Rule Five Draft Noon Thursday

[Roll Tide]

36 minutes ago, bobmc said:

Are you trying to get past the 5 page limit to win the bet with SG?

Computer was acting up... removed the dupes 

 

And still at page 6

 

[HowAboutThat]

I find it very interesting that several of the guys taken were not among ranked prospects, And not on anybody’s radar.… Well except on the radar of the teams that took them, ha ha

I wonder what that is all about?

[Roll Tide]

Here is the complete list ...both phases for anyone interested

 

Quote

1) Pirates: Jose Soriano, RHP (Angels No. 13)
2) Rangers: Brett de Geus, RHP (Dodgers No. 27)
3) Tigers: Akil Baddoo, OF (Twins No. 13)
4) Red Sox: Garrett Whitlock, RHP (Yankees)
5) Orioles: Mac Sceroler, RHP (Reds)
6) D-backs: Zach Pop, RHP (Orioles)
7) Rockies: Jordan Sheffield, RHP (Dodgers)
Angels: Jose Rivera, RHP (Astros No. 14)
9) Mets: Luis Oviedo, RHP (Indians No. 25)
10) Mariners: Will Vest, RHP (Tigers)
11) Phillies: Kyle Holder, SS (Yankees)
12) Giants: Dedniel Nunez, RHP (Mets No. 18)
13) Marlins: Paul Campbell, RHP (Rays No. 24)
14) Cubs: Gray Fenter, RHP (Orioles)
15) Indians: Trevor Stephan, RHP (Yankees No. 24)
16) A's: Ka'ai Tom, CF (Indians)

Round 2

17) Orioles: Tyler Wells, RHP (Twins)
18) A's: Dany Jimenez, RHP (Blue Jays)

Triple-A Phase

Round 1

1) Pirates: Shea Spitzbarth, RHP (Dodgers)
2) Rangers: Matthew Wivinis, RHP (Yankees)
3) Tigers: Yunior Perez, RHP (Cubs)
4) Red Sox: Tyreque Reed, 1B (Rangers)
5) Orioles: Rickey Ramirez, RHP (Twins)
6) D-backs: Tyler Gilbert, LHP (Dodgers)
7) Angels: Brendon Davis, SS (Rangers)
Mets: Andrew Ferguson, CF (Astros)
9) Mariners: Amador Arias, 2B (Rays)
10) Giants: Vince Fernandez, OF (Rockies)
11) Astros: Joe Record, RHP (Twins)
12) Marlins: Jake Fishman, LHP (Blue Jays)
13) Reds: Errol Robinson, SS (Dodgers)
14) Cardinals: Garrett Williams, LHP (Angels)
15) Blue Jays: Sebastian Espino, SS (Mets)
16) Yankees: Matt Krook, LHP (Rays)
17) Cubs: Nicholas Padilla, RHP (Rays)
18) White Sox: Martin Carrasco, RHP (Padres)
19) Indians: Chris Roller, CF (Dodgers)
20) Braves: A.J. Puckett, RHP (White Sox)
21) A's: Zach Jackson, RHP (Blue Jays)
22) Twins: Jhonleider Salinas, RHP (Rays)
23) Padres: Yorman Rodriguez, C (Blue Jays)
24) Rays: Jordan Brink, RHP (Cardinals)
25) Dodgers: Ryan January, C (D-backs)

Round 2

26) Pirates: Claudio Finol, SS (Reds)
27) Rangers: Yohel Pozo, C (Padres)
28) Red Sox: Kaleb Ort, RHP (Yankees)
29) Orioles: Christopher Hudgins, C (Royals)
30) Angels: Gustavo Campero, C (Yankees)
31) Mets: Justin Dillon, RHP (Blue Jays)
32) Giants: Ronnie Williams, RHP (Cardinals)
33) Astros: Seth Martinez, RHP (A's)
34) Marlins: Dylan Bice, RHP (Rangers)
35) Reds: Wilfred Astudillo, C (Mets)
36) Yankees: Reggie McClain, RHP (Phillies)
37) Cubs: Samuel Reyes, RHP (Pirates)
38) Braves: Jalen Miller, 2B (Giants)
39) A's: Brett Graves, RHP (Marlins)
40) Twins: Josh Mitchell, LHP (Royals)
41) Padres: Ben Ruta, LF (Yankees)
42) Rays: Ezequiel Zabaleta, RHP (Mets)
43) Dodgers: Roimer Bolivar, RHP (Rays)

Round 3

44) Pirates: Jeffrey Passantino, RHP (Cubs)
45) Rangers: Justin Marsden, RHP (Rays)
46) Orioles: Ignacio Feliz, RHP (Padres)
47) Mets: Drew Jackson, 2B (Dodgers)
48) Giants: Mitchell Tolman, 2B (Mets)
49) Marlins: Marcus Chiu, 2B (Dodgers)
50) Reds: Chuckie Robinson, C (Astros)
51) Braves: Jacob Pearson, OF (Twins)

Round 4

52) Mets: Jesus Reyes, RHP (Reds)
53) Reds: Yoel Yanqui, 1B (D-backs)

Round 5

54) Mets: Jose Zorrilla, LHP (Reds)
55) Reds: Wes Robertson, RHP (Rangers)

Round 6

56) Reds: Steven Leyton, SS (D-backs)

 

[Sports Guy]

It’s annoying that in something as insignificant as the rule 5 draft that the organization actually got worse today.
 

