Jump to content

MLB-Draft.com's latest mock: 5-6-08


Recommended Posts

Go here or see below...

Round 1

1 Rays > Tim Beckham, H.S. SS, (GA)

2 Pirates > *Pedro Alvarez, College 3B/1B, Vanderbilt

3 Royals > Gordon Beckham, College SS, Georgia

4 Orioles > #Justin Smoak, College 1B, South Carolina

5 Giants > Buster Posey, College C, Florida State

6 Marlins > *Brian Matusz, LHSP, San Diego

7 Reds > Aaron Crow, College RHSP, Missouri

8 White Sox > *Kyle Skipworth, H.S. C, (CA)

9 Nationals > T. Scheppers, College RHSP, Fresno State

10 Astros > Shooter Hunt, College RHSP, Tulane

11 Rangers > *Eric Hosmer, H.S. 1B, (FL)

12 Athletics > Yonder Alonso, College 1B, Miami (FL)

13 Cardinals > Tim Melville, H.S. RHSP, (MO)

14 Twins > *C. Friedrich, College LHSP, E. Kentucky

15 Dodgers > *Brett DeVall, H.S. LHSP, (FL)

16 Brewers > Josh Fields, College RHRP, Georgia

17 Blue Jays > *Brett Wallace, College 1B, Arizona State

18 Mets > Ethan Martin, H.S. RHSP, (GA)

19 Cubs > Alex Meyer, H.S. RHSP, (IN)

20 Mariners > *R. Havens, College 2B, South Carolina

21 Tigers > Aaron Hicks, H.S. CF/RHSP, (CA)

22 Mets > Gerrit Cole, H.S. RHSP, (CA)

23 Padres > *Ike Davis, College 1B/OF, Arizona State

24 Phillies > Lance Lynn, College RHSP, Mississippi

25 Rockies > *David Cooper, College 1B, California

26 D'Backs > *Kyle Lobstein, H.S. LHSP, (AZ)

27 Twins > #Jemile Weeks, College 2B, Miami

28 Yankees > Andrew Cashner, RHRP, TCU

29 Indians > *C. Gillaspie, College 3B, Witchita State

30 Red Sox > *Zach Collier, H.S. OF, (CA)

Supplemental Round 1

31 Twins > *Dennis Raben, College OF, Miami

32 Brewers > Brad Holt, RHSP, UNC-Wilmington

33 Mets > *Allan Dykstra, College 1B, Wake Forest

34 Phillies > Cody Satterwhite, College RHSP, Ole Miss

35 Brewers > Scott Green, College RHSP, Kentucky

36 Royals > Tyler Sample, H.S. RHSP, (CO)

37 Giants > Ryan Perry, College RHP, Arizona

38 Astros > Jake Thompson, College RHSP, Virginia

39 Cardinals > Casey Kelly, H.S. SS, (FL)

40 Braves > Michael Palazzone, H.S. RHSP, (GA)

41 Cubs > *Nick Maronde, H.S. LHSP, (KY)

42 Padres > Bryan Price, RHRP, Rice

43 D'Backs > Sonny Gray, H.S. RHSP, (TN)

44 Yankees > *Tim Murphy, LHSP, UCLA

45 Red Sox > Zach Stewart, RHRP, Texas Tech

46 Padres > Casey Kelly, H.S. SS, (FL)

Round 2

47 Rays > Isaac Galloway, H.S. OF, (CA)

48 Pirates > *Ryan Flaherty, 2B/SS, Vanderbilt

49 Royals > Zach Putnam, RHRP, Michigan

50 Orioles > Tyson Ross, RHSP, California

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Interesting that they show teams moving towards position players early on and Crow / Matsuz moving beyond the top 5.

Not that I dislike the concept of having Smoak, but the thought we'd not get Alvarez or either of the Beckhams leaves me a little...I dunno...Disappointed?

We sure could use legit 1B prospects, though.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a single pitcher in the top 5? Really. I wonder if this could be a reaction to statistics at this time of year that tend to favor hot hitting position prospects.

