Jump to content

DL Hall 2019


weams

Recommended Posts

7 hours ago, orioles22 said:

Not sure how the gamecast works, but it looks like Hall is hitting the corners and everything is being called a ball unless it's right down the middle. It looks like he's having to throw it down the middle to get a strike.

 

3 hours ago, connja said:

Another poor start for Hall.  Seems to not have his control so far this spring.  Hope it gets better soon.

I'll try and see him in person.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

37 minutes ago, Frobby said:

Great game tonight for Hall: 5 IP, 1 H, 0 R, 1 BB, 8 K’s.   For good measure, Luis Perez provided 4 innings of 2 hit relief, striking out 7.    

I watched Hall's innings and Perez's first two. I'd seen Perez earlier in the year as well. 

Hall looked like a guy who is in the conversation for the best pitching prospect in baseball. I mean it was that good, no one hit the ball hard, he was blowing fastballs by people, getting ahead with curveballs and sliders for strikes, had feel for the changeup. Fastball was 94-97 again with life. The stuff is better than any LHP in the minors. He put lefties in the bucket with breaking balls that ended up on the plate more than once. Command could still be improved, but control was there and he did spot it up at times. 

Perez is a fun guy, he's older, but the stuff is interesting. He's 90-93 with some serious armside run on the fastball, it must be a 2S grip. His slider has practically the opposite movement with considerable gloveside horizontal break. He has a hard time controlling his stuff because of the substantial horizontal movement on both pitches, but when he gets ahead in counts, he's hard to square up.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Luke-OH changed the title to DL Hall 2019
4 hours ago, Luke-OH said:

I watched Hall's innings and Perez's first two. I'd seen Perez earlier in the year as well. 

Hall looked like a guy who is in the conversation for the best pitching prospect in baseball. I mean it was that good, no one hit the ball hard, he was blowing fastballs by people, getting ahead with curveballs and sliders for strikes, had feel for the changeup. Fastball was 94-97 again with life. The stuff is better than any LHP in the minors. He put lefties in the bucket with breaking balls that ended up on the plate more than once. Command could still be improved, but control was there and he did spot it up at times. 

Perez is a fun guy, he's older, but the stuff is interesting. He's 90-93 with some serious armside run on the fastball, it must be a 2S grip. His slider has practically the opposite movement with considerable gloveside horizontal break. He has a hard time controlling his stuff because of the substantial horizontal movement on both pitches, but when he gets ahead in counts, he's hard to square up.

Great report about both.     Your assessment of Hall is mouthwatering.    Let’s hope that, like last year, he keeps improving as the season progresses.    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

52 minutes ago, Frobby said:

Great report about both.     Your assessment of Hall is mouthwatering.    Let’s hope that, like last year, he keeps improving as the season progresses.    

I've said it before, but I'll reiterate, the only real question with Hall (other than staying healthy of course) is command. If he gets to average command, he's going to be a #1/#2 guy. There are only 2 left handed starting pitcher in the majors who throw as hard or harder than Hall (Paxton and Snell). Hall's secondaries are better than Paxton's. The thing last year is the CB and SL weren't really distinct pitches, now they are and both are better than last year. The changeup is better than I saw it last year (although some evaluators saw a plus change last year, I saw fringe to average). So while I'm not on board with 4 plus pitches yet (as Meoli states in his article), it's probably comfortably a 60 FB, 60 CB, 55 SL, 55 CH. 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

2 hours ago, Luke-OH said:

I've said it before, but I'll reiterate, the only real question with Hall (other than staying healthy of course) is command.

Of course, that’s always a huge, criminally underrated “if.”   Still, that’s quite a scouting report for a 20-year old in A-ball.  

Link to comment
Share on other sites

19 minutes ago, LookinUp said:

This thread took a nice turn.

We’v Been waiting since Messina for one of these guys to pan out. Hopefully this is the guy. Would be beautiful if Gray Rod also ends up as a 1a to Hall’s 1.

I’d argue that Bedard panned out.   Thankfully MacPhail had the foresight to trade him at peak value, because I wouldn’t view him the same way if he’d stayed with us and spent half his time on the IL the next few years.    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.


  • Posts

    • Two routine plays by a ML 3B. 
    • It’s not strange at all. They brought him back quickly off the IL because they felt he could hit. He has sat twice since bringing him back…day games after a night game. When he was playing in the field, he was getting a day off every week as well. So, they are giving him an extra day off as he recovers from an injury..being extra cautious with him. I don’t think that’s strange at all. If he needed TJ surgery, they wouldn’t have brought him back and it’s not likely his elbow has gone from tendonitis to a torn ligament in a weeks time (ie, it’s not likely to have gotten that much worse) I had tennis elbow and couldn’t lift anything heavier than a cell phone without having a lot of pain and ended up having to get 3 cortisone injections for it to be ok. Suffice it to say, if this is what he’s experiencing, he likely couldn’t lift a bat, much less get hits. They are essentially letting him rehab while playing, which indicates to me their intention of having him up this year.
    • If he’s at the point where he’s throwing off the mound, he might not need too much rehab outings. Heck, you get a 26 man roster for a 3/5/7 game series. You can even go with him as a prayer on a big roster and even IL him and replace him mid series. What would we have to lose. He most certainly has the frame to help out.  We’ll see. I hope. 
    • I understand @Sports Guy ‘s thinking here. If Adley/Basallo are your C/DH next year, Holliday is at 2B, Mounty has more trade value than O’Hearn, but even with all that… can we really move on from Santa and Mounty in the offseason? It sounds plausible, and that could be our Burnes money, but that is a lot to move on from on a b2b 100 win team.  It just is. But I can see the thinking. Use the saved money from Mounty/Santa for Burnes’ 2025 salary. Then trade Mounty for a SP. The 2025 rotation would then be Burnes, Grayson, Traded for SP, Irvin, Povich. Kremer and Suarez in the mix as well. 
    • You could argue that, except that a trade where Westburg is the center piece won’t get you a #1 starter. Trading a young controllable MVP level player can absolutely be a smart thing to do if you’re getting a young controllable Cy Young level pitcher back (Skubal, for example). 
    • Realistically, they can ask for the moon and it likely not be an overpay. If he stays healthy all year I think the plan was to move him back to the rotation next year. He's under control for a long time.
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...