Jump to content

Meoli on the 1st base situation


Sports Guy

Recommended Posts

3 minutes ago, Morgan423 said:

I'm way late to this party, but thought you'd be curious.  I caught a YT video about two weeks or so before the end of this season that had the topic of pitch framing.  During it, the presenter laid out a graph with a wide range of catchers, from the absolute worst framers in the league to the absolute best.  And Adley?

Adley was a zero, on that stat scale, which was based on how many runs that each catcher had gained or lost his team via stealing or costing strikes through framing (because not only is there a neutral result where the ump didn't buy your ball to strike frame job, there's actually a negative result where the pitcher threw an actual strike and because of the way you received it, it got called a ball).

So no, he's definitely not helping us through pitch framing.   

He was an asset in the past, he wasn't this most recent season.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 minutes ago, Moose Milligan said:

No one wants to discuss that his overall production has declined for three years in a row. 

On an annual basis that is probably true because his second half was so bad. However he was on pace for a career year in the first half '24 before he hit an absolute wall. He was hitting .294/.821 through the end of June and deservedly started the ASG, leading AL catchers in both fWAR and bWAR at that time. The data could fit a gradual decline narrative or playing through an injury/slump narrative. As an optimist I lean to the latter but we probably want to start thinking about depth and alternatives. His second half was so bad and went on long enough that you have to take it seriously. https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2024/06/30/mlb-all-star-roster-projections-positional-war-leaders/74261534007/

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

12 minutes ago, Aristotelian said:

On an annual basis that is probably true because his second half was so bad. However he was on pace for a career year in the first half '24 before he hit an absolute wall. He was hitting .294/.821 through the end of June and deservedly started the ASG, leading AL catchers in both fWAR and bWAR at that time. The data could fit a gradual decline narrative or playing through an injury/slump narrative. As an optimist I lean to the latter but we probably want to start thinking about depth and alternatives. His second half was so bad and went on long enough that you have to take it seriously. https://www.usatoday.com/story/sports/mlb/2024/06/30/mlb-all-star-roster-projections-positional-war-leaders/74261534007/

I don’t care what he was on pace to do.  It’s not being intellectually honest and refuses to acknowledge the whole story.  I’m glad you’re an optimist and I’d like to join you there but I also can’t ignore the decline that I’m seeing.  I also can’t ignore that he plays the most physically demanding position on the field.  If he was hurt, he wasn’t hurt enough to go on the IL.  

He came up in 2022 and put up 5.4 WAR in 113 games/470 plate appearances. Over a full season, he’d probably have been in MVP WAR range. 

2023, 4.3 WAR but in significantly more games and significantly more plate appearances:  154/687

2024: 3.4 WAR in 148 games, 638 plate appearances. 

No matter how you cut it, no matter what excuses you want to make for him, his rookie year is by far and away the best season he’s had.  His OPS+ has declined each year. 

If he weren’t a catcher, maybe I wouldn’t be this bothered by it. But even if he had nagging injuries this year, IMO, that’s not a good harbinger of things to come. 

Like I said, I can’t ignore what I’ve seen.  His biggest WAR season came in his first year and in the lowest amount of games played.  I’d love to be wrong but I also wouldn’t be surprised if we’re witnessing a really slow decline.  

If you don’t believe that, you have to at least recognize that that possibility does exist and that it was always inevitable that he’d have to move off catcher anyway.  

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Moose Milligan said:

I don’t care what he was on pace to do.  It’s not being intellectually honest and refuses to acknowledge the whole story.  I’m glad you’re an optimist and I’d like to join you there but I also can’t ignore the decline that I’m seeing.  I also can’t ignore that he plays the most physically demanding position on the field.  If he was hurt, he wasn’t hurt enough to go on the IL.  

He came up in 2022 and put up 5.4 WAR in 113 games/470 plate appearances. Over a full season, he’d probably have been in MVP WAR range. 

2023, 4.3 WAR but in significantly more games and significantly more plate appearances:  154/687

2024: 3.4 WAR in 148 games, 638 plate appearances. 

No matter how you cut it, no matter what excuses you want to make for him, his rookie year is by far and away the best season he’s had.  His OPS+ has declined each year. 

If he weren’t a catcher, maybe I wouldn’t be this bothered by it. But even if he had nagging injuries this year, IMO, that’s not a good harbinger of things to come. 

Like I said, I can’t ignore what I’ve seen.  His biggest WAR season came in his first year and in the lowest amount of games played.  I’d love to be wrong but I also wouldn’t be surprised if we’re witnessing a really slow decline.  

If you don’t believe that, you have to at least recognize that that possibility does exist and that it was always inevitable that he’d have to move off catcher anyway.  

 

There was another thread about Adley’s usage on a daily basis regardless of CA/DH,  last offseason. Carlton Fisk and Realmuto are good comparisons of games played.  Adley is neither and they need to back off at least some of the playing time.