I would be floored if the Pirates took a Boras client. I see them taking a pitcher.

Good point, quick fingers and agreement from this poster.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Go here or see below...

Round 1

1 Rays > Tim Beckham, H.S. SS, (GA)

2 Pirates > *Pedro Alvarez, College 3B/1B, Vanderbilt

3 Royals > Gordon Beckham, College SS, Georgia

4 Orioles > #Justin Smoak, College 1B, South Carolina

5 Giants > Buster Posey, College C, Florida State

6 Marlins > *Brian Matusz, LHSP, San Diego

7 Reds > Aaron Crow, College RHSP, Missouri

8 White Sox > *Kyle Skipworth, H.S. C, (CA)

9 Nationals > T. Scheppers, College RHSP, Fresno State

10 Astros > Shooter Hunt, College RHSP, Tulane

11 Rangers > *Eric Hosmer, H.S. 1B, (FL)

12 Athletics > Yonder Alonso, College 1B, Miami (FL)

13 Cardinals > Tim Melville, H.S. RHSP, (MO)

14 Twins > *C. Friedrich, College LHSP, E. Kentucky

15 Dodgers > *Brett DeVall, H.S. LHSP, (FL)

16 Brewers > Josh Fields, College RHRP, Georgia

17 Blue Jays > *Brett Wallace, College 1B, Arizona State

18 Mets > Ethan Martin, H.S. RHSP, (GA)

19 Cubs > Alex Meyer, H.S. RHSP, (IN)

20 Mariners > *R. Havens, College 2B, South Carolina

21 Tigers > Aaron Hicks, H.S. CF/RHSP, (CA)

22 Mets > Gerrit Cole, H.S. RHSP, (CA)

23 Padres > *Ike Davis, College 1B/OF, Arizona State

24 Phillies > Lance Lynn, College RHSP, Mississippi

25 Rockies > *David Cooper, College 1B, California

26 D'Backs > *Kyle Lobstein, H.S. LHSP, (AZ)

27 Twins > #Jemile Weeks, College 2B, Miami

28 Yankees > Andrew Cashner, RHRP, TCU

29 Indians > *C. Gillaspie, College 3B, Witchita State

30 Red Sox > *Zach Collier, H.S. OF, (CA)

Supplemental Round 1

31 Twins > *Dennis Raben, College OF, Miami

32 Brewers > Brad Holt, RHSP, UNC-Wilmington

33 Mets > *Allan Dykstra, College 1B, Wake Forest

34 Phillies > Cody Satterwhite, College RHSP, Ole Miss

35 Brewers > Scott Green, College RHSP, Kentucky

36 Royals > Tyler Sample, H.S. RHSP, (CO)

37 Giants > Ryan Perry, College RHP, Arizona

38 Astros > Jake Thompson, College RHSP, Virginia

39 Cardinals > Casey Kelly, H.S. SS, (FL)

40 Braves > Michael Palazzone, H.S. RHSP, (GA)

41 Cubs > *Nick Maronde, H.S. LHSP, (KY)

42 Padres > Bryan Price, RHRP, Rice

43 D'Backs > Sonny Gray, H.S. RHSP, (TN)

44 Yankees > *Tim Murphy, LHSP, UCLA

45 Red Sox > Zach Stewart, RHRP, Texas Tech

46 Padres > Casey Kelly, H.S. SS, (FL)

Round 2

47 Rays > Isaac Galloway, H.S. OF, (CA)

48 Pirates > *Ryan Flaherty, 2B/SS, Vanderbilt

49 Royals > Zach Putnam, RHRP, Michigan

50 Orioles > Tyson Ross, RHSP, California

This Casey Kelly kid must be some ballplayer for teams to try to draft him ever when he's already been taken :D

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Only two things I have to add to Greg's list.

1. I have my doubts that the Pirates take Alvarez. Call it a gut feeling...

2. I also doubt the Royals will pass on their hometown boy (i.e., Crow).

Otherwise, I'm in your corner, Greg. Great list as always. :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This Casey Kelly kid must be some ballplayer for teams to try to draft him ever when he's already been taken :D

He's really good if he can get two signing bonuses.

