Jump to content

Who is the best defensive SS? Gunnar, Ortiz or Holliday?


wildcard

Recommended Posts

I know Holliday is the 1:1 Golden Boy that everyone goes nuts over but......  Gunnar has pretty good range and a strong arm at SS.   Ortiz is a slick fielder but is he better defensively than Gunnar or Holliday?    They are all good but who is the best defensive SS at this point.  Not in the future.  Now? And why?

Edited by wildcard
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Ortiz and it's not really close in my opinion. 

Can Gunnar play there? Sure as could Westburg. Hell, in a pinch you could throw Frazier at SS if needed. 

Ortiz and Mateo are very close in hands, range and footwork. Mateo has the stronger arm (I would put Gunnar's arm a tick above Joey's as well). I think that with Mateo's defense being not quite where it was last year, Joey has closed that gap between the two of them. Ortiz is the best defensive infielder that is in the system, period. The only argument would be Jorge but I think Joey is an overall better player on that side of the ball and more so in general. 

I maintain that Holliday ends up at 2nd when he is promoted to the Orioles. Much like Gunnar, he can play there. He probably won't hurt the defense by playing SS and yes he is only 19 and is going to improve but I just don't see him sticking at short. The arm strength is a tick below all of Mateo, Gunnar and Ortiz and from all of what I've seen of him I don't see Holliday as rangy as either of the three of them. Again, he will get better with age and reps of course but that's how I see it unfolding with all of them. 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It doesn’t make sense to compare Holliday to the other two at this point. I doubt many people have seen Holliday enough to have an informed opinion. And that doesn’t tell you how he will progress. While I think Ortiz is the best of the bunch, I think Gunnar plays a more than adequate SS. 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I haven't seen enough of any of them playing to judge. Based on the reports I think all three have the talent to play there. So far I like Gunnar's defense at SS better than 3B. Right now I think our best alignment is Urias 3B, Gunnar SS, Westburg 2B. I trust the organization to figure out the rest when the time comes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Range Factor this year at SS.

Gunnar       4.20

Ortiz           4.12

Mateo        3.90

Holliday      3.38 (3.60 at all levels for 2 years)

Westburg   3.27

For all those who don't like Range Factor.....Please show me a better stat that compares major and minor league fielding.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just about everybody knows that the obvious answer to this question is Ortiz.

However, a better question IMO that should be asked is which player gives the best value at SS considering both their defensive and offensive offerings?

Gunnar appears to be more than capable of manning SS right now (admittedly it is a small sample size at the Big League level thus far). And we know that Holliday will be given a regular spot in the infield. So again this comes down to which one the O's like more between Ortiz or Westburg.

I just can't see the Orioles pencilling the lesser talented player (Ortiz) for a permanent spot on the infield and then trying to figure things out by staffing the more talented players (Holliday and Henderson to fit around Ortiz.

I know that Joey Ortiz has a considerable fanbase/admirers on this site. But that logic doesn't seem to make sense in terms of how Major League teams usually operate. You usually want your most talented best/hitters to have regular places and then you usually staff around that.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, wildcard said:

Range Factor this year at SS.

Gunnar       4.20

Ortiz           4.12

Mateo        3.90

Holliday      3.38 (3.60 at all levels for 2 years)

Westburg   3.27

For all those who don't like Range Factor.....Please show me a better stat that compares major and minor league fielding.

There is way too much noise in Range Factor.  Books have been written on the subject.  (Okay, I’m exaggerating, but it’s been discussed ad nauseum.)

If Gunnar has more range than Mateo, then please gouge my eyes out because they’re clearly worthless.  Gunnar’s very solid though.  

I haven’t seen enough of any of the three to make an independent judgment on the topic, but from everything I’ve read, I think Ortiz is superior to Gunnar.  I don’t really know about Holliday, but he’s less experienced, so it’s not a completely fair comparison. 


 

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think its great to have this versatility.   After this season (possibly sooner), Frazier and Mateo will be gone.   It's nice to have three guys that can play shortstop efficiently, with another in the wings.  

Edited by clapdiddy
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • When he first came up, his slider was very mediocre and only really used as a get me over change of pace. Now it seems like a weapon. I wonder if he went to school with Professor Bradish for that.
    • Yeah, kinda why I asked the question. That seems real lofty for a comparison.
    • After a really disappointing April that saw his ERA balloon to 7.78, Alex Pham has found his bearings in May, allowing 3 ER in 14.1 IP, allowing 8 hits and 4 walks while striking out 17.   Yesterday Pham allowed a run on 2 hits and a walk in 4.2 innings, striking out 7.   53 of 72 pitches were strikes.  The sole run charged to Pham scored when reliever Kyle Virbitsky allowed a 2-out double to the first batter he faced after relieving Pham in the fifth.    Due to the poor start, Pham’s ERA still rests at an unimpressive 5.29, but he’s definitely been headed in the right direction.  Also, he’s struck out 40 batters in 34 innings.     
    • I can’t emphasize enough how stupid that rain delay was.  No rain at all for 45 minutes, then two hours of light mist, the kind that teams play through all the time.  I was standing near the kids play area during most of the delay and believe me, that rain didn’t deter any kids from using the playground equipment for two hours. Then, 15 minutes before the game is going to start, the grounds crew is watering the infield.  What? The game itself was not worth the wait, needless to say.   But what annoys me most is the complete lack of communication during these delays.  How about letting the fans who are there know what the thinking is about how long the delay will be?  How about an update every 30 minutes or so.   Nope, nothing.   Just a generic message on the scoreboard saying that the start of the game will be delayed to to the “threat” of inclement weather.   My phone was showing .05” of rain expected in the next six hours.  Some threat! On the bright side, the team did announce that ticket holders would be given vouchers that could be used for a Monday - Thursday game.  That was the least they could do.       
    • 19,286 for that rain-delayed mess of a game.  I’d say about 2/3 of those stuck through the 3 hour delay and were in their seats at game time.  
    • And paid Scherzer, and Zimmerman, and Corbin, and Werth.   They didn’t all work out, but nobody could say the Nats didn’t spend to put a winning team on the field during their run.  The run basically ended because Stras II and Corbin blew up in their face.   But there’s always 2019.   
    • I can’t believe that 8 hours after Grayson stepped off the mound, I’m the first person to update his thread.   After a 19-day IL stint and without a rehab stint, Grayson threw 6 innings of one-hit shutout ball last night.  The one hit was an infield squibber hit 59.5 mph off the bat.  His command was a tad shaky at times, as he walked three and hit a batter, but he still breezed through 6 innings on 82 pitches, 50 for strikes.  If it hadn’t been his first outing in three weeks, he certainly could have pitched the 7th inning.  Unfortunately, the bullpen blew it for him. Fastball topped out at 98.4 and he was still hitting 97 in his final inning.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...