Who are the O's best 25?

[wildcard]

Forget the contracts. Forget the options. Lets said everyone is healthy. Who are the best 25 major league players in the O's organization? If you think a minor league player would produce better than a major leaguer put him on your team.

[Bahama O's Fan]

Tillman

Chen

Gonzalez

Gausman

Norris

Jiminez

Britton

Oday

Hunter

Matusz

Brach

Wright

Wieters

Joseph

Davis

Schoop

Hardy

Machado

DeAza

Jones

Pearce

Snider

Young

Flaherty

[wildcard]

Forget the contracts. Forget the options. Lets said everyone is healthy. Who are the best 25 major league players in the O's organization? If you think a minor league player would produce better than a major leaguer put him on your team.

OK, no one is interested. So at least I will post mine.

1B Davis

2B Schoop

SS Hardy

3B Machado

LF De Aza

CF Jones

RF Snider

C Wieters

DH Pearce

Bench

Cabrera

Joseph

Young

Reimold

Tillman

Chen

Gonzalez

Norris

Gausman

Britton

O'Day

Hunter

Brach

Matusz

W Wright

Jimenez

[wildcard]

Tillman

Chen

Gonzalez

Gausman

Norris

Jiminez

Britton

Oday

Hunter

Matusz

Brach

Wright

Wieters

Joseph

Davis

Schoop

Hardy

Machado

DeAza

Jones

Pearce

Snider

Young

Flaherty

That's 24.

[Bahama O's Fan]

That's 24.

Sorry, add Cabrera, if we are putting the best there regardless of position.

[weams]

Tillman

Chen

Gonzalez

Gausman

Norris

Jiminez

Britton

Oday

Hunter

Matusz

Brach

Wright

Wieters

Joseph

Davis

Schoop

Hardy

Machado

DeAza

Jones

Pearce

Snider

Young

Flaherty

Sorry' date=' add Cabrera, if we are putting the best there regardless of position.[/quote']

Since Wieters is injured, I pick Lavarnway. And since Hardy is hurt, Garcia. Otherwise, I am good with yours.

[wildcard]

Since Wieters is injured, I pick Lavarnway. And since Hardy is hurt, Garcia. Otherwise, I am good with yours.

The whole idea is everyone is healthy.

[weams]

The whole idea is everyone is healthy.

I guess if they really were, I'd have to drop Cabrera and Lavarnway. I guess.

[weams]

Pretty funny that a week or so ago you didn't think much of Snider at all.

I am convincing.

[Can_of_corn]

Interesting that no one is picking Harvey over someone like Brach.

I think he would have no problem getting out major leaguers in 1-2 inning bursts.

[wildcard]

Pretty funny that a week or so ago you didn't think much of Snider at all.

He was bad for years. Had a good 2nd half last year. Was not hitting in ST until the last week. Then had two homers. I said in another thread I don't want to root against the guy. I want to see him do well.

http://forum.orioleshangout.com/forums/showthread.php/147178-O-s-questions-to-start-the-season

[weams]

Interesting that no one is picking Harvey over someone like Brach.

I think he would have no problem getting out major leaguers in 1-2 inning bursts.

I guess you are. I'd love to see your list.

[Orioles0615]

I for one and super happy Chris Davis suspension is over.

[CA-ORIOLE]

OK, no one is interested. So at least I will post mine.

1B Davis

2B Schoop

SS Hardy

3B Machado

LF De Aza

CF Jones

RF Snider

C Wieters

DH Pearce

Bench

Cabrera

Joseph

Young

Reimold

I think this is what I'd say for position players. Being without Wieter's really wouldn't bother me.

[Aristotelian]

If we are going purely overall value rather than constructing a balanced team, I am not going with any relievers other than Britton and O'Day. I would rather have position players and starters.

Position players:

1. Jones 2. Machado 3. Hardy 4. Pearce 5. Davis 6. Wieters 7. De Aza 8. Snider 9. Schoop 10. Joseph 11. Cabrera 12. Flaherty 13. Alvarez 14. Reimold 15. Young

Pitchers:

1. Tillman 2. Chen 3. Gausman 4. Gonzo 5. Norris 6. Britton 7. O'Day 8. Jimenez 9. Tyler Wilson 10. Zach Davies

If I am trying to construct a roster with a balanced team, that is a different question.