Jump to content

How much faith do you have in Elias to address the needs this month?


How much faith do you have in Elias to address the needs this month?  

90 members have voted

  1. 1. How much faith do you have in Elias to address the needs this month?

    • Total faith. In Elias we trust. He's not going to waste this year of Burnes. We're getting a very good SP and RP, at the least.
    • I feel pretty good about the deadline. Fairly certain he will address the pitching in a meaningful way.
    • Eh, not great? There may not be a lot of sellers and Elias may not give up the pieces it will take. Maybe a deadline akin to 2023.
    • It's gonna be a total botch. Elias misreads the room and can't lock down any meaningful trades, while other teams are aggressive and get deals done.


Recommended Posts

43 minutes ago, HowAboutThat said:

I reiterate my vote. I don’t actually think Mike will do nothing, but I do think he will do nothing significant, which I think was the actual intent of the question.

I think a far better question would be to ask what is Mike’s goal? This is the third year of success, even less than that if you remember that last May or so we were 10 games under .500.

Maybe he doesn’t care about winning a series this year and is more interested in his pipeline of successful players?

It’s clear he has to trade several players simply because they’re wasting away in the minors, but he certainly hasn’t yet.

Who is wasting away in the minors?  No one is the answer.  They gave Holliday second base and he wasn’t ready despite the majority opinion here at OH.  Stowers and Norby aren’t here because there are better players at the major league level.  Mayo is not wasting away.  If he doesn’t come up until next year it won’t hurt his career one bit.  They want him to get better at defense or he would be here.  They will move someone in the offseason to make room for him and Holliday if he shows he is ready.  At 20 years old he can spend a couple more years in the minors and still won’t be wasting away.

  • Upvote 1
  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1. The new owner needs to sign Burnes, Rutschman, and Henderson to long term deals. Consider similar deals for Westburg and Grayson.

2. Don’t really care about short term trades that supposedly get us to the WS. More interested in long term success.

3. Willing to trade any of Hayes, Santander, Mountcastle, Stowers, Norby, Beavers, Bradfield, or lower prospect for RP or 4,5 starter.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I have a ton of faith in the FO, but the way the poll was worded, had to cast my vote a little lower.  

We won't know for years - if ever - which offers were made but rejected.

Grayson has given everything I was hoping for from Bradish.  Burnes has exceeded the hype.  So, we need to replace the #3/#4 pitcher we expected Grayson to be.  Suarez is still a great surprise.  Kremer, in my mind, is trending upward.  A solid #3 would be thrilling.

On the reliever front, one solid (non-elite) leverage-type reliever can push Tate/Baker/Akin back to Tidewater and make the whole BP look better.  And Coloumbe returns for the push.

I guess I'm saying we don't need an ace and a closer, but a #3 and a 7th inning specialist.  Should be doable.

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

1 hour ago, accinfo said:

Who is wasting away in the minors?  No one is the answer.  They gave Holliday second base and he wasn’t ready despite the majority opinion here at OH.  Stowers and Norby aren’t here because there are better players at the major league level.  Mayo is not wasting away.  If he doesn’t come up until next year it won’t hurt his career one bit.  They want him to get better at defense or he would be here.  They will move someone in the offseason to make room for him and Holliday if he shows he is ready.  At 20 years old he can spend a couple more years in the minors and still won’t be wasting away.

They are wasting way because they are major league ready players who are not on a major league team. They are wasting away because we can’t use them. We don’t have a place for them, but instead of trading them, we are letting them languish.

It is silly not to find a trade partner for them. If the value is low, well, the value is low, and you get what you can.

I was talking about neither Holliday nor Mayo, and I’m sorry I wasn’t clear enough. but you mentioned Stowers and Norby and you mentioned it exactly the problem that exists they’re not here because we don’t have room for them.
I am one of the very few voices who wants mayo to remain where he is unless he develops worthwhile defense, although I would be happy to trade him.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Posted (edited)
6 hours ago, accinfo said:

Who is wasting away in the minors?  No one is the answer.  They gave Holliday second base and he wasn’t ready despite the majority opinion here at OH.  Stowers and Norby aren’t here because there are better players at the major league level.  Mayo is not wasting away.  If he doesn’t come up until next year it won’t hurt his career one bit.  They want him to get better at defense or he would be here.  They will move someone in the offseason to make room for him and Holliday if he shows he is ready.  At 20 years old he can spend a couple more years in the minors and still won’t be wasting away.

