Jump to content

Saturday, June 10 -- Adley/Captain America Bobblehead day vs Royals


Tony-OH

Recommended Posts

1 minute ago, Mr-splash said:

Cuz the risk is not worth the extra base when you're trailing by 3 runs. Just ran themselves out of a 2 on and 1 out situation. 

Witt Jr. Has stolen 20 out of 24 bases before that try and was actually safe until he overslid the bag. Rutschman has struggled to throw out runners this year and it took a pitch out and he still was safe until he overslid the bag.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Tony-OH said:

Personally I don't think they should start playing matchups offensively until the 7th inning unless it's a key situation and the platoon difference was huge and you gain a defensive advantage. And certainly not in a 4-1 game. 

I agree with that, I do think it's too early to play matchups because McKenna will now have at least 1 or 2 PAs vs RHPs.  But I was specifically responding to a post that said "you can't tell me that McKenna is a better matchup than O'Hearn even against a lefty".     So I completely stand by what I said as a valid response to that post.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Moose Milligan said:

BuT AdLeY iSn’T gOoD aT tHrOwInG oUt bAsE StEaLeRz!!!!!!11

Did the throw beat Witt?  Or did we catch a break because Witt over-slid the base and came off?  The throw was to the third base side of the bag.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Tony-OH said:

Witt Jr. Has stolen 20 out of 24 bases before that try and was actually safe until he overslid the bag. Rutschman has struggled to throw out runners this year and it took a pitch out and he still was safe until he overslid the bag.

Shouldn't have overslid the bag then.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 minute ago, Tony-OH said:

He's got a 4-1 lead and as at 72 pitches. I think it was too early. Maybe you don't let him face the tie run at the plate, but you got to let him see if he can get the next guy.

Hey, Tony. I don't see the button that allows me to upvote comments, but I am signed in. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, SteveA said:

I agree with that, I do think it's too early to play matchups because McKenna will now have at least 1 or 2 PAs vs RHPs.  But I was specifically responding to a post that said "you can't tell me that McKenna is a better matchup than O'Hearn even against a lefty".     So I completely stand by what I said as a valid response to that post.

 

 

I was just responding more towards the entire situation vs your accurate stat post.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, forphase1 said:

Did I say he made all the wrong moves?  Or that some of his moves are frustrating?  And even head scratching.  Besides,  even with the good record, that doesn't mean management or the front office is perfect and doesn't make mistakes.   Even the best teams should constantly be trying to get better and improve by making smarter decisions and replacing non-performing players. 

Write this post about all 30 managers in the MLB right now, because not a single one doesn't make fans frustrated. Ever....Ever. It's never been done in the history of baseball. It's really easy for us to manage from the comfort of our couches.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • Soto has had 6 years in the majors. Only 2 of them with an ERA under 4 and he's averaged a 100 ERA+. He has a career FIP of nearly 4. A career WHIP of over 1.4. Why is that valuable? Yeah, he can go on dominant runs. But so could Bryan Baker.  That's worth clogging up a spot and not getting somebody more consistent and...well...better?
    • Taking a look at 2023 vs 2024 FANGRAPHS WAR, some interesting directional info.  (Acknowledging that WAR is not definitivve,  FG uses FIPERA for Pitcher WAR).  This is meant to highlight areas of opportunity not a deep dive on data.  Highlighted 5 key areas:   1) TOR/Ace role /Burns FA.  All other roles 2-6 are likely fine.  Bradish coming back in 2nd half of 2025 would be a boost but should not be counted on.   Going into 2025 w/o sourcing a 4 WAR type of replacement for Burns would be a huge miss.    Most important decision/move for 2025.  2) Need to solidify closer and BP which is hopefully Felix coming back strong but should not depend on 2023 dominance.  Need a deep pen with reliable depth in minors and assume more trade deadline reinforcements.   Plenty of good options here, spend $ smartly but don't depend solely on waiver claims.  3) Adley - none of Elias' 2024 calculus included AR's huge 2nd half dropoff.    If he does not come back strong, may have to re-think AR contribution and make up for any defecit in other positions.  If Gunnar is a 10 and Adley's a 4 WAR we are more than fine, should not assume Adley is a 5+WAR player.  4) Santander - How is he best replaced.  Elevate Heston and pair him with a RH platoon partner who can back-up all three OF postions.  Not an easy find but needs to be impactful - a RH bat, preferably a high OBP type- that player does not exist in the org in terms of 2025 readiness.     Supposedly that's why Mayo is so highly valued as a RH  bat which is why not developing him as an OFer is curious.  5) Jackson Holliday - Biggest upside story for 2025.  Expect to see major improvement and the type of bat the lineup needs.  Should be settled in, got to experience the post season without playing but a lot of the Elias' plan/process is JH becoming a very good player.   
    • I don't get the idea of not wanting Soto back. First of all, lets talk about money.  He probably gets around $6M in arb for 2025. 37 relievers made 6M or more in 2024. 56 made 4M or more.  A 1/6 deal for him isnt bad and its not a long term commitment, which is a huge plus. After his 2 awful outings after he got here, Soto appeared in 20 games. He threw 16.1 innings and had a 1.10 ERA. He gave up 1 homer, walked 4, 11 hits and struck out 20.  For the season, his ERA was a mediocre 4.42 but his FIP was 3.68, his K rate was over 11 and his HR rate was .68. The issue is the walks. He is still only 29 years old, has over 60 appearances each of the last 4 years (ie he's durable) and he has very good seasons in the past. Even last year, when his ERA was 4.62, his xERA was 2.79 and his FIP was 3.59. With his ability to get Ks and miss bats and the upside he has, taking the chance on him for 1/6 is a risk you would be foolish not to take.
    • Haha. Our reliever with the lowest FIP & WHIP and highest K/BB rate.
    • Akin is discussed above. Pretty sure he is out of options as of this year. But I am far from a roster nerd.  Cano and Felix do have options but they are not the type of guys you would option assuming they are performing at a high level, only if they struggle. We are not going to want to option them just to get through a bullpen day or manage rest. 
    • It's a tough question. Akin stunk/hurt in 2023, this year he was very good in medium/low leverage situations. Suarez is a starter *and* was effective in relief. I don't know, think I'd rather have Suarez, tbh.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...