Postseason awards?

[Sports Guy]

Who gets your vote for:

AL Cy

NL Cy

AL MVP

NL MVP

AL ROY

NL ROY

[beaner]

Who gets your vote for:

AL Cy

NL Cy

AL MVP

NL MVP

AL ROY

NL ROY

AL Cy-CC Sabathia

NL Cy- Jake Peavy

AL MVP-Alex Rodriguez

NL MVP- Matt Holliday

AL ROY-Daisuke Matsuzaka

NL ROY-Ryan Braun

AL Manager- Eric Wedge

NL Manager-Clint Hurdle

[square634]

Who gets your vote for:

AL Cy - Sabathia

NL Cy - Peavy

AL MVP - A-Rod

NL MVP - Matt Holliday

AL ROY - Pedroia

NL ROY - Braun

AL Manager - Eric Wedge

NL Manager - Manny Acta

[Crazysilver03]

Who gets your vote for:

AL CY: Fausto Carmona

NL CY: Jake Peavy

AL MVP: Alex Rodriguez

NL MVP: Jimmy Rollins

AL ROY: Dustin Pedroia

NL ROY: Ryan Braun

Those are my votes.

[mweb]

Sabathia

Peavy

Arod

Wright despite the choking of the team.

Guthrie

Braun

[Crazysilver03]

The general consensus is that:

NL CY: Peavy

NL ROY: Braun

AL MVP: A-rod

Everything else is still up for grabs.

[Sports Guy]

The general consensus is that:

NL CY: Peavy

NL ROY: Braun

AL MVP: A-rod

Everything else is still up for grabs.

Agree....Go with Pedroia, Holliday(Rollins and Wright are close seconds) and Sabathia for the others.

[Crazysilver03]

AL ROY comes down to Pedroia vs. Dice-K, but Pedroia easily wins that one.

The AL CY, I give to Carmona just because he impressed me with how he turned his season around.

The NL MVP is between Rollins and Holliday, but I would tend to give it to Rollins just for the career year he had and that he carried the Phillies in the postseason today. It can go either way, since the same case can be made for Holliday.

[mweb]

I know most won't support Wright due to what happened with the Mets, but he was the best player in the NL imo, and was obviously on a contender.

[Sports Guy]

I know most won't support Wright due to what happened with the Mets, but he was the best player in the NL imo, and was obviously on a contender.

Wright had the highest WARP3 of the 3 players...1 better than Holliday and 2 better than Rollins.

[mweb]

Wright had the highest WARP3 of the 3 players...1 better than Holliday and 2 better than Rollins.

And the highest VORP and RC/G, huge edge in both over Rollins.

[Sports Guy]

I hadn't realized Wright had 34 steals this year.

Holliday had an OPS 50 points higher than Wright....He was better than him in almost all categories.

[mweb]

I hadn't realized Wright had 34 steals this year.

Holliday had an OPS 50 points higher than Wright....He was better than him in almost all categories.

Wright has a little better OBP, and like I said, the better RC/G and VORP. Also must consider position, defense(Wright is tremendous), and ballpark. Holliday only had an .860 road OPS. Switch home parks, and Wright easily has the higher OPS imo.

[twoBshorty]

AL Cy: C.C. Sabathia

NL Cy: Jake Peavy

AL MVP: Alex Rodriguez

NL MVP: Jimmy Rollins

AL ROY: Dustin Pedroia

NL ROY: Ryan Braun

AL MOY: Eric Wedge

NL MOY: Manny Acta

When do we hear about these awards, BTW? Are they all in November?

[mweb]

BTW, I recall getting bashed for saying Wright is close to MCab before the year, well maybe I was overestimating him then, but my foresight was tremendous. Wright's season > MCab's year.