Jump to content

If you could only keep one of these 2 players...


Billy F-Face3

Recommended Posts

24 minutes ago, Billy F-Face3 said:

If you could only keep 1, and you had to choose between Jorge Mateo and Ramon Urias, who are you keeping on the Orioles? And why?

This is purely for a hypothetical trade scenario.

Urias and it really isn't close for me.  Much more steady of a player,  rarely gives away at bats.   Less flashy, but much more solid and consistent. 

Edited by forphase1
Added why.
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, bpilktree said:

More consistent?  Urias average OBP slugging and Ops by month over last two seasons.

April 22   .194/.239/.224/.463

May 22.   .260/.309/.477/.787

june 22.    .167/.211/.556/.766

July 22.     .329/.380/.575/.955

August 22  .221/.262/.368/.631

Sept. 22     .258/.370/.371/.741

April 23      .261/.354/.348/.702

May 23       .222/.300/.278/.578

Urias is a great defender and is versatile but  has no speed, doesn’t hit for great average, doesn’t hit for many extra base hits and up and down.  He will be 29 this week so we know who he is.  
 

Mateo has tools other guys in the system don’t have with top level speed, and excellent defense.  You basically have another Urias in the system in Ortiz that can do the same type things with the glove and has higher upside with bat imo.  If we could swap Urias for a quality left handed reliever I would do it in a heart beat and let Ortiz take his utility role.  

Yes, more consistent.  His lowest OPS in that list you posted was .463 and highest was .955.  Compare that to Mateo who just over the past 2 months has a high of 1.044 and a low of .285!  If you removed the highest and lowest for Urias, he has had between .578 and .787 every month.  Mateo, over the same span and also throwing out his highest and lowest, had had a high of .819 and a low of .502.  So yeah, overall Urias is more consistent overall than Mateo.  Certainly never as good as Mateo on his best, but also not as ice cold as Mateo can get for an extended period, more or less.  Honestly I don't want either starting on a regular basis and think the team will be better over all when one or both are not on the team any longer or are in a pure utility/substitution role.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

40 minutes ago, bpilktree said:

More consistent?  Urias average OBP slugging and Ops by month over last two seasons.

April 22   .194/.239/.224/.463

May 22.   .260/.309/.477/.787

june 22.    .167/.211/.556/.766

July 22.     .329/.380/.575/.955

August 22  .221/.262/.368/.631

Sept. 22     .258/.370/.371/.741

April 23      .261/.354/.348/.702

May 23       .222/.300/.278/.578

Urias is a great defender and is versatile but  has no speed, doesn’t hit for great average, doesn’t hit for many extra base hits and up and down.  He will be 29 this week so we know who he is.  
 

Mateo has tools other guys in the system don’t have with top level speed, and excellent defense.  You basically have another Urias in the system in Ortiz that can do the same type things with the glove and has higher upside with bat imo.  If we could swap Urias for a quality left handed reliever I would do it in a heart beat and let Ortiz take his utility role.  

How about over the course of a career...not just last year:

Mar/Apr - .289/.307/.597

May - .331/.420/.752

June - .333/.649/.982

July - .374/.477/.851

Aug - .297/.398/.695

Sept/Oct - .400/.414/.814

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, bpilktree said:

More consistent?  Urias average OBP slugging and Ops by month over last two seasons.

April 22   .194/.239/.224/.463

May 22.   .260/.309/.477/.787

june 22.    .167/.211/.556/.766

July 22.     .329/.380/.575/.955

August 22  .221/.262/.368/.631

Sept. 22     .258/.370/.371/.741

April 23      .261/.354/.348/.702

May 23       .222/.300/.278/.578

Urias is a great defender and is versatile but  has no speed, doesn’t hit for great average, doesn’t hit for many extra base hits and up and down.  He will be 29 this week so we know who he is.  
 

