Jump to content

Poll: Smoak v. Alvarez


Who would you prefer to see the O's draft, were they both available?  

89 members have voted

  1. 1. Who would you prefer to see the O's draft, were they both available?



Recommended Posts

I'll not continue this with you, but if you could... what was that last bolded line about?

Just meant it in a "dispassionate, just my opinion, agree to disagree" kind of way, as in I didn't want to seem like I was getting worked up over my opinion.

I guess it wasn't very clear. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 32
  • Created
  • Last Reply

To me its Alvarez. He's universally considered a better player than Smoak. Maybe the experts are wrong in the end, but do you bet against the wisdom of everyone? There's usually something when all the scouts agree.

As a slight aside, I hope the Orioles take a hitter. I know you don't draft by need, but it seems likely the Orioles will have their pick of plenty of similarly ranked players. And the top pitchers aren't the kind that scouts drool over. A lot of projections have the O's taking Matusz. But this team has tons of pitching propsects. It would be nice to have legit hitting prospects. All that's there now is Weiters, and to a lesser extent Reimold. Guys like Rowell and such are way far off and pretty iffy. But in the end, I can't really complain about who the O's take unless they go way off board or pass on Alvarez or Tim Beckham (and both are likely to be off the board anyway).

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • OP may be trolling or just doing a dumb reverse jinx joke, but Kremer does have a 5.74 xERA on the season. He’s doing ok on K/BB, whiffs and chase so he’ll probably be ok, but he is giving up a lot of hard contact and tons of barrels. His xFIP is 3.92 and that’s still more predictive in this sample, but he can’t keep giving up hard contact like he’s pitching against the Orioles lineup every game. With Irvin pitching really well and Means lights out yesterday, I do think Kremer is more at risk of a numbers-game option to AAA if Grayson is able to come back soon and Kremer’s not straightened his contact quality numbers out. Povich is also lurking as a possibility to force a call up if he puts up another ~5 starts as dominant as his start to the season has been. Possibly they will consider going to a 6-man rotation for some period of time as well.
    • Nice analysis. Would love to see you add a paragraph for defense as well.    
    • It is better due to natural bats growth. Pitching I think in the aggregate Burnes and Kimbrel hold their own relative to Gibson and Bautista, even though there Burnes is the one doing almost all the work. The Ryans both playing strong is going to give the organization a tough Coby Mayo decision this summer.    I believe Sigbot still regards Mayo's talent the more capable at the highest level of competition, but without a random act of injury it will involve reducing the role of a very productive player. We should do better, hopefully much better, than Fujinami and Flaherty this July.
    • I haven't really followed the Reds, but I am impressed with their rotation so far of: Hunter Greene Andrew Abbott Nick Lodolo   That's a heck of a top of the rotation....  I am actually thrilled we were able to win at least 2....  Good for us!  Go O's!
    • You could say the same about Cole Irvin.  I think he's due to regress too....
    • Another factor — the 2024 team is in a better place to fortify over the course of the season, whether internally (Holliday, Mayo, Povich, McDermott) or externally (surely better than Flaherty, Fuji).
    • It was definitely weird. It seems like some information is missing — either from last season or the spring, be it an arm strength issue or lingering soreness (which maybe counts as a slight setback). The lack of details made it seem like an NHL injury report, purposefully vague. Either he had some issues or they kept a guy who looked more than ready in his first start off the roster too long.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...