Jump to content

Hypothetical trade for Yates


Recommended Posts

Could the Rangers be interested in Mountcastle?

Nate Lowe has a good BA/OBP but he has a sub 400 slugging and is likely going to be in the 10+M range next year. He seems like a prime candidate for a non tender.

Texas, if they sell, isn’t a team that’s going to rebuild but they certainly could sell off pieces that are free agents, like Yates and Scherzer but they only have so many long term holes.  First base could be one of those holes though.

Could we have something built around Mounty/Scherzer/Yates? 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

He is an experienced closer and appears to have his good stuff this year. I would think it will take quite a bit more than Pham. In principle, Yates is a good fit and Yates for a second tier prospect is a good framework for a deal. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

25 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

Could the Rangers be interested in Mountcastle?

Nate Lowe has a good BA/OBP but he has a sub 400 slugging and is likely going to be in the 10+M range next year. He seems like a prime candidate for a non tender.

Texas, if they sell, isn’t a team that’s going to rebuild but they certainly could sell off pieces that are free agents, like Yates and Scherzer but they only have so many long term holes.  First base could be one of those holes though.

Could we have something built around Mounty/Scherzer/Yates? 

Someone suddenly has a one-track mind about getting rid of Mountcastle in a deadline deal.  

  • Upvote 4
Link to comment
Share on other sites

54 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

Fansided is so bad.

Rangers could easily get a better prospect than that but I do like Yates as one of the BP targets.

I make that trade immediately if I'm Elias, but I also see the Rangers demanding a better prospect in return. Get Yates and another reliever solves much of the issues with the bullpen.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Sports Guy said:

Could the Rangers be interested in Mountcastle?

Nate Lowe has a good BA/OBP but he has a sub 400 slugging and is likely going to be in the 10+M range next year. He seems like a prime candidate for a non tender.

Texas, if they sell, isn’t a team that’s going to rebuild but they certainly could sell off pieces that are free agents, like Yates and Scherzer but they only have so many long term holes.  First base could be one of those holes though.

Could we have something built around Mounty/Scherzer/Yates? 

I think we’ve talked about this, but I would love to replace James McCann with Jonah Heim. Jonah Hime is a gold glove winner and even though he’s having a really bad offensive year compared to last year, he’s worlds better than McCann and would make it much easier to rest Adley more often. He has already been mentioned as a non-tender candidate because he’s apparently expecting a significant raise despite his mediocre season. Lowe might be as well, but it’s probably doubtful that they would move him now.

The Rangers, as current champs, are going to take a huge PR hit if they trade anybody but their departing free agents.

Half of their top 20 prospects are pitchers, but most have only 40-45 future values.

All of their outfielders are scuffling right now, but they are all really good so I doubt they would make any outfield trades, and just hope for some improvement from their guys.

I would love to get Robertson and Yates, and I wouldn’t mind Scherzer either. But we don’t have anybody they really need.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

9 hours ago, Sports Guy said:

Could the Rangers be interested in Mountcastle?

Nate Lowe has a good BA/OBP but he has a sub 400 slugging and is likely going to be in the 10+M range next year. He seems like a prime candidate for a non tender.

Texas, if they sell, isn’t a team that’s going to rebuild but they certainly could sell off pieces that are free agents, like Yates and Scherzer but they only have so many long term holes.  First base could be one of those holes though.

Could we have something built around Mounty/Scherzer/Yates? 

I can’t see them moving anyone from the ML team, except maybe Hays or Urias, in a deadline deal. Maybe move Mountcastle in the off-season. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 hours ago, HowAboutThat said:

I think we’ve talked about this, but I would love to replace James McCann with Jonah Heim. Jonah Hime is a gold glove winner and even though he’s having a really bad offensive year compared to last year, he’s worlds better than McCann and would make it much easier to rest Adley more often. He has already been mentioned as a non-tender candidate because he’s apparently expecting a significant raise despite his mediocre season. Lowe might be as well, but it’s probably doubtful that they would move him now.

The Rangers, as current champs, are going to take a huge PR hit if they trade anybody but their departing free agents.

Half of their top 20 prospects are pitchers, but most have only 40-45 future values.

All of their outfielders are scuffling right now, but they are all really good so I doubt they would make any outfield trades, and just hope for some improvement from their guys.

I would love to get Robertson and Yates, and I wouldn’t mind Scherzer either. But we don’t have anybody they really need.

Even if Heim were available, don’t you think a team that really needs a catcher is more likely to offer a better deal. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)
17 minutes ago, waroriole said:

I can’t see them moving anyone from the ML team, except maybe Hays or Urias, in a deadline deal. Maybe move Mountcastle in the off-season. 

I tend to agree. Mounty potentially represents a player we could use to bring back stuff we need while not giving up more and more MiL pieces.

My thought is that we only have so many bullets to fire off. Now, you never know how teams feel about our players but if we are rightfully keeping our top 3 plus any young player on the ML team, we start to run out of ammo.

As has been discussed, the Os system starts to thin out a little and once you have dealt Norby, Stowers and Beavers, the options start to dry up fast.

So, how else can you do it? Well, with the extra WC and so many more teams involved, I personally believe you will start to see more contender/contender trades. Now, in this case Texas isn’t a contender but they think they will be next year and first base is a potential hole.

The Os, who have been playing Mayo at first recently, have other first base options and Mounty is a guy who is likely not here next year.

So for me, he makes sense to shop if you get the right guys for him. Im Not sure I trade him for guys who can’t help this year or not, it would depend on the trade but if Mounty can be the key (only?) piece in getting Yates/LeClerg/Robertson and Scherzer, I’m all on board for that. I think that makes us a better team. 
 