It likely doesn’t matter in the long run and hopefully we get our guys back but this just wasn’t good by Elias.

[bobmc]

53 minutes ago, Roll Tide said:

Here is the complete list ...both phases for anyone interested

 

 

Jesus (Reyes) was finally taken during this season of love and joy and his last name translates as kings!  PTL

[Roll Tide]

23 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

It’s annoying that in something as insignificant as the rule 5 draft that the organization actually got worse today.
 

It likely doesn’t matter in the long run and hopefully we get our guys back but this just wasn’t good by Elias.

I don't think we have better talent now then before the draft. Interesting that Estevez was widely speculated in many of the rule 5 articles and wasn't taken. 13 0f the 16 players selected were pitchers

[Frobby]

1 hour ago, Sports Guy said:

It’s annoying that in something as insignificant as the rule 5 draft that the organization actually got worse today.

So you’ve already made that judgment?    I’ve been busy and haven’t studied the two guys we acquired.    I was very disappointed (certainly not shocked) that Pop got popped.  Fenter was passed over last year and so I was quite surprised he got picked this time around.    I like him but won’t lose any sleep over him (unless he turns out to be good, of course!).    

[Sports Guy]

1 hour ago, Frobby said:

So you’ve already made that judgment?    I’ve been busy and haven’t studied the two guys we acquired.    I was very disappointed (certainly not shocked) that Pop got popped.  Fenter was passed over last year and so I was quite surprised he got picked this time around.    I like him but won’t lose any sleep over him (unless he turns out to be good, of course!).    

Yes..there is very little to like about the Big Ben’s nephew..The other guy maybe is worth something but I would much rather have Pop than both of them.  He’s younger, and has a higher ceiling (neither of these guys will stick as a starter, so I’m judging that as a reliever prospect).

 

I like Fenter and would probably rather have him too but I wouldn’t have protected him and expect him to be back. I’m not upset about him.

[jabba72]

Well this was an active Rule 5 Draft this year. Looks like almost every team drafted a player or two. I guess Elias isnt the only GM who loves this draft. 

[Frobby]

By the way, how were the Rule 5 requirements to stay on the ML roster applied this year?    If you kept a guy on for all 60 games, was that considered a full year for Rule 5 purposes such that a team can send that player to the minors in 2021?     Also, normally a Rule 5 guy can spend some time on the DL and have rehab assignments but still exhaust the eligibility requirement if they spent at least 90 of 162 games on the ML roster. Was that reduced proportionately? If so, a player could have been on the roster for 34 of the 60 games and spent the rest of the time on the DL or in rehab.    Best year ever to draft a Rule 5 guy, if that’s how it worked.  

[sevastras]

Pop should have been protected.  He is someone that could have been selected and carried on the MLB roster all year by the current Os team. Doesn’t matter that he is replaceable, he is good enough to be worth a 40/26 man spot. 

[Sports Guy]

6 hours ago, RZNJ said:

You're a funny guy.  None of has a clue about the ledger sheet for today.  Most are reasonable enough to admit that.  Pop, Fenter, and the two guys we picked up are all wildcards.  You've already determined that Elias screwed up.  Both of the guys we picked up are 99.9% going to start out as relievers with the Orioles.  Watching someone get bent out of shape over the rule 5 draft does provide some entertainment value so thanks for that.  lol

Yes, I’m able to formulate an opinion based off of info at hand as opposed to being a sheep and just bowing to the Os at every turn.

Didnt you say Pop wouldn’t get picked?  

[VaBird1]

Here is fangraphs take on the draft picks:

https://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-2020-rule-5-draft-scouting-reports/

[Roll Tide]

4 hours ago, Sports Guy said:

Yes, I’m able to formulate an opinion based off of info at hand as opposed to being a sheep and just bowing to the Os at every turn.

Didnt you say Pop wouldn’t get picked?  

 

10 hours ago, sevastras said:

Pop should have been protected.  He is someone that could have been selected and carried on the MLB roster all year by the current Os team. Doesn’t matter that he is replaceable, he is good enough to be worth a 40/26 man spot. 

Considering we had Susac, Wynns, etc when the roster needed to be set not protecting him was stupid. I’m betting he’s a closer within the next couple of seasons

[DrinkinWithFermi]

Pretty darn annoyed that we didn't protect Pop, whom I do not see coming back to us. The Marlins will almost certainly find a way to stash his power arm for a season's worth of games.

I will unironically REEEE if he ends up having the best MLB career of the players we received for Manny, which I don't think is too crazy to imagine happening, and we ended up letting him go for nothing.