Jump to content

Tim Dierkes: Orioles should trade John Means


waynebug

Recommended Posts

47 minutes ago, waynebug said:

There's also the issue that if you extend him you're buying into his age 32 season.

Dierkes is the owner and creator of MLB Trade Rumors.  He gets 100s of thousands of views every day.

Today's Mailbag was for subscribers only.  I think I pay $3 a month.

"Quint" asked  would he trade Means and what could he expect to get in return.   He mentioned outfielder Robert Hassell of the Padres currently the #37 prospect in somebody's eyes. 

Sounds misguided.  Trading Means for an outfield prospect.  Dierkes must be a Padres fan.

 
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I said when the idea came up this spring:

If you even want to start the conversation its two top 50 global prospects.  Then we'll figure out the rest.

I'm not interested in a "reasonable" return.  A "fair" return.  If that's your offer, keep on walking.

If we trade Means- and I'm not saying I'm unwilling, see above- I don't see how it is possible we improve next year.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

28 minutes ago, Pickles said:

I said when the idea came up this spring:

If you even want to start the conversation its two top 50 global prospects.  Then we'll figure out the rest.

I'm not interested in a "reasonable" return.  A "fair" return.  If that's your offer, keep on walking.

If we trade Means- and I'm not saying I'm unwilling, see above- I don't see how it is possible we improve next year.

That last sentence revolves around the notion that no other moves will be made for the staff.  While that's a distinct possibility, I don't believe they could trade Means and not find a decent replacement.  Now I doubt they sign someone like Robbie Ray, but if they traded Means and signed Ray, I'd be happy.

Means is a good pitcher, not a great one.  I suppose we can debate on what "reasonable" and "fair" means.  But I don't think any of us should get our hopes up and be "blown away" on a return for Means.  That's not likely to happen if he's traded.

The market, IMO, always wins.  We might like to think starting the conversation centers around two top 50 global prospects.  The market might tell us different.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Covid, and our current crop or “starting pitching” prospects in the MLB, both pushed our window back. I’d trade Mullins and Means. Mancini is a given. Yes. We’ll be the worst team in baseball again.
 

2023 will be hopeful at MLB level and we will have an absolute stacked system that will be top 1-10 in MLB for years even with the graduation of top prospects. 
 

Should we try and get lucky in 2023?  Or should we be an absolute dynasty from 2024+?

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

In theory you could use Robert Hassell to play centerfield and then it would give the option to trade Mullins. 

I think at some point you have to hold onto your better players and Means might be a guy you want to keep.

If you get blown away by an offer for Means then consider trading him, but don’t trade him just to accumulate more prospects. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

16 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

Nothing misguided about it.  If you trade Means, you trade him for the best package you can get, OFer or not.

I agree you would prefer to target other areas though.

O's have no reason to trade Means unless it improves their pitching.  Trading him for an outfield prospect is misguided.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, wildcard said:

O's have no reason to trade Means unless it improves their pitching.  Trading him for an outfield prospect is misguided.

You can always trade the OF prospects for pitching.  You don’t have to solve your problems with one move.

If the Os decide they want to trade Means, you trade him for the best package you can get. It would be irresponsible and dumb to do anything else.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

That last sentence revolves around the notion that no other moves will be made for the staff.  While that's a distinct possibility, I don't believe they could trade Means and not find a decent replacement.  Now I doubt they sign someone like Robbie Ray, but if they traded Means and signed Ray, I'd be happy.

Means is a good pitcher, not a great one.  I suppose we can debate on what "reasonable" and "fair" means.  But I don't think any of us should get our hopes up and be "blown away" on a return for Means.  That's not likely to happen if he's traded.

The market, IMO, always wins.  We might like to think starting the conversation centers around two top 50 global prospects.  The market might tell us different.  

It isn't impossible for them to trade Means and improve next year.  It's just highly unlikely.

When the market is unfavorable, you don't make the deal.  That's how you "beat" the market.

Means pitching like a top 10 pitcher in July gets you two top 50 prospects.  So you wait.

And if it never materializes, if he gets injured or regresses, what did you miss out on?  Josh Bell (The prospect we received from the LAD for George Sherrill)?

That won't kill your rebuild.  Trading your best pitcher, and one of your best developmental successes, for nothing will.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

4 hours ago, sportsfan8703 said:

Gotta trade him. We’re definitely going to be terrible again next year. 2023 would be a 2012 type miracle. We need pieces for 2023+.  Keep stockpiling the system. It’ll pay off in a big way and not just an ALDS and WC win. 

So trade everyone with some possible trade value and more than two years of ML experience for prospects who may or may not become major leaguers? Or is it three years?

