Jump to content

Austin Hays called up, Ryan Mountcastle not called up


MurphDogg

Recommended Posts

10 hours ago, makoman said:

Maybe, but the players aren’t exactly known for fighting for the rights of those who aren’t in the union yet. Everyone in the union is already past the service time game. 

If by "aren't exactly know for.." you really mean "completely willing to trade away others' rights for their gain" I'd be a little more on board with your statement.

Both sides have at least hinted around that the service time stuff is a problem for a while, so maybe they'll do something.  But what's the fix?  I like making everyone a free agent at 28, but I doubt that has any traction.  Maybe you become a free agent seven years after you're drafted/signed, eight for high schoolers?  I don't know what might be deemed acceptable.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

29 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

If by "aren't exactly know for.." you really mean "completely willing to trade away others' rights for their gain" I'd be a little more on board with your statement.

Both sides have at least hinted around that the service time stuff is a problem for a while, so maybe they'll do something.  But what's the fix?  I like making everyone a free agent at 28, but I doubt that has any traction.  Maybe you become a free agent seven years after you're drafted/signed, eight for high schoolers?  I don't know what might be deemed acceptable.

A few random thoughts:

  1. If a player with less than a year's service time spends at least half the major league season on the big league team, they will be credited with one year of service time. Computation of service time in subsequent years will remain the same as it is today. This should eliminate a lot of the game playing.
  2. Eliminate arbitration and make all players free agents after three years of service time. If the owners want to go young, then free agency should go young.
  3. Raise the pay of minor league players who are on major league contracts to 50% of the major league minimum. Because they deserve it.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

59 minutes ago, DrungoHazewood said:

Both sides have at least hinted around that the service time stuff is a problem for a while, so maybe they'll do something.  But what's the fix?  I like making everyone a free agent at 28, but I doubt that has any traction.  Maybe you become a free agent seven years after you're drafted/signed, eight for high schoolers?  I don't know what might be deemed acceptable.

The NHL 27 or 7 for free agency is along those lines.  NHL teams only have one or two affiliates; so the long player-development process of MLB is different.  But I could see the next MLB CBA being closer to the current NHL model than the counting days of MLB's current CBA.

https://www.liveabout.com/nhl-free-agents-explained-2778995

Link to comment
Share on other sites

27 minutes ago, mdbdotcom said:

A few random thoughts:

  1. If a player with less than a year's service time spends at least half the major league season on the big league team, they will be credited with one year of service time. Computation of service time in subsequent years will remain the same as it is today. This should eliminate a lot of the game playing.
  2. Eliminate arbitration and make all players free agents after three years of service time. If the owners want to go young, then free agency should go young.
  3. Raise the pay of minor league players who are on major league contracts to 50% of the major league minimum. Because they deserve it.

There are already rules about (3).   If I recall correctly, for a team to retain a player it had the year before but keep him in the minors, they have to pay him 60% of what he earned the previous season.    

Link to comment
Share on other sites

50 minutes ago, Frobby said:

There are already rules about (3).   If I recall correctly, for a team to retain a player it had the year before but keep him in the minors, they have to pay him 60% of what he earned the previous season.    

According to this article posted in March 2018:

  • Quote

     

    • Players signing their first major league the annual minor league salary is $44,500.
    • Players signing their second major league contract the annual minor who have at least one day of major league time gets an annual salary of $88,900.

     

    Unless that has changed, your statement is incorrect.

  •  
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Just now, Frobby said:

This is for players who are on the 40-man roster but have not spent time in the majors.    I’m talking about players who have spent time  on the major league roster.    

And I was talking about players who haven't. They deserve to make more money.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.




  • Posts

    • Of course I’ll be watching. Filled with dread in all likelihood. As will most of us.  LOL. 
    • Very interesting to read through this. Full of optimism…those were good times. Turns out I voted 91-94. Such pessimism…grrr…and even that was too little. Several of the posters should run out and buy lottery tickets because they are definitely prescient.
    • During all the hullabaloo about the team floundering, way too little was said about fundamental baseball judgement and defense. In a game a couple days ago, a guy came up to bat with runners on. This guy is all speed and defense, with no power, and bunted for a single. The radio guys pointed out that with a bunt threat at the plate, the defense moves in to anticipate the bunt, but this wasn’t done. He barely beat out the throw. Even two steps in from the defense would have been the difference. Little flubs like that happen CONSTANTLY, and don’t count as errors, but good teams avoid them without even thinking. The OF collision two days ago. Why did that happen? It shouldn’t have, and wouldn’t have with a good team, yet we’ve had at least three, two of which resulted in serious injury. Westburg and Urias are both solid players with solid fundamentals. Even if they don’t blaze away at the plate, they haven’t forgotten their defense, and we can hope that will be enough to get us to 90 wins.
    • The Boys are back and you're going to be in trouble.  Hey-la Hey-la. The Boys are back.
    • I was just reading my unread posts in the thread, and didn’t notice that your post was a week old.   And I don’t consider that I called you out.  The post sort of read like the outcome of the playoffs was so certain that there was no point in watching, so I was ribbing you about it.  Nothing personal intended. I have a feeling you’ll be watching!   
    • I was expecting Boston to be last and NY to be fourth…I never expected the Jays to be as bad as they’ve been, and the Rays are always good.
    • Fewer than 3% of our posters thought the O’s would win under 90 games this year.  They can still win 90, but it will take a 4-3 finish or better to do it.    
  • Popular Contributors

×
×
  • Create New...