Jump to content

Two HoFers? Beltre and Konerko

Moose Milligan

Recommended Posts

I still don't like him, but espn.com has a piece on Adrian Beltre's chances for the HoF.


He's been around since he was 19, so he can pile up some nice counting stats.

When I was watching the game last night, I thought about Paul Konerko's chances. He's 36 and still going strong so I think he could have at least two more productive seasons left. As it stands right now, I think he'd be on the bubble. He's never lead the league in anything, never won an MVP...but he's been really consistent for his career. In some respects, he reminds me of Eddie Murray, though Murray lead the league in a few things here and there throughout his career. His closest comp is Fred McGriff though.


Link to comment
Share on other sites

Beltre would have a good case to get in if he quit today imo. He's one of the better defensive third baseman I've ever seen and his offense was clearly suppressed those years in SEA.

Konerko is more iffy (based on being a first baseman). He does seem to have gotten better with age.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I don't think Konerko is very deserving, if you're simply going off of WAR. Beltre is definitely deserving but I think he'll get overlooked because he wasn't one of the more household names in baseball. But according to BRef, he has 21.6 dWAR so far in his career. That's 35th all time and he'll probably play 8-10 more years. That's pretty crazy.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Konerko has been a solid offensive player throughout his career, but if you're someone who goes by WAR, his WAR isn't all that impressive in large part because he's been such a poor defensive player. If he gets to 500 home runs I think he'll get greater consideration, as I don't recall him ever being suspected of anything, but a part of me wouldn't be surprised if he ends up a Fred McGriff type guy whose perpetually stuck in that good, but not great, or good, but how good realm. I haven't looked at the numbers for Beltre recently, but he's got a shot at 3,000 hits, which still carries an aura about it that 500 homers doesn't. Plus, he's a third baseman, of which there aren't a great number of in the hall, and for which defense can really carry you over even average offense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites


This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

  • Posts

    • Eh, noise. IDGAF anyway, having cut the cord long ago. I know the feeling though… Dish pulled that BS a couple years ago. I’m hoping Rubenstein can find a way to ala carte everything. There will certainly be demand.
    • I haven’t seen this mentioned anywhere, but Irvin morphed his slider into a cutter last year that is by far his best pitch by Stuff+. He threw it 16% of the time too, decent usage but could be increased more. He’s always going to score poorly in stuff for pitch models but very well in command grades, so even some slight upticks in stuff could make a big difference. His curve is also decent. He relies a lot on his fastball/sinker/change, so I’d be interested in him moving more towards the cutter/curve (which generally are still effective against RH batters). Irvin was absolutely unreal horrific in his first few starts last season, which tanked his season numbers (particularly xERA), but really righted the ship after that. He’s a decent piece to be a 5th starter, he’s been very durable, throws a lot of strikes and as a result can pitch a lot of innings (if you aren’t pulling him early in close games), and is a good fit for OPACY. It’s just a bad spot that our depth chart is already whittled down to him being that to start the year. 
    • Things aren’t looking good for MASN and comcast.     Would still figure they find a way to get a deal done but it doesn’t seem as certain as I think it was.
    • Verlander needs 140 IP and a clean doctor's note to assure himself of 1/35 next season but if he misses that I could see him somewhere on Elias' target list for the year over year Lyles-Gibson-Kimbrel 1-year contract stretch. Its a bit of an art question for baseball how it wants to grapple with all Friedman and Driveline have brought to the game.    Roki Sasaki or Paul Skenes or even Grayson Rodriguez might be their generation's Justin Verlander but today's game will constrain them from revealing it as fully to baseball fans even if they are. Verlander has become a TJ statistic in recent years, but for me he really isn't - every bit of work on his Hall of Fame plaque was done before the surgeon took some of him.
    • Buried in the article, but it says this:   “Verlander said he heard at the trade deadline that the Dodgers and Orioles were interested, and he said he’d have accepted Los Angeles or even Baltimore if those were the options. “I’m from Virginia,” Verlander said. But when Houston, where he’d won his rings, became viable, he said he was happy to “steer things” that way.”
    • Has the added benefit of being on the 40-man already, so nobody necessarily needs to be removed for him to come up as a reliever later in the season.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Create New...