Who will be the #5 and #6 prospects?

[Tony-OH]

Who will be the #5 and #6 prospects? 

[Tony-OH]

My only clue, if I had to guess, the majority will not get this one right.

[DirtyBird]

I wish Hays would have just gotten his AB’s to be removed as a prospect, to eliminate the semantics of how much of a “prospect” he should be considered.

[Tony-OH]

4 minutes ago, DirtyBird said:

I wish Hays would have just gotten his AB’s to be removed as a prospect, to eliminate the semantics of how much of a “prospect” he should be considered.

Not saying he's here or not, but at the end of the day, he hasn't "proven" anything in the majors yet so I'm fine with him still being a rookie. Plus, he'll get an entire year as a rookie and hopefully will be in the rookie of the year conversation like Means will be this year.

[DirtyBird]

2 minutes ago, Tony-OH said:

Not saying he's here or not, but at the end of the day, he hasn't "proven" anything in the majors yet so I'm fine with him still being a rookie. Plus, he'll get an entire year as a rookie and hopefully will be in the rookie of the year conversation like Means will be this year.

So, he’s not here. Damn, I already voted.

[weams]

DL Hall and Mountcastle

---

×

• 

  DirtyBird

  Yesterday at 09:06

• John Welch

  Yesterday at 09:07
• 

  Satyr3206

  Yesterday at 09:19

• MarCakes21

  Yesterday at 09:23
• 

  Ripken

  23 hours ago
• 

  The Goob

  23 hours ago
• 

  LookinUp

  23 hours ago

• UpstateNYfan

  23 hours ago
• 

  Greg Pappas

  23 hours ago

• Sydnor

  23 hours ago
• 

  weams

  23 hours ago
• 

  canonfaz

  23 hours ago
• 

  MurphDogg

  23 hours ago

• Absltgreek

  23 hours ago

• wildcard

  22 hours ago

• Frobby

  22 hours ago

• eddie83

  22 hours ago
• 

  Number5

  22 hours ago

• TGO

  22 hours ago
• 

  HarlowFan

  22 hours ago

• ChosenOne21

  21 hours ago

• Pickles

  21 hours ago
• 

  gold21030

  21 hours ago

• Pushmonkey

  21 hours ago
• 

  Mountain Bird

  21 hours ago
• 

  ReclaimTheCrown

  21 hours ago
• 

  ShaneDawg85

  21 hours ago

• WalkWithElias

  20 hours ago

• jkrout

  20 hours ago

• Lefty0315

  20 hours ago
• 

  Spl51

  20 hours ago
• 

  luismatos4prez

  19 hours ago
• 

  rudyrooster

  19 hours ago

• Corolla35

  19 hours ago

• Too Tall

  19 hours ago
• 

  olddogger

  19 hours ago

• maybenxtyr

  18 hours ago

• SilverRocket

  18 hours ago

• VaBird1

  17 hours ago

• Cavspider

  16 hours ago

• calsmanystances

  16 hours ago

• ChuckS

  15 hours ago
• 

  dabirds

  14 hours ago

• oriole

  14 hours ago
• 

  Jagwar

  14 hours ago
• 

  Camden_yardbird

  13 hours ago
• 

  24fps

  13 hours ago
• 

  NCRaven

  12 hours ago

• leftygrove

  10 hours ago
• 

  hgizzle

  10 hours ago

• cnmilton

  9 hours ago
• 

  sportsfan8703

  5 hours ago
• 

  ScGO's

  1 hour ago

• Triple Crown

  58 minutes ago
• 

  NJOsFan

  45 minutes ago

   

  Step on up and claim your Steak Knives. 

[jamalshw]

24 minutes ago, Tony-OH said:

My only cue, if I had to guess, the majority will not get this one right.

I wish I would have read the thread before voting. I voted Diaz and Baumann, but I now think it's Hays/Baumann as I think most expect Diaz to be in the top-5, let alone top-6, and this option would exclude him.

[DirtyBird]

11 minutes ago, jamalshw said:

I wish I would have read the thread before voting. I voted Diaz and Baumann, but I now think it's Hays/Baumann as I think most expect Diaz to be in the top-5, let alone top-6, and this option would exclude him.

I voted Hays/Baumann, but now I think it is Kremer, Diaz because this is the first Kremer has been a choice and everyone else I think already has been, except Hays, who was put in so many choices to throw people off and guess wrong.

[interloper]

Gotta be Kremer/Diaz.

[weams]

1 minute ago, interloper said:

Gotta be Kremer/Diaz.

Kremer is still on that rocket and Diaz is the 30 million dollar man. 

[Moose Milligan]

I went with Kremer and Diaz.  If so, interested to hear the justification for Diaz, not so much Kremer.   

[weams]

6 minutes ago, Moose Milligan said:

I went with Kremer and Diaz.  If so, interested to hear the justification for Diaz, not so much Kremer.   

Star power man. Star power. All the skills. Just need to corral them with good guidance.  He is so effortless. 

[Just Regular]

13 minutes ago, weams said:

Star power man. Star power. All the skills. Just need to corral them with good guidance.  He is so effortless. 

I was encouraged to see the points about Eastern League v. International League as run environments this year making Diaz's year not as bad as it seemed.  After so many years of Norfolk being the graveyard of hitting stats, it's a little bit of a tricky adjustment to make mentally.

[Tony-OH]

43 minutes ago, DirtyBird said:

I voted Hays/Baumann, but now I think it is Kremer, Diaz because this is the first Kremer has been a choice and everyone else I think already has been, except Hays, who was put in so many choices to throw people off and guess wrong.

I definitely think out my choices to throw people off, so whether a guy was on a list or not may or may not have any bearing on whether he's the next selection. I also switch it up where the choices do give you some indications. Basically, I try to give as little away as possible with the choices other than to make people think and to discuss the possibilities!

[LookinUp]

2 hours ago, Tony-OH said:

My only clue, if I had to guess, the majority will not get this one right.

I'm shocked Baumann isn't an option at #5. I think some would have taken that bait. Maybe me. Still not sure how I'll vote.