Jump to content

vs. RED SOX, 4/19

OFFNY

By OFFNY
in Game Threads

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 575
  • Created
  • Last Reply
SteveA Hangout Grand Counsel

SteveA

Posted
Posted
I'm not sure how you are the only person in the thread not understanding this. Lets try and make it easy. The announcers said you cannot challenge a fair/foul ball over the base due to that play being in front of the umpire.

Another poster asked if thats the case, could they not have challenged a HR call like the McLouth one in Yankee stadium in the playoffs.

I then said That play can never be in front of the umpire, unless an umpire is in the stands, so HR fair/foul can be challenged.

Please note the difference in a play in front of the ump, and behind the ump.

I also stated that I don't know if they just made it up for the broadcast, but I assume they know what they're talking about in regards to a fair/foul over the base call not being able to be challenged. I hope this clears it up, if not, well, I give up.

OK, I am sorry.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Malike Hangout Grand Counsel

Malike

Posted
Posted
Still not sure I understand. I have no idea if the statement about not being able to challenge balls over the bag is true or not. But CLEARLY you CAN challenge a home run fair/foul, so that entire part of the discussion is completely irrelevant to anything we are talking about.

From CBS sports in regards to the expanded replay.

4. Balls hopping over first or third base that require a fair-or-foul ruling can?t be challenged.

Link to comment
Share on other sites
Palmoripken Hangout Grand Counsel

Palmoripken

Posted
Posted
The other problem with a ball down the line is' date=' like that one hit today, the ump raises his arms calling it foul and all play stops. Who knows how far the runner would have gotten; would the fielder had thrown them out, etc...[/quote']

So it's like football and challenging plays made after the whistle is blown then. Thanks, that does make sense.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.

Go to topic listing


  • Posts

    • SouthernBird
      Injury updates

      By SouthernBird · Posted

      Well, I guess I need to get to the stadium by 11 AM today to watch Urias and Westburg here in Nashville! The stadium is 50 feet from my office window.
    • MCO'sFan
      Elias…DFA Kimbrel now!! (9/18: Kimbrel DFA'd, Baker recalled)

      By MCO'sFan · Posted

      No, It is my understanding that he is now a FA. Any team that picks him up is on the hook for prorated minimum this year only. The O's owe him the buy out. 
    • Fiver6565
      O’s look done

      By Fiver6565 · Posted

      Burnes starting won’t help anyone hit. And I have minimal expectations for Westburg in his very first game back.    We just gave up 15 runs to a pretty damn pedestrian SF lineup last two games. I don’t think a ‘hangover lineup’ is going to help as much as you think. Plus again, if we can’t score it doesn’t matter much what the opposing lineup looks like.    I did just realize we have 10 games left, not 11. 3-7 seems even less likely than 3-8, ha.   
    • Just Regular
      O’s look done

      By Just Regular · Posted

      Game 1 Corbin Burnes, and Sunday Jordan Westburg and a bullpen game before an off day? We'll see in 10 days, but I think the Tigers run of good play at the end will have helped protect OPACY home field for the ALWC round. Very happy flight for the Tigers, and I'd guess they are asleep at their Baltimore hotel by now, waiting for tomorrow night.    Tigers home next week with two Skubal starts if necessary and a White Sox series, so the Royals and Twins are probably cheering pretty hard for us. If we finish this week 0-4, the Yankees might have that hangover lineup the day after division clinching one of our games there.    It looks pretty likely while we are in New York, the guys will have a front row seat handing over the AL East champion honor.
    • Fiver6565
      AL playoff picture

      By Fiver6565 · Posted

      They still need to win a few games to get there. I still don’t understand why people are acting like that is so certain (quoting you but not referring to you, per se).    3-8 in the last 11. 11 games left. In all seriousness, what makes anyone think we can even go 3-8 in the next 11?  We are bad in every single phase of the game and we’re playing against teams who have everything to play for (other than SF today, and they’ve pretty easily handled us this week already).    These last two games against SF, especially last night, have convinced me they’re going to fully blow this. We’ve already shown that Detroit can handle us. Probably going to lose to Webb today. Then it’s NY in NY. When is the last time we beat the Yanks in a late season series that mattered to both teams?  Ever? This team certainly isn’t the one to do it. And then it’s do or die in MIN. Anybody believe we can take 2/3 there?  I just don’t see a path to more than three wins, and even getting three doesn’t seem remotely certain. I think we’ll be lucky to win one game each of these last three series. Maybe that’s enough, but I’m far from sure they can even do that.    What’s the counterpoint to this?  Injury returns?  Too late for that IMO. Just start playing better?  What would make anyone believe that’s going to happen after 3.5 months of bad baseball? For real, someone tell me what they’re seeing that makes them think even 3-8 is going to happen in the next 11. 
    • gtman55
      O’s look done

      By gtman55 · Posted

      We traded far too much for what we got in return IMO. You can't totally judge trades this early but as it stands now, Elias gets a well deserved D for his trade deadline performance. I've said this before. He's done a fantastic job bringing this club back to relevancy. I just question some of his roster construction and trade decisions.
    • Tony-OH
      O’s look done

      By Tony-OH · Posted

      Since July 1st, the Orioles are 31-37 and since the Trading deadline when Elias was supposed to make the team better they've gone 19-24 (.441). Now grant it the team lost Westburg and Grayson as well as Eflin for a little bit, but what can't be swept under the rug is that Elias traded a decent part of his minor league league prospects and the team has done worse. The acquisitions of Rogers, Jimenez and Soto have not improved the team. Eflin has kept them from being even worse and we have him for next year, and the same goes for Dominguez. Hopefully Soto will figure it out or Elias wasted two pitching prospects (Chace being probably being the one with the most upside of any pitcher traded).  

  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...