Also, no more wall sit commercials for pnc bank

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 minutes ago, Since1984 said:

There was another thread about Adley’s usage on a daily basis regardless of CA/DH,  last offseason. Carlton Fisk and Realmuto are good comparisons of games played.  Adley is neither and they need to back off at least some of the playing time.


Also, no more wall sit commercials for pnc bank

I am 100% on board with the idea that a day at DH is not a "day off" but he only played 103 games at catcher and another 45 at DH.  If he can't handle that workload at 26 he has to improve his conditioning.  (2023 was 110 and 46 games played)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Moose Milligan said:

I don’t care what he was on pace to do.  It’s not being intellectually honest and refuses to acknowledge the whole story.  I’m glad you’re an optimist and I’d like to join you there but I also can’t ignore the decline that I’m seeing.  I also can’t ignore that he plays the most physically demanding position on the field.  If he was hurt, he wasn’t hurt enough to go on the IL.  

He came up in 2022 and put up 5.4 WAR in 113 games/470 plate appearances. Over a full season, he’d probably have been in MVP WAR range. 

2023, 4.3 WAR but in significantly more games and significantly more plate appearances:  154/687

2024: 3.4 WAR in 148 games, 638 plate appearances. 

No matter how you cut it, no matter what excuses you want to make for him, his rookie year is by far and away the best season he’s had.  His OPS+ has declined each year. 

If he weren’t a catcher, maybe I wouldn’t be this bothered by it. But even if he had nagging injuries this year, IMO, that’s not a good harbinger of things to come. 

Like I said, I can’t ignore what I’ve seen.  His biggest WAR season came in his first year and in the lowest amount of games played.  I’d love to be wrong but I also wouldn’t be surprised if we’re witnessing a really slow decline.  

If you don’t believe that, you have to at least recognize that that possibility does exist and that it was always inevitable that he’d have to move off catcher anyway.  

 

How is this really slow? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Mountcastle and his RH bat is staying IMO. 

O'Hearn moves on and Kjerstad takes his spot as the LH platoon bat at 1B

Holliday breaks camp as starting 2B although I'm intrigued with the idea of moving him to CF given Jackson Merrill's success with that.

O's sign a solid veteran bat for RF (fingers crossed).  I don't hate the thought of Santander returning, but I'm not in love with it either.

Mayo starts the season at AAA - he'll be 23 in December so it won't kill him even if it frustrates the hell out of rest of us.  I don't see Elias having more than 2 of Holliday/Kjerstad/Mayo working on their transition to ML at once even if Kjerstad is a weak side platoon.

That's the way I see it breaking out.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

I don’t care what he was on pace to do.  It’s not being intellectually honest and refuses to acknowledge the whole story.  I’m glad you’re an optimist and I’d like to join you there but I also can’t ignore the decline that I’m seeing.  I also can’t ignore that he plays the most physically demanding position on the field.  If he was hurt, he wasn’t hurt enough to go on the IL.  

He came up in 2022 and put up 5.4 WAR in 113 games/470 plate appearances. Over a full season, he’d probably have been in MVP WAR range. 

2023, 4.3 WAR but in significantly more games and significantly more plate appearances:  154/687

2024: 3.4 WAR in 148 games, 638 plate appearances. 

No matter how you cut it, no matter what excuses you want to make for him, his rookie year is by far and away the best season he’s had.  His OPS+ has declined each year. 

If he weren’t a catcher, maybe I wouldn’t be this bothered by it. But even if he had nagging injuries this year, IMO, that’s not a good harbinger of things to come. 

Like I said, I can’t ignore what I’ve seen.  His biggest WAR season came in his first year and in the lowest amount of games played.  I’d love to be wrong but I also wouldn’t be surprised if we’re witnessing a really slow decline.  

If you don’t believe that, you have to at least recognize that that possibility does exist and that it was always inevitable that he’d have to move off catcher anyway.  

 

I did recognize the possibility. As I said it's a serious concern.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 hours ago, Jim'sKid26 said:

One thing he did not mention is the impact on the DH.

Adley will DH some against RHP. Does Mayo DH some against LHP? I would think so.

I personally don't want Adley DHing. I'd rather see him get more regular days off.

I've never liked the idea of having a catcher as DH anyway. Just acquire good LH or RH hitters who can serve well as DH and you don't have to deal with it. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It would be kind of funny to have 1-1's as DH and 2B.

I agree there might be something to more full days off.    The first 3 years the Orioles have ridden Adley hard with many of the best talents completely unready.    The last 3 years I hope will be different.

Kjerstad, Mayo and Basallo do what Elias hopes...Adley might not make first string at Orioles DH.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

No one wants to discuss that his overall production has declined for three years in a row. 

