Jump to content

The Defense Thread, 2016


OFFNY

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 339
  • Created
  • Last Reply

August

A couple of really nifty 5-4-3 DPs in this game that most teams don't make.

JJ made a great backhand stop of a smash on the short hop.

The game arguably turned on the pop fly down the LF line that Manny got a glove on but couldn't catch, eventually ruled a fair ball.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

o

(vs. ATHLETICS, 8/11)

Jonathan Schoop made an excellent, heads-up play that intially was ruled to be the last out of the game, but was overturned.

With runners on 1st and 2nd base and 2 outs, Ryan Flaherty (the shortstop) snared a ground ball that was a few feet into the outfield grass and flipped it to Schoop at 2nd base. The runner was safe ...... but Schoop noticed that the lead runner had rounded 3rd base, and so he fired the ball to Manny Machado, who applied the tag.

The officials in New York ruled that there was irrefutable evidence that the runner was safe, and so Zach Britton had to get one additional batter out to end the game.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

o

(vs. ATHLETICS, 8/11)

Jonathan Schoop made an excellent, heads-up play that intially was ruled to be the last out of the game, but was overturned.

With runners on 1st and 2nd base and 2 outs, Ryan Flaherty (the shortstop) snared a ground ball that was a few feet into the outfield grass and flipped it to Schoop at 2nd base. The runner was safe ...... but Schoop noticed that the lead runner had rounded 3rd base, and so he fired the ball to Manny Machado, who applied the tag.

Wasn't it the other way around? I thought Schoop was the one who gloved the ball in the outfield and flipped to Flaherty, and Flaherty threw to third.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Wasn't it the other way around? I thought Schoop was the one who gloved the ball in the outfield and flipped to Flaherty, and Flaherty threw to third.

I think that you're right, Paul.

Thanks for the correction.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Two great backhand plays by Manny tonight. On the first, he fielded the fall while going into foul territory and threw a strike to second base while falling away. On the second, he took the ball deep behind the bag and fired a one-hopper that Davis corralled for the out on a tough hop.

On the play where the Giants scored their first run, Schoop airmailed a relay throw to the plate. I think a good throw would have nailed the runner.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a play last night, I think on Ubaldo's last batter, where the ball was blooped to RCF and landed short of Trumbo and Jones. I can't be sure from the camera angle they showed, but I had the distinct impression that a good RF would have charged that ball and caught it, and that even Jones might have had a shot but he expected Trumbo to go for the catch but ended up watching Trumbo pull up short. Anybody else see it that way? I believe that play either tied the game or put Houston back in the lead.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

There was a play last night, I think on Ubaldo's last batter, where the ball was blooped to RCF and landed short of Trumbo and Jones. I can't be sure from the camera angle they showed, but I had the distinct impression that a good RF would have charged that ball and caught it, and that even Jones might have had a shot but he expected Trumbo to go for the catch but ended up watching Trumbo pull up short. Anybody else see it that way? I believe that play either tied the game or put Houston back in the lead.
It seems to me that's what Trumbo does. He errs on the side of caution wanting to avoid letting the ball get by him.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

o

(vs. ASTROS, 8/21)

Manny Machado flubbed a routine ground ball to start the 5th inning.

Chris Davis had a routine line drive hit off of his glove 3 plays later in right field, and what was a close game is now 4-1 in favor of the Astros.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

o

(vs. ASTROS, 8/21)

Manny Machado flubbed a routine ground ball to start the 5th inning.

Chris Davis had a routine line drive hit off of his glove 3 plays later in right field, and what was a close game is now 4-1 in favor of the Astros.

No clue how they are considering the ball Chris missed a double. Need to make that play, which should be an error.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Another game argualbly lost by poor defense, and again poor RF defense.

and yet the O's don't have even a middling COF prospect in the minors.

What a good GM could have gotten for O'day and Davis at the 2015 trade deadline?

I hope the O's win tomorrow, just so you crawl back into your hole for a couple of days.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

(vs. ASTROS, 8/21)

Manny Machado flubbed a routine ground ball to start the 5th inning.

Chris Davis had a routine line drive hit off of his glove 3 plays later in right field, and what was a close game is now 4-1 in favor of the Astros.

Showalter stated that Davis lost the line drive off of his glove in the lights.

https://twitter.com/masnRoch/status/767526107482644480

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • Where are the ABs for Mayo? Verse a lefty you have Hays/Santander/Mountcastle above him as a bat.  He's worse than them defensively.  There's abs for him at DH vs LHP. If you stop using it to rest Rutch. Are you ready to bring him up to do that and only that? Because there's not 200 abs in that role for the rest of the season. It's not about Mateo vs Holliday.  It's about Holliday didn't look ready to be playing in the MLs.  If 3 weeks in the MiLs can fix that, great.  I'm skeptical. As to what to trade, instead of just throwing out stupid descriptives, give me names.  Are you willing to trade Basallo?  Mayo? Kjerstad?  Because if not, then Stowers and Norby are about the best you have.
    • Kjerstad is the best prospect we have that you can argue should be available in the right deal. The question is his defense and that could be enough to trade himself. I would rather keep him but should be available in the right deal.
    • My bad.  He can make the roster I guess.  😁
    • For the record, I hated giving him up, and felt he could have had a long-term role in this organization, and said that many, many times. That said, this is the game, and this team is highly unlikely to ever really regret it unless something very strange happens with Holliday. I totally understand the trade from the O's perspective, but a lot of how we feel about this trade long-term is going to be determined by a few starts in October.
    • There are clearly at bats available for Mayo and let’s not get into this overrating Mateo stuff again.  You should have learned your lesson. He is doing well in a part time role and they are riding him playing well for the moment but Holliday is the clear better option and will be the obvious starter within 6 weeks.  And we all know this isn’t what Mateo really is. That has been proven. That said, he can have a role on this team and he is proving to be an asset, which is good to see. As for what to trade, I think that’s an awful take but it is what it is.  Some people are ok with hoping for the best and if that doesn’t work out, so be it.
    • Good catch.  And changes the math.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...