Jump to content

Source: O's working on Fernando Rodney...


Bazooka Jones

Recommended Posts

Ya'll realize if we spend 5m or more on Rodney there won't be many marbles left right?

This move just screams of desperation and looks reactionary to say the least. Got to keep the charade going though, they are trying. They really are.

Wha? 5 mill puts us at about 88. That leaves 12.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • Replies 269
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Didn't Rodney pitch in the WBC last year? Isn't there a long history of pitchers having good years and then pitching in the WBC and having a bad year? Question is what is the rebound rate after that.

At least it is something to grasp onto if Rodney does sign with the Orioles.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Didn't Rodney pitch in the WBC last year? Isn't there a long history of pitchers having good years and then pitching in the WBC and having a bad year? Question is what is the rebound rate after that.

At least it is something to grasp onto if Rodney does sign with the Orioles.

Well, that's something at least :)

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just don't understand how anybody could prefer him over Johnson. If Johnson drove you mad, Rodney will drive you nuts. Yes I know 2012 was an amazing season for Rodney, but so it was the same for Johnson and that didn't buy him much love one year later. He'd been worth 1.4 WAR his entire career prior to 2012. Even for a reliever that just isn't inspiring. Even before 2012, JJ had been worth 6.4 WAR. Bottom line, as a set up guy he could be tolerable, but expensive. As a closer, I just don't see the reason to go with Rodney at this point over Hunter. Their best chance was Balfour and that blew up in the face. Rodney is not a good consolation prize, at all.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

You could absolutely argue that Rodney is a better fit than Balfour or Johnson.

In the case of Johnson, it's as simple as Rodney should not cost as much as the $10MM JJ got. It should be much closer to the $12MM that Balfour received.

With Balfour, both pitchers have big K numbers. Both have had BB problems (4.4/9 career for Rodney and 3.9/9 career for Balfour). The big difference? Balfour is a FB pitcher (career 35% GB rate) and Rodney is a GB pitcher (career 50% GB rate) which profiles better at OPACY.

A lot of the Rodney hate stems from the arrow-shooting and the fact that he had a couple truly awful years in the middle of his career.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Archived

This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.


  • Posts

    • First.. most is not accurate as it relates to those who questioned Gunnar sticking at SS. There were concerns but it was hardly a consensus. Secondly, the questions on Gunnar as a SS were not about his skill/talent as a defender. The two main concerns were whether he could be more consistent to occupy the most premier infield position for you and if he would outgrow SS. There weren't questions around his arm, his ability to make plays in the hole, his mechanics fielding a groundball, etc. etc. so that statement above is quite misleading.  Gunnar may outgrow SS. At 22 he's 6'4ish and probably every bit of 215 lbs, if not bigger. As he matures physically he very well could add 15 lbs of muscle without the extended effort that would be required of someone like EBJ to add the same amount. But just as you point that JH's incentive to improve as a SS is the payday, Gunnar has that same incentive and he's already night and day better as a defender than JH and was two years ago at the same age as JH. 
    • Exactly right. Like all young players, I’m sure he has some things to “clean up” but he the question mark about his defense isn’t range or hands or anything like that..it’s his arm.  He needs to improve the arm strength and get the velo on the throws up.    I personally don’t think he would be the #1 prospect if people doubted he could be a ML SS. 
    • Defense doesn't peak at age 19.  Also, who is reporting that he needs to improve "significantly" on defense? He wouldn't be the #1 overall prospect if that was the case. 
    • Juan Pierre is another name that I keep thinking of as far as light hitting speedster CF's making solid WAR contribution without much power. 17 WAR, .295/.343/.704
    • Show me the national people who believe he will never be a long term answer at SS.  
    • It might be. It’s always possible. Defense is largely about effort in many ways. You have to work at it and want to work at it.  If he doesn’t do that, this is who he will be. If he does work at it, he will get better. Im sure he understands that the arm is currently lacking. Im sure his father can see it and it’s something they worked on and will continue to work on. He has the foundation outside of that to be really good, according to basically everyone. His incentive is that the payday will be larger long term as a SS than a second baseman.  So, it’s up to him on whether he wants to get better or not. A few years ago, most didn’t believe Gunnar could be a SS. Those people were proven to be incorrect in short time. I’m guessing that Gunnar worked hard at it and wanted to become better.    My personal assumption about Holliday is that he will want to work hard to get better. That may be a wrong assumption but it is my belief.
  • Popular Contributors

  • Popular Now

×
×
  • Create New...