Mateo has tools other guys in the system don’t have with top level speed, and excellent defense.  You basically have another Urias in the system in Ortiz that can do the same type things with the glove and has higher upside with bat imo.  If we could swap Urias for a quality left handed reliever I would do it in a heart beat and let Ortiz take his utility role.  

Why do folks follow up "gut feel" comments with amazing facts to the contrary??

Well done with the analysis.  That's not very consistent at all.  Right now, I'd trade both of them.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.



  • Posts

    • A little funny to have provided descriptions of the hits (“weak” single; “500 foot” HR). FIP doesn’t care about any of that either, so it’s kind of an odd thing to add in an effort to make ERA look bad.  Come in, strike out the first hitter, then give up three 108 MPH rocket doubles off the wall. FIP thinks you were absolutely outstanding, and it’s a shame your pathetic defense and/or sheer bad luck let you down. Next time you’ll (probably) get the outcomes you deserve. They’re both flawed. So is xFIP. So is SIERA. So is RA/9. So is WPA. So is xERA. None of them are perfect measures of how a pitcher’s actual performance was, because there’s way too much context and too many variables for any one metric to really encompass.  But when I’m thinking about awards, for me at least, it ends up having to be about the actual outcomes. I don’t really care what a hitter’s xWOBA is when I’m thinking about MVP, and the same is true for pitchers. Did you get the outs? Did the runs score? That’s the “value” that translates to the scoreboard and, ultimately, to the standings. So I think the B-R side of it is more sensible for awards.  I definitely take into account the types of factors that you (and other pitching fWAR advocates) reference as flaws. So if a guy plays in front of a particular bad defense or had a particularly high percentage of inherited runners score, I’d absolutely adjust my take to incorporate that info. And I also 100% go to Fangraphs first when I’m trying to figure out which pitchers we should acquire (i.e., for forward looking purposes).  But I just can’t bring myself say that my Cy Young is just whichever guy had the best ratio of Ks to BBs to HRs over a threshold number of innings. As @Frobby said, it just distills out too much of what actually happened.
    • We were all a lot younger in 2005.  No one wanted to believe Canseco cause he’s a smarmy guy. Like I said, he was the only one telling the truth. It wasn’t a leap of faith to see McGwire up there and Sosa up there and think “yeah, those guys were juicing” but then suddenly look at Raffy and think he was completely innocent.  It’s a sad story. The guy should be in Hall of Fame yet 500 homers and 3,000 hits are gone like a fart in the wind cause his legacy is wagging his finger and thinking he couldn’t get caught.  Don’t fly too close to the sun.  
    • I think if we get the fun sprinkler loving Gunnar that was in the dugout yesterday, I don’t think we have to worry about him pressing. He seemed loose and feeling good with the other guys he was with, like Kremer.
    • I was a lot younger back then, but that betrayal hit really hard because he had been painting himself as literally holier than thou, and shook his finger to a congressional committee and then barely 2 weeks later failed the test.
    • Not bad, but Mullins needs to be at Centerfield for his range, glove, and defensive ability. Top teir premium defense cannot be underestimated. Kjerstad will be on the bench. I think the question is whether Slater or Cowser plays. I would prefer Ramirez over Slater if they need another right handed bat. Sig needs to look at Adleys recent sample sizes vs LHP before making him DH. McCann is catching for Burnes and hitting the left handed pitcher. He's also on a hot streak.
    • I’m slightly (irrationally, I admit, there’s no factual basis for what I’m about to say) worried that Gunnar is going to view this as the “Gunnar vs. Bobby” show and press hard at the plate and in the field leading to bad at bats and unforced errors. 
    • Sounds like getting your heart broken by big league ballplayers is a personal problem. Learn and adjust accordingly. These guys usually aren’t trying to be role models and he played in an era where a lot of players were on the gas. Was I surprised? Yeah, a little bit.  No one likes to admit Jose Canseco was the most honest one up there that day and was telling the truth the entire time.    
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...