detailed report @Frobby. I'm not sure I understand how the stats for Rutschman and McCann warrant identical B- grades. Sure... Adley missed high expectations and McCann was better than last year's backups, but for me their "test scores" would not each receive the same grade. 

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...