Jump to content

Umpire Scorecard Thread


Can_of_corn

Recommended Posts

6 hours ago, Orioles4Life21 said:

Are umpires worse than they always have been or does every broadcast now having a box that we can use to judge every call off of just skewing it in our minds?

I think umpires right now are better at their jobs than at any time in the past. And I think a lot of that improvement has to do with replay. 20-30 years ago there were a dozen or more umps working MLB games who were as bad (and even more arrogant) as Angel Hernandez is today. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, ShoelesJoe said:

I think umpires right now are better at their jobs than at any time in the past. And I think a lot of that improvement has to do with replay. 20-30 years ago there were a dozen or more umps working MLB games who were as bad (and even more arrogant) as Angel Hernandez is today. 

More arrogant than Hernandez? Joe West maybe. I need a memory refresher.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, ShoelesJoe said:

I think umpires right now are better at their jobs than at any time in the past. And I think a lot of that improvement has to do with replay. 20-30 years ago there were a dozen or more umps working MLB games who were as bad (and even more arrogant) as Angel Hernandez is today. 

Before the great purge in the 1990s* the umps more-or-less did whatever they wanted. They'd interview an ump and he'd say things like "the strike zone is what I say the strike zone is." There would be talk of reforming things and the umps and their union basically just said no. We're the umpires, goldang it, and we control what goes on. Wrong call? Missed something? Bullcrap, we're the best umps in the world, how dare you question us? And until HDTV and cameras everywhere, and tracking systems in the last ~20 years it was often hard to tell just how good or bad they were. 

There was that famous Eric Gregg game in the 1997 NLCS where he just decided the strike zone was going to be three feet wide and Livan Hernandez (career K rate of 5.9, never struck out more than 11 in any other game in his long career) struck out 15. It just happened, no consequences, nothing.

But now, with Statcast everywhere, even in the minors, and HD broadcasts of every game, it's a whole new world. Umpires have been graded on balls/strikes for many years. They just accept that the whole world knows more-or-less objectively if they were right or wrong in near real time. They can't hide. Truly terrible, belligerent, rogue umps don't exist like they did when I was a kid. That's why Angel and one or two others stand out. But they'd have been mid-pack or better in the 1990s.

There can still be improvements, but umpiring is better than it's ever been.

* Remember there was some kind of work stoppage and the umps resigned en masse, and the owners called their bluff and accepted the resignations. When the umps came crawling back the owners only brought back the ones they liked.)

Edited by DrungoHazewood
Link to comment
Share on other sites

14 hours ago, Otter said:

Ken Kaiser, Garcia....

Ya, Kaiser was in his own world when it came to arrogance and incompetence. I remember a game (in Texas?) where he blew a call at 1st base early in the game and then instantly tossed Eddie Murray because Eddie looked at him wrong. It was no surprise that after the mass resignations Kaiser was one of the few who wasn't allowed to return. Everybody in the game wanted him gone. Same with Rich Garcia and Eric Gregg. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

7 hours ago, Orioles4Life21 said:

CB Bucknor was surprisingly ok tonight

By "surprisingly ok" I assume you mean his strike zone was predictably terrible, as opposed to being a complete and utter abomination. This was his last game behind the plate. Notice a pattern? 

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

8 hours ago, Orioles4Life21 said:

CB Bucknor was surprisingly ok tonight

Yes, after the terrible 3rd strike call on Gunnar in the 1st he was actually better than he normally is.  But I loved how Palmer tore into him after that bad call.  It's almost as if Palmer was just waiting for the first chance to bash him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, ShoelesJoe said:

By "surprisingly ok" I assume you mean his strike zone was predictably terrible, as opposed to being a complete and utter abomination. This was his last game behind the plate. Notice a pattern? 

 

 

He was quite good last night actually. 
 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

23 minutes ago, Orioles4Life21 said:

He was quite good last night actually. 
 

 

I guess you can't trust the scorecards either because it says 1 of 36 called strikes were true balls. But we know for sure that there was at least 2 to Gunnar alone. One in the first inning and one in the sixth inning.