Because there are “Better Players” doesn’t mean they aren’t wasting away in the minors. Neither guy has anything left to prove in AAA. 

You’re right about Mayo who is 22 …. But we have 6 prospects who are 24 or older in our top 30. These players start to diminish in value due to age. 

Edited by Roll Tide
Link to comment
Share on other sites

11 hours ago, Sports Guy said:

Total faith 

Me too. I think he’ll get us a game 3 SP that’s a better option than Suarez, and he’ll get us a high leverage arm for the bullpen. 

But… other people have different wants/expectations. 

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • It’s more about the idea of giving up assets for someone who may not help you at all when you need it the most.
    • I remember Cashman giving some pretty sharp comments during 2023 spring training after Montas played out mostly as damaged goods when the Yankees traded for him in 2022. Yankees general manager Brian Cashman was very frank with reporters when discussing the trade on Feb. 15 in Tampa, per Joel Sherman of the New York Post. “We haven’t gotten access to the pitcher that we know what he is capable of when he is right,” Cashman said. “Clearly it hasn’t worked out at all. You know we didn’t really get anything out of it. I’m not looking for a headline of I regret the trade and then they run Montas down. This is part of doing business when you’re dealing with pitchers and there’s no guarantees and he came over with a clean bill of health. And obviously he wasn’t healthy, so the trade goes into a bad category. We gave up assets and we didn’t get anything for it. That’s also part of the business. I’ve traded players that have gone on and gotten hurt elsewhere and I’ve acquired players who [have gotten hurt]. You just don’t want to be a part of it, but it happens.”
    • Hernandez was coming off of a 107 OPS+, I think teams might have been reluctant he was falling off. The last time Santander had an OPS+ under 120 was in 2021.
    • He's hit more HRs in the past 3 years than any switch hitter in baseball and doesn't kill you in the field. His getting a QO was never in doubt. Not even in May.
    • I'm telling you why he should be moved (to the minors or in a trade) now, especially because there are superior replacement options on the major league roster and in the minors that can be more productive than him, as well as make the 26-man roster more versatile. It's perfectly reasonable for us to disagree on the timing on when the team will or should move on from Hays, and you're most likely correct that it will most likely be this offseason. But because I want the team to win a World Series this season, I hope they move on from him now/ASAP. Unfortunately, because of Elias's track record with even worse players such as Rougned Odor, Adam Frazier, Aaron Hicks, Ryan McKenna, and Jorge Mateo, I do think it'll be much later than I'd want. And, in my opinion, it's going to be to the detriment of the team. Another thing to consider - you point out that Hays has an OPS over .800 against lefties in 2024 at the moment. I don't think it's reasonable to consider that to be sustainable to due Hays' own career splits. Hays has a career OPS against lefties of .788. So it's reasonable to expect Hays to wind up close to that number by the end of this season. Even if Hays settles at .800 OPS against lefties as his final line, that'll mean he's likely going to be slashing an OPS of below .725ish (maybe less, I'm not great with math on the fly) the rest of the way to wind up there. That's not really any kind of significant platoon advantage to be benching Kjerstad in particular. The other reason it's reasonable to expect Hays' OPS against lefties to regress is that, just as Hays has a pronounced favorable career split against LHP, he also has a pronounced unfavorable career split in the second half. For his career, Hays has hit .242/.296/.710 in the second half, for a tOPS+ of 90. So Hays in the second half has been 10 percent worse than his total career OPS. That makes sense given Hays is an injury prone player and tends to play through nagging injuries, leading to diminished production at the plate.  Hays is/has been playing hurt. So it's not good baseball to stick with him and merely hope for the best, or to expect for him to continue overperforming considering his talent level, underlying metrics, and his career production. Its best to move on quickly to the younger options the team has available to replace him. 
    • Teoscar Hernandez seems like the good comp for what type of salary he would get though the year he having hitting might pass that.  Hernandez took a 1 year deal for 23.5 million for little bounce back deal.  
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...