I was I’m hoping his arm would get better as well, but it hasn’t. His caught stealing percentage since 2022 is 39%, 22% last year and fell to 19% this season. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

I don’t care what he was on pace to do.  It’s not being intellectually honest and refuses to acknowledge the whole story.  I’m glad you’re an optimist and I’d like to join you there but I also can’t ignore the decline that I’m seeing.  I also can’t ignore that he plays the most physically demanding position on the field.  If he was hurt, he wasn’t hurt enough to go on the IL.  

He came up in 2022 and put up 5.4 WAR in 113 games/470 plate appearances. Over a full season, he’d probably have been in MVP WAR range. 

2023, 4.3 WAR but in significantly more games and significantly more plate appearances:  154/687

2024: 3.4 WAR in 148 games, 638 plate appearances. 

No matter how you cut it, no matter what excuses you want to make for him, his rookie year is by far and away the best season he’s had.  His OPS+ has declined each year. 

If he weren’t a catcher, maybe I wouldn’t be this bothered by it. But even if he had nagging injuries this year, IMO, that’s not a good harbinger of things to come. 

Like I said, I can’t ignore what I’ve seen.  His biggest WAR season came in his first year and in the lowest amount of games played.  I’d love to be wrong but I also wouldn’t be surprised if we’re witnessing a really slow decline.  

If you don’t believe that, you have to at least recognize that that possibility does exist and that it was always inevitable that he’d have to move off catcher anyway.  

 

A LOT of players peak in their first three years, including a lot of excellent players. Markakis is an interesting Oriole-related example. Some of it is injuries and wear and tear on players but a lot of it is just aging. The good news is that a 3 WAR catcher, or any other position for that matter, is a valuable player. Markakis, for example, only had two seasons with a bWAR higher than 2.9. Adley, even with the late season plunge, had a very valuable season. But it didn’t meet our expectations and he probably won’t meet our expectations going forward. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • Manny- Low leverage - 969 OPS High leverage - 1018 Arod- Low leverage - 942 High leverage - 952   I'd be fine with either.
    • I don’t think “not taking accountability/responsibility/blame” is Colton’s issue. Frankly, I think anyone who thinks that is an issue for him hasn’t been paying very close attention. I get that people — especially pissed off, frustrated fans, which we all are — want to see someone taking responsibility and accepting blame and acknowledging how big and crushing their failure was. But I don’t think that’s always a very productive mindset for professional athletes.  No one wants a shooter who comes into the huddle before the final shot saying “guys, I know I’m 1 for 13, I’m killing the team, and I’m really sorry about it. Try to avoid passing me the ball if you can because I just don’t have it and I’ve already let the team down enough tonight.” No one wants a press corner who breaks the defensive huddle thinking “this receiver’s way better than me, he just torched me on that last play, realistically I got no chance to hang with him. I better just sit back and give him a big cushion, try to minimize the damage.” And no one wants a hitter in baseball who can’t let go of his failures and keeps beating himself up for letting the team down. There’s a reason why you’d probably rather have a Manny Ramirez — blissfully indifferent to his prior failures, focused only on each fleeting moment, deeply satisfied that he’s the right man for the job — up there in high leverage moments than an Alex Rodriguez, who was constantly fretting about his performance, legacy, image, etc. It’s hard to say for sure from the outside. But I’d lay pretty good money that our kids (and especially Colton) cared and beat themselves up too much for their various struggles and failures, rather than too little. 
    • I was at one of those games in Japan, when the O's played the Tokyo Giants. My Dad was in the Navy, stationed as a small listening post called Kamiseya. We lived there from 1970-1975. The base organized a bus trip to the game, and I went, it was my 9th birthday present. Loved baseball, played little league, my favorite team at that time was the Dodgers, as my parents were both huge Dodger fans. But it was a tepid connection. Once the tour was announced, the Stars and Stripes newspaper had an article about the Orioles almost every day, and I ate it up. It was the beginning of my lifelong addiction to the Orange and Black. When game day came, I remember getting up early and trying to figure out the lineup and starting pitcher they'd use that day. My 9 year old brain was thinking they were going to play this like a world series game. I don't remember too much of the game, other than they won, but they won most of those games. None of the big 4 started, and the only position player I remember for sure was Frank Robinson played left field because my Dad's friend Tom Holstein would yell "Hey Frank quick picking your nose and get out there" every time Frank would saunter out to left field. Over the years, I've been fortunate to talk with Boog Powell, Jim Palmer, and Merv Rettenmund about that tour. The one thing they all said is that they were bloody exhausted, having just come off a full season and a 7 game loss in the World Series.
    • Kjerstad will be given a big chance unless AS comes back. Holliday will get big playing time. Not quite so sure about Mayo unless mounty gets injured. He’s only played like 10 games at first, and not very well. How much do you think he can get done offseason and ST? It’s only 1B so who knows  
    • Yes that is exactly what I said. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...