Now, if we can use MiLers to do that and we have enough left to make other moves, that’s fine too.

 

Edited by Sports Guy
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

I tend to agree. Mounty potentially represents a player we could use to bring back stuff we need while not giving up more and more MiL pieces.

My thought is that we only have so many bullets to fire off. Now, you never know how teams feel about our players but if we are rightfully keeping our top 3 plus any young player on the ML team, we start to run out of ammo.

As has been discussed, the Os system starts to thin out a little and once you have dealt Norby, Stowers and Beavers, the options start to dry up fast.

So, how else can you do it? Well, with the extra WC and so many more teams involved, I personally believe you will start to see more contender/contender trades. Now, in this case Texas isn’t a contender but they think they will be next year and first base is a potential hole.

The Os, who have been playing Mayo at first recently, have first base options and Mounty is a guy who is likely not here next year.

So for me, he makes sense to shop if you get the right guys for him. Im Not sure I trade him for guys who can’t help this year or not, it would depend on the trade but if Mounty can be the key (only?) piece in getting Yates/LeClerg/Robertson and Scherzer, I’m all on board for that. I think that makes us a better team. 
 

Now, if we can use MiLers to do that and we have enough left to make other moves, that’s fine too.

 

That’s a fair plan for trading Mounty. I wouldn’t hesitate to include him if the other team saw him as enough to replace someone like Norby in a package. But, given how this team is afraid of rookie playing time, I can’t see them putting Mayo in a spot where they’d have to rely on him against LHP. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Looking at last year we had some trades for high profile relievers. 

  • Paul Sewald cost the Diamondbacks INF Josh Rojas (MLB), OF/1B Dominic Canzone (#19) and INF Ryan Bliss (#29).
  • David Robertson cost the Marlins INF Marco Vargas (#18) and C Ronald Hernandez (#21).
  • Jordan Hicks cost the Blue Jays RHP Sem Robberse (#7) and RHP Adam Kloffenstein (NR).
  • Kendall Graveman cost the Astros C Korey Lee (#7).
  • Aroldis Chapman cost the Rangers LHP Cole Ragans (MLB - whoops) and OF Roni Cabrera (NR).
  • Brad Hand cost the Braves RHP Alec Barger (NR) though Hand was not having a good season.

Absolutely not trading Mountcastle for a rental relief pitcher, that's bizarre.

  • Thanks 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

  • Posts

    • Would you feel better about this pick if they saved ~$300,000 -$500,000 against his slot value? He's unlikely to go back to UNC for his senior year. I think the O's could save quite a bit of money. @Frobby you've been in tough negotiations before your retirement. Do you think the O's have the ability and desire to save money on this pick? 
    • Kinda hard to know though because the $cost per win in general will rise over the coming years.  
    • For those who don't follow Florida JUCO baseball, Northwest Florida State Junior College is a baseball powerhouse that is rather notorious for providing a platform for promising HS players to get drafted. (https://www.nwfraiders.com/sports/bsb/index). They were 40-15 last year and lost in the Championship game of the D1 JUCO National Championship. So they were the second best JUCO team in the nation.  They had 5 guys drafted off that team including Mack Estrada RHP to Yankee$ in round 11 (#331) and Colby Jones, INF to Braves in round 13 (#401). (https://www.nwfraiders.com/general/2024-25/releases/20240717ms8qm5). Multiple kids from NWFS go on the D1 4 years schools including SEC schools. This is a move up for George in terms of baseball development opportunities and gets him back into the draft in 2025.  While you never know whether kids will "bet on themselves" and take overslot money to turn pro, this move to NWFS indicates to me that he will be a tough sign.
    • The Rule 5 play is revisionist at best. The Orioles 40 man was pretty tight with our potentially injured pitchers and the fact that Holiday was near his shot.    As it was, the bullpen had very little maneuverability and adding another piece that couldn’t go up and down makes it easy to understand why we didn’t pick one. 
    • I don’t know if the O’s will be able to fix Honeycutt or not, but it’s worth the risk.  He seems like he’s likely to make the majors even if he can’t really be fixed, and could be a well above average starter if he can be fixed to a decent degree.  I’m not usually someone who likes guys with a poor hit tool, but at 22 this was a good gamble.  
    • Occasionally, though, you strike gold, and you get a Ryan 'Flash' Godflaherty. 🤩
    • Yeah, I don't understand. We have: the #1 farm system with 2 prospects in the top 5 and 3 in the top 15 the #1 rated prospect three years in a row (possibly 4 if Basallo goes off in the 2nd half) the best record in the AL 4 All-Stars including the AS starting pitcher better depth of position players than any team in baseball a new owner whose indicated he'll spend to improve the team and who is clearly a huge baseball fan and not a dick last years AL manager of the year a legit top 2 MVP candidate who is under team control for years to come the best closer in baseball (unfortunately injured) the best ballpark in baseball (I'm biased, but sue me) at least 5 players performing at or near All-Star levels who were castoffs from other teams (Santander, O'Hearn, Cano, Webb, Coulombe) two legit ACE / #1 starter candidates under multi-year team control (G-Rod, Bradish) at least a 5 year championship window, and possibly a 10 year window if things break our way one of the best GMs in the game one of the lowest payrolls in the game, giving ownership the ability to spend to improve the club the most HRs in the league, leading the Yankees and their "money is no object" payroll by a wide margin And I'm sure I'm missing some other positives. What the hell do people want?
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...