TT: Who would you want as a full-time DH?

[Tony-OH]

Just thought I'd try this little exercise and see how it comes out. If you had to choose between these candidates, who would you install as the full-time DH? BTW, all four players played in the same league. For more fun, put them in order.

Player A: 27-years old at spring training, .284/.344/.494/.838 with 30 2B, 23 HR, and 46/85 BB/K ratio at AAA the year before, once rated #23 prospect in baseball by BA
Career Minor League Slash line .277/.342/.446/.788

Player B: 26-years old at spring training, .264/.321/.437/.757 with 29 2B, 18 HR, and 40/138 BB/K ratio at AAA the year before
Career Minor League Slash line .276/.342/.449/.791

Player C: 25-years old at spring training, .280/.349/.427/.775 with 22 2B, 13 HR, and 48/123 BB/K ratio at AAA the year before
Career Minor League Slash line.306/.357/.477/.834

Player D: 24-years old at spring training, .305/.379/.515/.894 with 32 2B, 19 HR, and 54/136 BB/K ratio at AAA the year before, twice named Top 100 prospect by BA (#95, #45)
Career Minor League Slash line .293/.368/.473/.841

[Can_of_corn]

Off the information provided:

 

D

 

C

A

B

 

 

[Satyr3206]

A

D

C

B

[backwardsk]

I'd be interested in the number of games played for each in that league. 

D or C would be my top choice.

[ArtVanDelay]

D easily. 

[backwardsk]

Is one of these guys Jesus Montero? Lol

[ArtVanDelay]

Just now, backwardsk said:

Is one of these guys Jesus Montero? Lol

He was a top 3 prospect in all of baseball at one point. 

[ReclaimTheCrown]

Clearly C or D are the most intriguing.  As I've got a hunch (as I'm sure others do) as to who at least one of those players is, I'm curious which AAA league each guy played in.  Obviously there can be some pretty darned inflated numbers coming out of the PCL...

[backwardsk]

3 minutes ago, ReclaimTheCrown said:

Clearly C or D are the most intriguing.  As I've got a hunch (as I'm sure others do) as to who at least one of those players is, I'm curious which AAA league each guy played in.  Obviously there can be some pretty darned inflated numbers coming out of the PCL...

I assume based off the OP that they are all IL guys.

[Can_of_corn]

5 minutes ago, ReclaimTheCrown said:

Clearly C or D are the most intriguing.  As I've got a hunch (as I'm sure others do) as to who at least one of those players is, I'm curious which AAA league each guy played in.  Obviously there can be some pretty darned inflated numbers coming out of the PCL...

Only one I recognized from the info given was D.  At least with any certainty.

[backwardsk]

1 minute ago, Can_of_corn said:

Only one I recognized from the info given was D.  At least with any certainty.

C should be recognizable.

[ArtVanDelay]

13 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

Only one I recognized from the info given was D.  At least with any certainty.

Who is D? I couldn't figure that one out. 

[El Gordo]

D, A, C, B.

[ReclaimTheCrown]

8 minutes ago, backwardsk said:

I assume based off the OP that they are all IL guys.

Ack...sorry, didn't read that carefully enough.  You're right, probably all IL guys.

[Can_of_corn]

17 minutes ago, ArtVanDelay said:

B is @@@@@ and C is #######. Who is D? I couldn't figure that one out. 

PM sent.  I don't want to taint Tony's experiment by naming names.

On a side note can we still do spoiler tags on the new board?  (not that anyone really bothered, I'm just curious)