Maybe Greg can hire you as a cross-checker for his site. ;)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I would be floored if the Pirates took a Boras client. I see them taking a pitcher.

The Pirates have completely changed management since last year. While I don't think they'd put the money out for just any Boras client, Alvarez could be that exception.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a single pitcher in the top 5? Really. I wonder if this could be a reaction to statistics at this time of year that tend to favor hot hitting position prospects.

I would be floored if the Pirates took a Boras client. I see them taking a pitcher.

Well, this year's draft is heavy on positional talent and light on elite pitching. Still, I think both Crow and Matusz are gone in the first five picks. PIT and Matusz have had an open dialogue for some time, and the rumor is he's told them he'll sign for slot. My best guess right now would be:

TAM -- Posey or T-Bex

PIT -- Matusz

KAN -- Crow (even with the rough couple of weeks)

BAL -- one of G-Bex/Alvarez/Smoak or the left-over from TAMs Posey/T-Bex

Link to comment
Share on other sites

3rd Mock Draft I have seen so far with Texas taking Hosmer.

Looks like his demands are making him slip. As a resident of Dallas in shocked and pleasently pleased with this.

I havent heard anything from my Rangers interns regarding the draft, but i should hear something soon after finals.

Any other guys that might fall like Porcello from last year?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Doh! My bad... thanks. :)

Not at all and please don't think I meant anything negative by it.

However, there must be something about the kid for you to think of him twice - is he really good? Maybe we should hope / pray for him in R2!

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.



  • Posts

    • There have been numerous studies into whether home crowds affect referees' calls in other sports, mostly soccer and basketball. Many, I think most, found that referee calls do tend to favor the home team. There is a 2023 study about ball/strike calls in baseball that appears to be behind a pay wall, but it apparently found that home plate umpires favored home teams by a small, but statistically significant amount. https://www.valpo.edu/stories/2024/03/19/bias-at-the-plate-what-umpires-tell-us-about-evaluators/  Two thoughts. If it's true that umpires calls are affected by a (presumably subconscious) desire to please home crowds, it makes sense that the NYYs would reap the largest benefit (or among the largest benefits) of that bias.  Their home crowds not only are among the largest in MLB, they are among the loudest, "home"-est and most vociferous in MLB. If there were away to combine and assess those elements, I am pretty sure the NYYs would head the list. In addition, I'm sure that the NYYs play their away games before crowds that include more of their fans than any other team in its away games -- including both transplanted New Yorkers and fans with no connection to New York who elect to root for a perennial contender with a rich history of success. Second, one thing I've always wondered about is the identity of MLB's video reviewers. Who are they, how are they chosen, and how does MLB insure that they're not biased? They work in New York. Do they live in New York? Did they live in New York before they were hired? Might some of them be NYY fans, or one-time NYY fans? Or have family members or close friends who are NYY fans? (I may have thought about that because I grew up in the same Philadelphia suburb where longtime NL umpire Shag Crawford resided. I recall thinking about,  and probably talking with other kids about, how Crawford, who spent his entire life in the Philadelphia area, must be affected by that connection when he umpired Phillies games. 
    • Heck, we could still be the #1 seed in the AL if we win out and the Yankees and Guardians lose out. Dream big!
    • It should also be noted that all 4 WC series ended in two game sweeps last year.  So the 'game 3' start could very well be game 1 of the ALDS.  Not sure that would change anyone's answer, but it might lend itself to less of the 'piggyback' approach knowing its not a winner take all. I would go Kremer either way.
    • He won't make the WC roster, but it resets after every round so its possible for later in the playoffs.
    • CLE is only 1.5 games behind NYY for the #1 seed, so we could potentially play CLE in the ALDS. CLE plays the Reds tonight and then plays the Astros who have already clinched their division.
    • All I know is that when they offer to let you switch from Door #1 to Door #2 you do it.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...