Gunner and Adley vs Witt and Salvi

[Baseball fandom]

Who would you take? I'm guessing most will say Gunner and Adley just because of Salvi's age. If Perez was about 4 or 5 years younger I would definitely take the KC combo. It's  remarkable though what Perez continues to do as a catcher at his age. 

[Mooreisbetter27]

It’s Gunnar with an A. Have been seeing that a ton recently for some reason.  
 

To the question, because of the age, you’d think you’d want the Gunnar, Adley combo. At some point, Salvy has to break down you’d think. 

[Baseball fandom]

3 minutes ago, Mooreisbetter27 said:

It’s Gunnar with an A. Have been seeing that a ton recently for some reason.  
 

To the question, because of the age, you’d think you’d want the Gunnar, Adley combo. At some point, Salvy has to break down you’d think. 

Thanks for the correction. 

[Moose Milligan]

I saw where Salvy has walked 238 times in his career.  Bonds once walked 232 times in a season. 

That doesn’t really mean anything but even though I’ve been a harsh Adley critic lately I’m taking him based off age alone. 

[Yossarian]

27 minutes ago, Mooreisbetter27 said:

It’s Gunnar with an A. Have been seeing that a ton recently for some reason.  
 

To the question, because of the age, you’d think you’d want the Gunnar, Adley combo. At some point, Salvy has to break down you’d think. 

It seems Adley has already broken down,  so there's that. 

[MurphDogg]

This is the first year that Perez has approached Adley in rWAR (2.8 vs. 2.7). Adley was worth 9.9 rWAR between 2022 and 2023, while Perez was worth 3.2.

Witt is a year older and has played 126 more games than Gunnar, and Gunnar leads him in rWAR 14.8 to 14. 

I would be pretty floored if Perez and Witt were more valuable over the next three years while Adley is under team control. Not a lot of 35-37 year old catchers providing significant Major League value.

[Since1984]

21 minutes ago, Yossarian said:

It seems Adley has already broken down,  so there's that. 

It’s those F’n Boring PNC commercials. Wall sit? Hope that took one take you bank WS stealing commercials

seriously that commercial should have been one take. Since the AS break, AR has been icing his entire body