When does this "stink today and hope for tomorrow" stuff end?   :confused: 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yes we should, and quickly.

 

I checked Seattle’s top 30, they don’t have any left handers who are near, and they don’t have very many right handers who are near either. Seattle would love to have a guy like Means, And if they miss the playoffs in the next couple weeks it will only be by a game or two, and a meaningful pitcher Could’ve made the difference, although their offense is woof.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • For decades the technique of “sweating a leg” or injured area has been a mainstay in conservative management of equine leg injuries, as well as improving cosmetic appearance in certain situations. While topical medications and application techniques vary greatly, all sweats have three common ingredients: A topical medication consisting of a base (traditionally nitrofurazone, or Fura-Zone, ointment) often mixed with various additives, most commonly an anti-inflammatory (a steroid such as dexamethasone or a non-steroidal anti-­inflammatory such as ­diclofenac), and dimethyl sulfoxide (DMSO) as a carrying agent. Plastic wrap. A firmly applied stable ­bandage. The purpose of a sweat is to apply moist heat and compression to a structure to increase the tissue temperature, stimulate circulation, and aid in the removal of edema (fluid swelling). Edema occurs when the fluid that naturally leaks from blood vessels is not effectively carried away by the lymphatic system, due to poor circulation or conditions in which excess fluid leakage overcomes normal lymphatic return capacity. The nitrofurazone (or other base ingredient) creates a moist environment, while the DMSO stimulates blood flow and helps carry any other medications in the mixture into the tissues. Saran or other plastic wrap helps keep the area moist and warm, while the stable bandage helps further retain heat and compresses the swollen tissues to help the lymphatic system clear up excess extracellular fluid. Sweating is best used once the acute stage of inflammation has resolved, since you do not want to add further heat to freshly damaged tissue. Ice and cooling clay poultices are more appropriate choices in those initial stages. Once things have settled down and healing has begun, you can use a sweat to reduce edema, encourage circulation, and aid absorption of topical medication. Ask your veterinarian when it’s appropriate to start sweating—usually when there’s no obvious heat in the affected limb. Sweats are also useful for managing old injuries that have resulted in stiffened tissues, such as an old suspensory ligament injury with scarring or the thickened capsule of an arthritic joint. Keeping those areas warm and supple can prevent repeat injury and help a horse feel more comfortable, particularly at the start of exercise when core and tissue temperatures are still below optimal for maximum function and flexibility. In cases when an area is not easy to bandage, you can replace the plastic wrap and stable bandage with a neoprene boot shaped to fit the area being sweated, such as a hock or knee. Neoprene wraps are also used to sweat and reduce the throatlatch area in conformation horses to give it a cleaner appearance. When using neoprene we typically skip the DMSO because it can create excess heat to the point of skin irritation. If DMSO is an ingredient in your sweat, be sure the leg is completely dry before application because when DMSO mixes with water, a significant exothermic (heat-releasing) reaction can occur to the detriment of skin health. Also avoid using DMSO on scrapes or skin injuries. Some horses with very sensitive skin, particularly nonpigmented limbs, can be sweated effectively with just a little rubbing alcohol, plastic wrap, and a bandage. With extremely sensitive horses, place the plastic wrap over the cotton (or pillow wrap or no-bow) so it’s not directly against the skin. Nitrofurazone-based sweats will stain the skin and hair yellow, so an alcohol-based sweat might be a better choice if you’re headed for the show ring. Sweats are typically applied on a 12-hours-on, 12-hours-off schedule; however, your veterinarian might have different instructions depending on your horse’s situation. Most veterinarians make a medicated sweat for these purposes and can give you specific instructions on safe use and medication withdrawal time. Remember to wear gloves when applying a sweat to protect yourself, particularly if DMSO is an ingredient.      
    • You spoke a bit soon.  
    • Both were infielders drafted 1-1 out of High School so they are kind of the same. 🤣
    • He’s pitched 12 innings and given up 4 earned runs. WHIP is 1.05 … Probably pitching an inning per appearance.    My guess is they are trying to get him straightened out.
    • Positive, with the injury situation we desperately need one of the new starters to come in and just play well for a few starts.  Help this team get on a bit of a run and ease the starter worries for at least a few weeks.
    • I’m a bit concerned to be honest. I am not normally someone who is tough on prospects and always say to be patient. He doesn’t look to go opposite field. Then I started checking his minor league stuff and everything is pulled. Some players were able to have decent careers doing this like Kevin Miller. He has a lot of time on his side and a great group of players/coaches to help him through this. Every one of these guys struggled.
    • I think he’s going to get it and probably goes back when Westburg returns. 
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...