Jump to content

What about Mayo?


RZNJ

Recommended Posts

2 minutes ago, Jagwar said:

If Urias and Mateo are still on the roster on opening day, I can't see how Mayo or Holliday make the team out of spring training.  

Both can’t buy why not one? 
 

Bench 

McCann

Mateo 

Urias 

Kjerstad/Cowser

C-Adley 

1B - Mountcastle 

2B-Holliday 

SS-Gunnar

3B-Westburg 

LF-Hays

CF-Mullins

RF- Santander 

DH-O’Hearn

Link to comment
Share on other sites

44 minutes ago, Jagwar said:

If Urias and Mateo are still on the roster on opening day, I can't see how Mayo or Holliday make the team out of spring training.  

Why not?  I think it’s pretty easy to see how either, but especially Holliday would fit.

3B Westburg/SS Holliday/2B Holliday/Mateo SS-OF/Urias 2B-3B

Or

3B Mayo/SS Henderson/2B Westburg. Mateo and Urías same as above

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, eddie83 said:

I think if Holliday doesn’t make it that helps someone like Hilliard out. Mateo would be back to playing more INF then.  
 

Also possible Hilliard makes it over Kjerstad/Cowser.  

Geez I hope Hilliard doesn't make it.  He's a AAAA player.  What's the purpose of having the #1 farm system if you don't give prospects a chance.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Jagwar said:

If Urias and Mateo are still on the roster on opening day, I can't see how Mayo or Holliday make the team out of spring training.  

Considering how Elias stuck until the bitter end with scrubs like Odor, Frazier, and Voth, it's a lock that Urias and Mateo will be on the OD roster. I don't like Mateo as a player at all and would have released him last season to give Westburg and Ortiz more playing time, but, unlike Frazier and Odor, I can understand the value that Elias sees in Mateo's speed and defensive versatility. And Urias has actual value to any team. The only way Urias and Mateo aren't on the Opening Day roster is if one of them is traded (no one will want Mateo except perhaps as a throw-in, so it would likely be Urias getting traded) or one of them gets hurt.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, RZNJ said:

Why not?  I think it’s pretty easy to see how either, but especially Holliday would fit.

3B Westburg/SS Holliday/2B Holliday/Mateo SS-OF/Urias 2B-3B

Or

3B Mayo/SS Henderson/2B Westburg. Mateo and Urías same as above

That means they only carry 4 outfielders, And McKenna and one of Cowser/Kjerstad are out. 

Your 5 + Mountcastle + O'Hearn + Rutschman + McCann + Hays + Mullins + Santander + 1 OF = 13 position players   

Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

Why is Holliday ready but Mayo isn’t?

Early spring training game reports certainly confirm his bat is ready. Defensively is the other side of the question and no one will say his defense is as good as Holliday’s that does not mean he is not ready to handle a big league defensive position. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, Jagwar said:

That means they only carry 4 outfielders, And McKenna and one of Cowser/Kjerstad are out. 

Your 5 + Mountcastle + O'Hearn + Rutschman + McCann + Hays + Mullins + Santander + 1 OF = 13 position players   

That’s right but Mateo is the other outfielder.  That’s the whole reason they have him playing there.  So they can carry Kjerstad and not another outfielder whose main job is to backup Cedric.  Also why Kjerstad is getting starts in LF.   He’ll definitely play LF on the road and If he looks good enough he will even get LF starts at home.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

35 minutes ago, Earl Buck said:

Early spring training game reports certainly confirm his bat is ready. Defensively is the other side of the question and no one will say his defense is as good as Holliday’s that does not mean he is not ready to handle a big league defensive position. 

Holliday is playing a relatively new position. Defense is his biggest question mark as of today.  Not that he can’t handle it imo, just saying I don’t feel that excuse works for one but not the other.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

26 minutes ago, Roll Tide said:

If you have Mateo and Urias I don’t see how you have room for Holliday and Mayo. 