What's that say about the rest of the scorecard.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3 hours ago, Moose Milligan said:

Bucknor had a few missed calls last night but wasn't as terrible as he's been.  

Good lord though, if he's 77th out of 81 umpires, who's the 81st?  I'm assuming Hernandez.

As of this morning, Bucknor is 80 out of 81 measured by Acc with John Bacon last, but it looks like Bacon has only called one game.  Unsurprisingly Laz Diaz, Hunter Wendlestedt, and Angel Hernandez also look to be in the bottom 20%.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, 24fps said:

As of this morning, Bucknor is 80 out of 81 measured by Acc with John Bacon last, but it looks like Bacon has only called one game.  Unsurprisingly Laz Diaz, Hunter Wendlestedt, and Angel Hernandez also look to be in the bottom 20%.

Umpires these days are like, if you know my name, I’m probably terrible at calling balls and strikes. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • In your retirement you stay up too late and worry too much.  
    • If you want style points, watch figure skating. A bloop hit looks the same as a line drive hit in the box score. A win is a win.
    • Every time we get a pitcher from the A’s this time of year, I think they are still doing us a solid for trading them Pat Neshek for cash in 2012.
    • I understand why you'd be concerned with Webb's performance but that contract is so juicy that I'd jump on him if he were available.  4/82 plus the remainder of his salary this year is a steal for him, even accounting for the fact that pitcher arb awards have been weirdly low.
    • Great to get a 2-0 win facing George Kirby, but man they made it way harder than it had to be. Grayson gets staked to a 1-0 lead in the top of the 4th, then walks 2 of the first 3 batters he faces in the bottom of the inning.  Fortunately, erased on a DP. The O’s score an insurance run in the 7th, but then can’t capitalize on a bases loaded, one out situation with Gunnar and Adley up.   In the bottom half, Grayson allows a single and puts the tying run on via a walk, then makes a poor throw on an easy DP comebacker that could have loaded the bases but Gunnar somehow got a barehand grip on the ball with his foot on the bag.   In the 8th, O’Hearn leads off with a double but the O’s failed to advance him. In the 9th, Kimbrel hits a guy, almost allows a game-tying homer that goes just foul, then hits another guy, and the baserunners both get into scoring position but Kimbrel is able to end it on a strikeout.    I’m thrilled they won, but man they made it gut-wrenching.   
    • 1: A lot of posters here actually have an milb.tv subscription and use it, or they attend games in person.  So you're off base if you think the prevailing opinion here is based on a few social media posts. 2: Henderson doesn't have a famous dad, and Holliday outproduced him at a younger age in the minors, and people here were about equally hyped about Henderson. 3: Holliday put up a 1.000+ OPS in AA as a 19 year old.  AA is harder than power-5 division 1 college baseball.  That's basically like a freshman putting up 25/10/5.  Not 4 points a game.  Get outta here with your terrible Bronny James comparisons.  If people here were actually blinded by a last name then posters here would have thought that Ryan Ripken was a legitimate prospect.  Believe it or not some of us actually do research on things like this.  We certainly aren't alone in rating Holliday highly, as he was rated #1 or #2 overall by every publication I can think of (and #1 by most of them if I recall.) 4: Holliday for Miller, who isn't guaranteed to be healthy enough to be in the starting rotation over the course of his controlled years, is a ludicrous trade proposal and I'm glad you're not our GM.  You're trading Holliday for an ace.  And not just any ace, an ace without injury concerns with years of control left.  Someone like Chris Sale, when the White Sox traded him for Moncada/Kopech+.  Anything less than an ace is a terrible return.  And I get that Moncada was probably a bad #1 overall prospect, but even if you think Holliday is a bad #1 overall too, you're still undervaluing him to an absurd degree by settling for a reliever with injury concerns, even a shutdown one.
    • So, Burnes is pushed back to Thursday. He could still make the Tuesday-Sunday starts next week, or does Hyde go with Kremer to make two starts next week. The Sunday game against the Yankees could be big. I think if we win two of three we clinch the season series.    
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...