Jump to content

Lets go get swept at the Trop!


theobird

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 46
  • Created
  • Last Reply
On 9/28/2017 at 1:01 PM, ArtVanDelay said:

I have 11,000 posts on an Orioles message board.  Pretty sure I’m not a casual........

That just doesn’t make any sense.  I want the Orioles to have improved draft position and pool money, so that makes me a casual fan?

No, it doesn't. Wanting them to lose, in my personal opinion makes you a casual fan. Yes the games are meaningless now, but I never want to see my team lose no matter the reason. They improve their draft position and get pool money then what? We get another Matt Hosbgood and and its all for not. Just keep winning and everything else will fall into place. Just draft a World-Beater with your current selection in the order. Just keep winning.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The argument that one isn't a true fan, if they want the better draft pick or a good trade in the event of that they are out of the playoffs, comes off as insulting and overly- crudely- simplistic.

Would you rather win 500 games in 6 years or 475 and a WS in 6 years?  You play to win championships.  Period.  The team that wins the WS with 88 wins gets the same WS trophy as the 105 game WS winner. 

My point is this: you don't play to simply blindly win as many games as possible, no matter what.  Every year, playoff teams will rest their big guns to line up their rotations and rosters for a better chance to win in the playoffs, if they aren't still competing for their playoff slot.  They rest their starters knowing it won't give them as good a chance at winning the last few regular season games.  They aren't trying to win every single game no. matter. what. 

I don't really see how trying to get a better draft pick is much different.  It's looking at the end goal (winning championships) and doing what's in the best interest of obtaining said goal.  Now, I'm not suggesting deliberately throwing a game.  I expect professional athletes to give it their all and try to win the game.. all 27 outs.  But the manager and GM need to look ahead, play some young guys from AA or AAA.. see what they have.  Whoops, we got swept.

The idea that a fan who's strategically looking ahead for whatever slight advantages a team might be able to get going forward is the casual fan is laughable. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, gmelson26 said:

The argument that one isn't a true fan, if they want the better draft pick or a good trade in the event of that they are out of the playoffs, comes off as insulting and overly- crudely- simplistic.

Would you rather win 500 games in 6 years or 475 and a WS in 6 years?  You play to win championships.  Period.  The team that wins the WS with 88 wins gets the same WS trophy as the 105 game WS winner. 

My point is this: you don't play to simply blindly win as many games as possible, no matter what.  Every year, playoff teams will rest their big guns to line up their rotations and rosters for a better chance to win in the playoffs, if they aren't still competing for their playoff slot.  They rest their starters knowing it won't give them as good a chance at winning the last few regular season games.  They aren't trying to win every single game no. matter. what. 

I don't really see how trying to get a better draft pick is much different.  It's looking at the end goal (winning championships) and doing what's in the best interest of obtaining said goal.  Now, I'm not suggesting deliberately throwing a game.  I expect professional athletes to give it their all and try to win the game.. all 27 outs.  But the manager and GM need to look ahead, play some young guys from AA or AAA.. see what they have.  Whoops, we got swept.

The idea that a fan who's strategically looking ahead for whatever slight advantages a team might be able to get going forward is the casual fan is laughable. 

Even last place teams, teams long out of the running, have fans in the seats right up to the last game of the season.  What could be responsible for such bizarre behavior?  Could it be that there are people out there who appreciate the game on its own terms, regardless of any larger context?   For some of us, a hard-fought nine innings is rewarding enough to spend the time and money to attend and the rest can take care of itself.

So maybe it's the notion that "You play to win championships. Period" that's overly simplistic.  Or worse.  I've always wondered if this attitude is nothing more than the unfortunate byproduct of sports talk radio poisioning or too much fantasy baseball.  The title of this thread certainly makes you wonder.   Championships are a worthy goal and I won't go down the rabbit hole of who is and isn't a "true fan", but any fan who finds himself concocting strategic reasons for wanting his favorite team to lose needs to take a long, hard look at his thought process beginning with the proposition that these last few games are meaningless.  The meaning is rooted in the contest itself and it always will be.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, 24fps said:

Even last place teams, teams long out of the running, have fans in the seats right up to the last game of the season.  What could be responsible for such bizarre behavior?  Could it be that there are people out there who appreciate the game on its own terms, regardless of any larger context?   For some of us, a hard-fought nine innings is rewarding enough to spend the time and money to attend and the rest can take care of itself.

So maybe it's the notion that "You play to win championships. Period" that's overly simplistic.  Or worse.  I've always wondered if this attitude is nothing more than the unfortunate byproduct of sports talk radio poisioning or too much fantasy baseball.  The title of this thread certainly makes you wonder.   Championships are a worthy goal and I won't go down the rabbit hole of who is and isn't a "true fan", but any fan who finds himself concocting strategic reasons for wanting his favorite team to lose needs to take a long, hard look at his thought process beginning with the proposition that these last few games are meaningless.  The meaning is rooted in the contest itself and it always will be.

 

And that's all I got to say about that! :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • I'm curious to see if it is immediate IL or downshifting to Irvin's swingman role is possible. He has been preventing runs early in games, and if it is just stamina he might still be a puzzle piece in the upcoming stretch. Obviously possible something acute happened on one of the pitches yesterday, if so that might make him a 2025-2026 two year kind of guy like Mahle or Woodruff from this past offseason if somebody really likes him.
    • Tampa also rolled the dice on him one offseason with leaving him off the 40-man roster when his name was prominent as a top Rule 5 candidate. Nobody did the Anthony Santander thing out of A-ball with a catcher. He was a high school bat who commanded a $1.6M bonus, and some of why high school catchers maybe have 2nd place to high school pitchers as a risky demographic is they take so long to develop. The Mariners have Cal Raleigh now and Harry Ford later.    It makes "who will the backup catcher be in 2025" less of a mystery starting out the offseason.
    • Sure, he’s by no means somebody that the Orioles should be overly resistant to part with if he’s a necessary piece in a deadline deal. But he’s not superfluous in the system so he’s not somebody I would expect they look to offer up as trade bait. I think the Orioles will try to deal from their strength in infield, corner OF and C, and avoid trying to deal any pitchers or CF. But if the team they’re trading with is demanding pitching or CF in return, Fabian and others the Orioles would probably prefer to hang onto will be on the table. Like when the Orioles traded Zach Showalter in the Flaherty deal last year, likely because the Cardinals were demanding pitching. 
    • Please please please stop with the Bauer! It's unbelievably tired, and smarter minds than you or I have decided that he's not worth the trouble. That means something. ME knows what he's doing.
    • It’s been a dramatic reversal. His command also looked good in Spring Training - 4 BB in 10.2 IP - so it was surprising to see it so bad early in the year. Hopefully it was just that back injury leading to the command issues and he’s over it now. 
    • Teams will never give him the hoped for mega bucks.  Even if he was unlikely to ever get much more than a two year deal.  No it seems no team will give him even a real good one year deal.  He will be forced to accept a "prove it deal" Honestly it might be time to go the Trevor Bauer deal.  Sign him for one year deal and if he is too much distraction you cut him.  No way a team does not sign him if he is not being intentionally black balled.  The Orioles could afford to take the chance being a great team a couple of arms away from winning it all.  
    • Considering we were DFA and losing him for zippo it a decent pick up. BTW, Hunt is showing in Seattle’s top 30 (#23) on MLB.com. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...