To answer SG, it looks like Mayo is ready but you’re right.  There’s no room on the infield.  He’d have to beat Westburg or Holliday out and even if his bat is better than both I don’t think they’re ready to do that.   The other possibility is beating out Kjerstad for the LF/RF job but unless he starts getting a crash course out there pretty soon, that’s not happening either.  Good problem to have but they may need to find a spot for Mayo sooner rather than later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • Good stuff here. Cano’s issue is simple imo…if he gets the ball up, it’s flat and extremely hittable. This was his issue last year and it remains his issues.    It is a bit unlucky to have that many homers on 12 fly balls but he’s also basically putting the ball on a tee when he’s up in the zone, so it’s not surprising the ball gets crushed.
    • Akin is a dime a dozen reliever that is capable of being really good or really bad. If you cut him today, you wouldn’t notice he was gone.
    • In terms of on the field and strictly talking about players, my biggest concern/question was the bullpen and it still is. However, the biggest question that I felt was looming over this team and the organization as a whole was how many young players is too many and when do you bring these guys up? In a year of contention, how many guys do you want “learning on the job” while still focusing on winning?     These are not easy decisions to make, especially when you have competent vet players that should produce at a level that helps the team, even if you feel the young players are more talented. Fast forward to right now.  Holliday came up and struggled and he controls his path to get back.  Mayo may have been close to a call up but he got hurt.  Now, he may be looking at late July/early August before he’s a factor here. Cowser has cemented himself as an everyday player despite his poor and unlucky numbers this month. But he takes arguably the best at bats on the team, is hitting the ball hard and is playing very good defense. Stowers is potentially getting himself in at least a role as the strong side platoon player in the OF. Kjerstad came up and was up and down but he he only had a few sporadic at bats and wasn’t given the proper chance. The other side to this are the vets and many of them have had a lot of issues.  Hays has been awful outside of that glimmer of hope for a few days when he came back off the IL.   He has an OPS+ of 28, a wRC+ of 24, to go along with mediocre at best statcast numbers. Mullins isn’t much better.  His statcast numbers are poor, his OPS+ is 68 and his wRC+ is 65. He is still playing good defense, so that’s good but he hasn’t been good with the bat at all. Santander is hitting 203 and has a sub 300 OBP. He has two 3 hit games this year and if you take those away, he’s hitting 158 And his OPS is closer to 600 than 700. Urias has been surpassed by Mateo and is barely playing and when he is playing, he’s not hitting at all. Mateo has exceeded expectations and looks like he should keep the UTI role this year but we all know the offensive downturn is very likely coming and going off the idea that he is 5 for his last 31, that downturn may have already started.  Still, he has a role here. Mountcastle and OHearn have been up and down but have remained relatively steady to the point where they playing them the amount they are, isn’t really hurting the team. Luckily the team is realizing they aren’t everyday guys, so that helps. I believe Santander will get things going but I’m becoming more and more skeptical about Hays and Mullins.  Mullins is showing some signs lately and has been much better than Hays and the team is playing him less, so I guess that’s good. But Hays is a problem. They need his RH bat but he’s not hitting anything and he’s swinging at awful pitches and he has largely been awful for the last 5 months of baseball. The question of, how much youth is too much is being answered and the answer is, there isn’t “too much” if some of the vets are going to continue to be non factors. If I were the Os, I would send down Hays for Kjerstad or Norby. Norby needs to be able to play OF defense up here but if he can, his RH bat may be valuable. Holliday will be up once he gets hot, so that will take care of itself and like I said, Mayo has to get healthy and playing again. The starting pitching has been better than we thought, so they have been able to keep the team winning through some of these offensive droughts but when you have the talent the Os do in the minors, you can’t keep holding guys back as you hope for these vets to start hitting. The Os have rightfully recognized that none of these vets are everyday guys, so they have at least taken that away but it may be time to do more than that.
    • I’ll take the May version in relief.  
    • Also have to keep in mind that Cano has the toughest job on the team. He gets the middle of the order every time and those matchups are occasionally going to result in a crushing home run. His numbers look about like they did in the second half last year--not elite, but still very good. Needs to work on misses in the zone that get hit hard. 
    • I’d think we’d put him on the FCL roster. 6’3 180. Gotta love that frame. Think of the trade this way, Rodriguez probably is the equivalent of a 5th-7th rd draft pick in this upcoming draft. So we flipped Stallings, who had no role, for a 5th round pitcher with a higher ceiling. 
    • If they were both DH’s maybe
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...