Jump to content

4/5 - Tides vs. Knights game three!


spleen1015

Recommended Posts

So if Elias cares about defense so much how come the defense is so poor?

Are they all supposed to suddenly jump from below average to good in the next few weeks?

Other than Jackson all these guys have had questions about their defense since draft day right?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

24 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

So if Elias cares about defense so much how come the defense is so poor?

Are they all supposed to suddenly jump from below average to good in the next few weeks?

Other than Jackson all these guys have had questions about their defense since draft day right?

I think Avg. EV trumps D and you figure it out from there.
 

But all seriousness, the miscues tonight are non-prospects mostly.  Also, guys are playing all over the field slightly out of position.

I think there is something to be said for that.  The myelination effect.  Super focus on a new skill, make it difficult, challenges always, no similar reps and skills will grow.  Rinse repeat fall into boring pattern and skills will not grow.  I think he puts folks out of their comfort zone a bit in the minors to promote skill growth.  Just a hunch. 

Edited by emmett16
Link to comment
Share on other sites

5 minutes ago, emmett16 said:

I think Avg. EV trumps D and you figure it out from there.
 

But all seriousness, the miscues tonight are non-prospects mostly.  Also, guys are playing all over the field slightly out of position.

I think there is something to be said for that.  The myelination effect.  Super focus on a new skill, make it difficult, challenges always, no similar reps and skills will grow.  Rinse repeat fall into boring pattern and skills will not grow.  I think he puts folks out of their comfort zone a bit on the minors.  Just a hunch. 

But shouldn't that be happening before AAA?

Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

But shouldn't that be happening before AAA?

I follow the Tides fairly closely.  I don't follow the lower minors as much.  I imagine they do it throughout.  I believe I've heard interviews about how their programming is consistent from the lowest levels to the highest and their special assistants (coaches) are roving up and down throughout the system.  I think they are all playing form the same sheet of music.  

Biggest jump in all baseball is AAA to MLB.  I think sometimes we all take for granted how darned good the guys in MLB are.  They make the impossible look easy...most of the time. 

I also think that's why we see so much positional movement at the MLB level.  

Edited by emmett16
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, Sports Guy said:

Btw, I think the new way of scheduling where you play the same team for a week is annoying.

Not if you're a 20-24 year old riding a bus lol 

 

But yes, from a fan standpoint, it's pretty lame. 

Edited by emmett16
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

6 minutes ago, emmett16 said:

I follow the Tides fairly closely.  I don't follow the lower minors as much.  I imagine they do it throughout.  I believe I've heard interviews about how their programming is consistent from the lowest levels to the highest and their special assistants (coaches) are roving up and down throughout the system.  I think they are all playing form the same sheet of music.  

Biggest jump in all baseball is AAA to MLB.  I think sometimes we all take for granted how darned good the guys in MLB are.  They make the impossible look easy...most of the time. 

I also think that's why we see so much positional movement at the MLB level.  

If they have been doing this for three to four years shouldn't they be better at it?

At some point you need to decide if Mayo is actually a third baseman.  Folks gave Dan grief for keeping Mountcastle at Short for too long. 

All the stuff you are talking about is great if the player can do it.

But I question how good it is when you have a bunch of guys that had questions on defense when they were drafted and those questions are still present years later.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 minutes ago, Can_of_corn said:

If they have been doing this for three to four years shouldn't they be better at it?

At some point you need to decide if Mayo is actually a third baseman.  Folks gave Dan grief for keeping Mountcastle at Short for too long. 

All the stuff you are talking about is great if the player can do it.

But I question how good it is when you have a bunch of guys that had questions on defense when they were drafted and those questions are still present years later.

I think it's all about the growth mindset and trying to find a competitive advantage.  Like, they believe it should work and be better and are sticking to their guns even though first glance shows poor results.  I have to imagine they have some internal metrics to measure their own process & progress.  

But again, this is just me guessing.  And I'm not going to sit here and say it works and is the way to do it.  I like the thought process, but like you I haven't seen the process coming to fruition yet and have reservations.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • If you’d rather have Trumbo under any circumstances, well then. God only knows how many extra runs scored because he let a ball fall in front of him, but it was a lot. An out at the plate is only an out, and it may or may not come with RISP, but a missed catch in the OF gives the offense another chance, extends the inning, puts more pressure on the pitcher.  Mullins saved a lot of runs with his defense and speed even when he wasn’t hitting. im not talking about errors, nor am I talking about routine fly balls, but about the extra inches a good defender gets that make the difference between a catch and a non- catch, and that’s important. And no one knows before the game what will be required of the defender. nine guys come to the plate, and if one of them is in the lineup not for his offense, but for what he offers with the glove, that’s fine. The other eight should cover for him. Thats why Kevin Pillar had a successful career.
    • Not sure why you bothered to quote me. I was helping another poster figure out how not important a left fielder is when it comes to defense in the modern game. You don't start a left fielder for defense.
    • Were we on Sunday Night Baseball that Sunday 9/17?    My Google of Rosh Hashanah 2023 said it ended at sundown the Sunday. I'm not Jewish either but I am baseball, and in childhood the Sandy Koufax stories I remembered most were about Yom Kippur. The Google also reminded me Kremer's turn as Texas finished the sweep was just 2 days after October 7th. Let's get a sweep, guys.
    • I don’t care what Slater did before he came to us this season. Just like I didn’t care what Hicks did before he came to us last year.  Since we acquired Slater he has a .707 OPS vs LHP and Cowser has a .500 OPS vs LHP.  It’s a coin flip. If we stick to what we’ve done, then it will be Slater. He hasn’t not started versus a LH SP since we acquired him.  I’m good with him or Cowser. Mullins is a lock. If I had to bet I’d think the lineup will be, 1. Gunnar SS L 2. Westburg 2B R 3. Santa RF S 4. Mounty 1B R 5. Adley DH S 6. Slater LF R 7. Urias 3B R 8. Mullins CF L 9. McCann C R
    • So he pitched on it last season?
    • Without Looking - Do you know who was second in Innings Pitched?  Pretty incredible.
    • Looks like it began on Friday, Sep 15 and ended on Sunday, Sep 17.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...